Organ donation issue surfaces after St. George death


The wishes of a Utah woman to donate her organs before she killed herself outside a St. George hospital Friday might have gone unfulfilled.

Saving solid organs, such as hearts and livers, from someone after a traumatic death is rare, local officials said. But some tissues, such as bone marrow and retinas, can be saved up to 24 hours after death.

Spokesmen for the St. George Police Department and the Dixie Regional Medical Center did not know Friday night whether the 57-year-old woman's organs could be saved. But it was clearly the intent of the woman, whose name has not been released, to donate them.

Police said she called St. George police at 11:39 a.m. local time claiming she was in the parking lot near the entrance to the hospital and wanted to donate her organs. Dispatchers then heard a gunshot, followed by silence.

When doctors from the hospital arrived, they found she had suffered a gunshot wound to the head. They rushed her to the emergency room and tried to save her but were unsuccessful.

The incident echoed the March 2009 death of Charles Bradley Campbell, who walked into the emergency room of St. Rose Dominican Hospital, Siena campus, in Henderson also expressing a wish to donate his organs. He was brandishing a gun and was eventually shot and killed by Henderson police when he pointed it at officers.

Clark County Coroner Mike Murphy couldn't recall Friday whether Campbell's organs were able to be donated, but officials shied from endorsing suicide as a way to intentionally donate organs.

"That is something that we would absolutely not endorse in any way, shape or form," said Ken Richardson, executive director of the Nevada Donor Network, which handles organ donations in Southern Nevada.

In most cases, the efforts probably would not be successful anyway.

The circumstances required to save organs are so rare that of the 2.5 million deaths in America each year, only 10,000 to 12,000 people -- less than half a percent -- are able to become donors, Richardson said.

In Las Vegas, there are usually only 50 to 60 deaths per year in which solid organs can be saved, according to Richardson. For tissues, the number is between 200 and 300.

Rarely do people become donors within minutes of entering a hospital. The most common situation is when a patient suffered some sort of head trauma, is rendered brain-dead and the family has chosen to take them off life-support machines, Murphy said.

If the person was one of the 40 percent of Nevadans who elected to become an organ donor, typically marked on the person's driver's license, then doctors and donation officials can begin doing tests to see which organs would be eligible for donation.

If the person did not choose to be an organ donor, the person's family can make that decision -- about three-quarters of families choose donation, according to Richardson. Many of them find comfort in the fact that their loved one's death helped someone else, he said.

Solid organs such as lungs, livers, kidneys and hearts have to be removed within moments and transplanted typically within six and 36 hours, depending on the organ, Richardson said. Tissues such as retinas, skin, bone marrow and heart valves can be removed within 24 hours after death and can sometimes be stored for years.

For traumatic deaths such as shootings, medical examiners with the coroner's office have to weigh the needs of the autopsy and any potential criminal prosecution with the needs of the organ donation.

"We work very hard to make sure those two don't conflict," Murphy said, adding that his office has a team that works with doctors and donor officials to make those decisions.

Contact reporter Lawrence Mower at lmower@reviewjournal.com or 702-383-0440.

 

Rules for posting comments

Comments posted below are from readers. In no way do they represent the view of Stephens Media LLC or this newspaper. This is a public forum. Read our guidelines for posting. If you believe that a commenter has not followed these guidelines, please click the FLAG icon next to the comment.