Some question green investment as clean-energy summit nears

Ten thousand.

That’s the number of green jobs Las Vegas had in 2010, according to a July report from the Brookings Institution. That jobs base accounts for 1.2 percent of the city’s jobs base, roughly equal to the number of Las Vegans employed by taxi and limousine businesses. From 2003 to 2010, the green economy in Las Vegas added 3,125 jobs — a little more than half of the jobs created when The Cosmopolitan of Las Vegas was brought to life in December.

What’s more, a March report from the Council of State Governments found that federal stimulus funds created or saved just 310 green jobs in Nevada in the fourth quarter, up from 95 created or saved in the first quarter of 2009, when the federal government began distributing recovery money. (The report didn’t list funding amounts.)

That’s a disappointing track record for a state that Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., has called the Saudi Arabia of solar and geothermal energy, say free-market groups.

"We’ve been talking about how renewable energy would be the job creator of the future since the 1970s, and the sector has consistently failed to deliver despite massive subsidies," said Geoffrey Lawrence, deputy director of policy at the Nevada Policy Research Institute, a libertarian think tank in Las Vegas. "It’s time to re-evaluate those promises."

Green-economy advocates counter that building the green sector is a long-term project that didn’t begin in earnest until the Obama administration took office in 2009, and it’s unfair to call it a failure so early in its development. That would be like saying the U.S. space program hadn’t lived up to its promise in 1963, noted Joe Romm, a senior fellow with the Center for American Progress Action Fund in Washington D.C.

Reid defended the sector’s economic track record Thursday.

"Despite the predictable opposition from naysayers, strategic investments in clean-energy job creation have a strong track record in Nevada, and remain key to getting people across the state back to work," Reid said in a statement. "Now is not the time to reduce our commitment to creating good-paying clean-energy jobs. We should be building new partnerships and encouraging friendly competition between states, regions and countries to promote innovation and breaking down 20th century barriers blocking clean-energy development."

Reid and the Center for American Progress will co-sponsor the National Clean Energy Summit at Aria on Tuesday to discuss federal policies to jump-start growth and job formation in the green-energy sector. Policymakers including Vice President Joe Biden, Nevada Gov. Brian Sandoval and U.S. Energy Secretary Steven Chu are scheduled to participate. It’s the fourth-annual summit, and it’s worth asking: Has all the talk about green jobs paid off in worthwhile investments?

It’s tough to say.


Agencies and advocacy groups count green jobs differently, so databases don’t show consistent numbers. For example, the BlueGreen Alliance, a Washington, D.C.-based coalition of labor unions and environmentalists, says the Obama administration has spent $93 billion saving or creating 1 million green jobs nationwide, at $93,000 per job, while a November report in The Washington Post pegged federal investment at $90 billion to save or create 225,000 green-energy jobs, or $400,000 per job.

Forget finding a straight answer on state or local jobs., the clearinghouse for details on stimulus spending, reports $2.2 billion in funds awarded and $1.3 billion actually distributed to Nevada governments and businesses between February 2009 and June, with 2,297 jobs created in the second quarter. But the site doesn’t separate out green jobs or say how many of those positions already existed.

Specific projects do show big-dollar investments, though.

Sempra Energy’s 48-megawatt Copper Mountain Solar plant near Boulder City consumed nearly $55 million in federal and state tax credits and incentives to create five permanent jobs. Enel Green Power got $61.5 million in stimulus funds for its 25-employee Stillwater and Salt Wells geothermal projects in Fallon. And a $490,000 grant to the Clark County Urban Forestry Revitalization Project, which plants trees in economically distressed neighborhoods, created 1.7 permanent jobs.

Not all green investments have been budget busters: Amonix built a solar-panel factory in North Las Vegas with $5.9 million in federal tax credits, and now employs more than 300 there.

Still, Reid’s office says the U.S. Department of Energy has spent more than $440 million in the last 2½ years on 80 Nevada projects, including solar-panel factories, geothermal plants, energy-efficiency grants, home weatherization and smart-grid infrastructure.

And yet Nevada still has the nation’s highest unemployment rate, noted Myron Ebell, director of the Center for Energy and Environment at the Competitive Enterprise Institute, a free-market group in Washington, D.C.

Observers say the green economy faces a stiff headwind.

Robert Boehm, director of the Energy Research Center at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, blames the general economy. It’s tough to rustle up funding for just about any project during a recession. Plus, California, Arizona and New Mexico are "formidable competitors" for green-energy manufacturing, and that’s hurt the industry here, he said.

Daniel J. Weiss, a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress, said Nevada’s leaders want to build a vertically integrated clean economy, starting with research and development and continuing through manufacturing, development and export. That takes time.

