Review-Journal LogoDonrey
Monday, Feburary 03, 1997

Reckoning in France


     Half a century after the United States and her allies liberated France from Nazi rule, the French people may finally be forced to come to grips with their shameful past.
      It was only in 1995 -- and after decades of official silence and denial -- that French President Jaques Chirac acknowledged his country's role in sending Jews to German death camps during the war.
      Now a Paris court has cleared the way for the war crimes trial of Maurice Papon, who served as a police official in the pro-Nazi Vichy regime and as France's budget minister in the 1970s. Mr. Papon stands accused of expediting the deportation of 1,560 people to the Auschwitiz death camp between 1942 and 1944.
      Vichy was the puppet state created out of Southern France after the French armed forces rolled over and played dead, allowing Hitler to usurp the rest of the country in 1940.
      The people of Vichy adored its pro-Nazi ruler, Marshal Petain, who emerged as the most popular French leader since Napoleon. Writes historian Paul Johnson of Petain's reign: "He was treated like royalty. Peasants lined the rails along which his train passed. Women held out their babies for him to touch." Indeed, French Catholic Cardinal Gerlier proclaimed: "France is Petain, and Petain is France."
      Under Petain's Vichy government, France became the most dangerous place in western Europe for Jews. (Ironically, fascist Italy was probably the safest place for Jews because the Italian people -- while aligned with Nazi Germany -- largely ignored German orders to round up and deport their Jewish countrymen.)
Next Column


      With the gleeful cooperation of the anti-Semitic Vichy government, tens of thousands of French Jews were shipped off to Nazi gas chambers and slave-labor camps. Writes Mr. Johnson: "Vichy, in effect, took an eager part in hustling foreign-born Jews into the death camps; and its claim that it protected its own Jews was false, since of some 76,000 Jews handed over by France to the Nazis (of whom less than 2,000 survived), a third were French by birth. Those murdered included 2,000 under (age) six and 6,000 under thirteen."
      Post-war Hollywood movies tended to portray the French as a brave but oppressed people, escaping abroad to struggle alongside Charles DeGaulle and his Free French forces or joining the French Resistance to battle the Nazis on French soil. But the fact is that, of the 700,000 men in the French army, only 35,000 followed Charles DeGaulle and his Free French into exile. Only about 170,000 Frenchmen worked in the Resistance -- a tiny fraction of the population -- and many of them were communists who used the opportunity to murder their anti-communist rivals. Many Frenchmen, not least those in the Vichy government, embraced the Nazis and all they stood for.
      Perhaps when Mr. Papon goes to trial, the attendant publicity will force the French to face this ugly reality.
Agree or disagree?
Write us at
letters@lvrj.com

[News] [Sports] [Business] [Lifestyles] [Neon] [Opinion] [in-depth]
[Classifieds] [Help/About] [Home] [Archive] [Current Edition]

[an error occurred while processing this directive]