"It will be a clean-energy evolution, not a clean-energy revolution," he said. "It’s not going to happen overnight."

Lawrence sees a more basic obstacle to green development: Fossil fuels are cheaper than renewables.

"The technology has never really been there for green energy to compete on a competitive basis," he said. "I think policymakers have placed a lot of faith in technologies that haven’t kept pace the way they wanted."


Clean-energy advocates say bringing the green economy up to speed will take effort — and more money. Others say it’s time to pull the plug on huge renewable-power subsidies sparked by wishful thinking.

Nevada already has an aggressive requirement that NV Energy get 25 percent of its electricity from renewables by 2025. It now gets nearly 15 percent from renewables and conservation. Weiss called the standard key to creating markets for renewables.

Making renewable tax credits permanent would also help, Weiss said. Countless renewable developments have had trouble with funding because they rely on tax credits, grants and loan guarantees that could expire by the end of 2011. Investors are cautious about buying into projects that may not come to fruition. Eliminating expiration dates would lure private investment, Weiss said.

Finally, the nation needs to invest in smart-grid infrastructure to transmit renewables, Weiss said. In Nevada, one such project is under way. NV Energy’s 235-mile, 500-kilovolt One Nevada transmission line (ON Line) will carry geothermal power from north to south when completed in 2013. The utility is developing the project with New York energy developer LS Power. LS received $363 million in Energy Department loan guarantees for its share of the $510 million project; NV Energy is paying for its 25 percent with equity and debt.

Boehm suggested guaranteeing higher power rates for renewable developers, a strategy that dramatically boosted clean energy in Germany and Spain.

But Lawrence, whose group argues against federal subsidies and favors for any industry, countered that those tactics merely drag down the rest of the economy by diverting capital toward an industry for which there’s not genuine demand. In that sense, spending on green energy actually kills jobs in every other industry, as providers of goods and services raise prices to cover higher power costs and reduce demand for their products as a result.

An April 2009 report in The Economist magazine said every green job created with government subsidies kills more than two jobs outside the sector.

"We’re talking about price-fixing and things like that, which really punish the consumer in the end," Lawrence said. "They’re the ones paying those higher prices. They won’t be able to afford other things, like food on the table or a roof over their head. There are always trade-offs. It’s time for policymakers to stop forcing it. Green energy does have a future, but it’s going to have to be able to compete on the market at some point. I think we have to allow the technology to develop until that happens."

Contact reporter Jennifer Robison at or 702-380-4512.

Happie Home Startup Establishing Headquarters In Las Vegas
Digital companion startup company Happie Home is establishing its headquarters in Las Vegas after receiving tax abatements from the Governor's Office of Economic Development on Nov. 15. (Bailey Schulz/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
A Facebook-branded space inside of Macy’s at the Fashion Show shopping center
A Facebook-branded space inside of Macy’s at the Fashion Show shopping center will showcase 13 small businesses in November and December and seven in January. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
T-Mobile uses ticketing data to plan for event
T-Mobile Executive Director of Arena Operations explains how ticket sales data and demographics help plan staffing, vendors, parking and operations for an event.
Costco opens its doors in southwest Henderson
Costco has opened its fifth Las Vegas-area location near the intersection of St. Rose Parkway and Amigo Street. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Las Vegas strip mall and office park
The Krausz Cos. and WG Group bought a strip mall and an office park in Las Vegas for nearly $80 million total. They acquired a portion of Tropicana Beltway Center in the southwest valley for $59 million. They also acquired the Westbay office complex in the Las Vegas Medical District. The buyers are former owners of The Gramercy, a once-mothballed mixed-use project in the Las Vegas suburbs. They sold The Gramercy in phases for more than $100 million.
Mario Barth talks about the growth of the tattoo industry
Celebrity tattoo artist and business owner Mario Barth talks about the growth of the tattoo industry at The World of Tattoo industry trade show at Planet Hollywood in Las Vegas
$7.5M Las Vegas pot dispensary opens near Las Vegas Strip
Planet 13, which bills itself as one of the largest dispensaries in the world, opened to the public Thursday. It has entertainment including an interactive floor and floating orbs. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Caesars CEO to step down next year
Caesars Entertainment Corp. CEO Mark Frissora will leave the casino company in February. Frissora has been CEO since July 2015. He was named CEO right after Caesars' operating company filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection Caesars Entertainment emerged from bankruptcy protection in October 2017 Before Caesars, Frissora spent seven years as chairman and CEO of Naples, Fla.,-based Hertz He led the consolidation of the rental-car industry through Hertz‘s acquisition of the Dollar Thrifty Automotive Group.
Planet 13 in Las Vegas adds twist to marijuana dispensary look
Planet 13, which bills itself as one of the largest dispensaries in the world, opened to the public Thursday. The dispensary is located near the intersection of Desert Inn Road and Sammy Davis Jr. Drive, near Trump International, in Las Vegas. Planet 13 has plans in the future for a coffee shop, a tasting room for marijuana-infused beer and wine, a lounge for consuming marijuana on site if that is legalized and space for food.
Caesars Entertainment opening 2 resorts in Dubai
Cove Beach will open on Meraas’ Bluewaters Island in Dubai in November and Caesars Palace Bluewaters Dubai and The Residences at Caesars Palace Bluewaters Dubai will open in December. (Caesars Entertainment)
Bellagio, MGM Resorts International’s luxury hotel turns 20
The more than 3,000-room Bellagio hotel is situated on the site of the former Dunes Hotel. The Dunes was imploded in 1993, and construction of the Bellagio started in 1996. It cost $1.6 billion to build, making it the most expensive hotel in the world at the time. The Bellagio was former Wynn Resorts Ltd. Chairman and CEO Steve Wynn’s second major casino on the Strip after The Mirage. MGM Resorts International acquired the property from Steve Wynn in 2000. (Tara Mack/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Facial recognition software at G2E – Todd Prince
Shing Tao, CEO of Las Vegas-based Remark Holdings, talks about his facial recognition product. (Todd Prince/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Former NBA player, Shaquille O'Neal, speaks about his new Las Vegas chicken restaurant
Former NBA player, Shaquille O'Neal, speaks about his new Las Vegas chicken restaurant. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
Bobby Baldwin to leave MGM
MGM Resorts International executive and professional poker player Bobby Baldwin is set to leave MGM.
Caesars has new armed emergency response teams
Caesars Entertainment Corp. has created armed emergency response teams. They are composed of former military and law enforcement officials. "These teams provide valuable additional security capabilities,” Caesars spokeswoman Jennifer Forkish said. Caesars is hiring Security Saturation Team supervisors, managers and officers, according to LinkedIn. The company did not say how many people it plans to hire for the units. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Las Vegas, airlines prepare for CES
CES in January is expected to attract more than 180,000 attendees. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
AGS partners with Vegas Golden Knights
AGS is the nation’s second-largest manufacturer of Class II slot machines used primarily in tribal jurisdictions. It announced a marketing partnership with the Vegas Golden Knights NHL team. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Lehman Brothers bet big on Las Vegas
Lehman Brothers collapsed 10 years ago, helping send the country into the Great Recession.
Fremont9 opens downtown
Fremont9 apartment complex has opened in downtown Las Vegas. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @marcusvillagran
Ross & Snow launches in Las Vegas
Luxury shoe brand Ross & Snow has opened in Las Vegas, featuring "functional luxury" with premium shearling footwear. (Bailey Schulz/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Remote Identification and Drones
DJI vice president of policy and public affairs discusses using remote identification on drones. (Bailey Schulz/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Drones and public safety in Nevada
Two representatives in the drone industry discuss UAV's impact on public safety. (Bailey Schulz/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Frontier Airlines to launch flights from Las Vegas to Mexico
Frontier, a Denver-based ultra-low-cost carrier, will become the first airline in more than a decade to offer international service to Canada and Mexico from Las Vegas when flights to Cancun and Los Cabos begin Dec. 15. (Rick Velotta/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
MGM Resorts International CEO Jim Murren addresses Oct. 1 lawsuits
MGM Resorts International Chairman and CEO Jim Murren addresses criticism his company has received for filing a lawsuit against the survivors of the Oct. 1 shooting. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
MGM Resorts International opens the doors on MGM Springfield
Massachusetts’ first hotel-casino opens in downtown Springfield. The $960 million MGM Springfield has 252 rooms and 125,000-square-feet of casino. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
MGM Resorts International prepares to open MGM Springfield
Las Vegas-based MGM Resorts International gave news media and invited guests a preview of the $960 million MGM Springfield casino in Massachusetts. The commonwealth's first resort casino will open Friday, Aug. 24. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
A Walk Through Circus Circus
It only takes a short walk through Circus Circus to realize it attracts a demographic like no other casino on the Strip: families with young children. (Todd Prince/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Morphy Auctions, a vintage slot machines seller, wants gaming license
Vice president Don Grimmer talks about Morphy Auctions at the company's warehouse located at 4520 Arville Street in Las Vegas on Thursday, Aug. 16, 2018. (Rick Velotta/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
News Headlines
Add Event
Home Front Page Footer Listing
You May Like

You May Like