Nevada Health CO-OP, now defunct, still causing headaches

The Nevada Health CO-OP went into receivership last fall, but the insurer created by the Affordable Care Act has still managed to fatten its bottom line.

The defunct health insurer’s cash on hand has more than tripled, from $5.4 million in early October to $17.3 million at the start of March, the most recent monthly number available. The gain came even as revenue from premiums and federal subsidies all but vanished following its closure five months ago.

Bob and Linda Ljungquist of Las Vegas may be able to explain the unusual financial results: The CO-OP has simply stopped paying its bills.

It’s normal for a bankrupt organization to halt accounts payable to creditors while in court. But in this case, creditors include doctors, hospitals and health clinics, and has helped squeeze patients such as the Ljungquists.

The former CO-OP enrollees have unpaid medical invoices dating to September. Now — in direct violation of a court order — doctors are chasing the couple for what the insurer owes.

“It was stressful, because my wife wasn’t in good shape at that point,” Bob Ljungquist said. “You just have to figure out what’s going on and make the best out of it.”

The CO-OP’s receiver, the Nevada Division of Insurance, wouldn’t grant an interview for this story, so it’s unclear how many of the nonprofit’s members are in the same bind.

But it’s unlikely the Ljungquists are suffering alone: At peak enrollment, the nonprofit insurer created in 2012 by the Affordable Care Act to inject competition into the state’s individual insurance market had more than 20,000 enrollees. Clark County District Court documents show the CO-OP hasn’t paid a single claim since at least October. It ceased operations Dec. 31, citing high claims costs and slower-than-expected membership growth. Enrollees were able to find 2016 coverage through the state’s Nevada Health Link marketplace, but that’s little help to members with unpaid medical bills or deferred care from 2015.


It wasn’t supposed to be this way for the Ljungquists.

When the Nevada Division of Insurance took receivership of the CO-OP in the fall, District Court Judge Kenneth Cory in an Oct. 14 injunction barred all CO-OP-contracted medical providers from trying to collect from patients fees the insurer owes doctors and hospitals. The order also prohibits providers from “interrupting or discontinuing” health care for enrollees whose premiums are current, or from “interfering in any way with the efforts of the receiver to assure that (the) co-op’s members and enrollees in good standing receive the health care services to which they are contractually entitled.”

Some providers never got that memo.

The Ljungquists’ insurance troubles began in August, when the CO-OP stopped sending explanations of benefits, which detail care received and how much the insurer will pay. The CO-OP announced later that month it would close at the end of 2015.

“As soon as they said they weren’t going to last past the year, I made the assumption it wasn’t going to be pretty,” Bob Ljungquist said. “That’s when we started calling, telling them we never got our (explanations of benefits), and asking them if our doctors had sent in their paperwork. They said, ‘Yes, they have — we’re just a little behind, but we’re getting caught up.’”

In September, Linda Ljungquist had surgeries for a torn rotator cuff and problem veins.

Again, no explanations of benefits followed. Nor did reimbursements to surgeons for the procedures.

By November, doctors — including an anesthesiologist, a family doctor and a neurologist — were canceling Linda’s appointments or asking for cash up front — also a violation of the Oct. 14 receivership order. A surgery scheduled in December was pushed into 2016, after the couple would have new coverage.

Then, collection notices began. The amounts weren’t huge, but Bob Ljungquist said he was frustrated they were happening at all, and it would take him weeks of his own accounting to figure out what was happening.

In February, Mountain View Hospital said the couple owed about $200 out of pocket for Linda’s pulmonary function test. Then came a $600 demand from Bronstein Hand Center.

Once the Ljungquists reminded Mountain View of the court order, the hospital backed off quickly.

Dealing with Bronstein hasn’t been so easy.

The clinic, whose managers didn’t return phone calls or emails requesting comment, agreed to cut the bill to $291.62, but the practice is still going after the Ljungquists, sending a final notice before collection action in April. Bob Ljungquist said attorneys with the CO-OP’s receivership “reached out to Bronstein once,” with no results, and have “implied they’re going to be more forceful” with the clinic going forward.

But with more than $17 million in cash on hand as of March, why didn’t the CO-OP’s receivership just pay the claims?

A state Division of Insurance spokeswoman cited the CO-OP’s “dire financial straits,” as well as missed federal funding the CO-OP said it needed to make provider payments.

“The special deputy receiver continues to make vigorous efforts to resolve this challenge but cannot comment publicly about those efforts,” she said in a statement.

Division officials did not respond to multiple requests for additional comment, including why the organization’s cash on hand soared as premiums and federal money dried up; what the receivership is doing to enforce the court order banning collections against patients; how many providers are short their reimbursements; how many patients are affected; or even what those patients should do if a doctor begins collections.


To be sure, the CO-OP is a victim of an unexpected cut in federal money designed to keep it solvent.

The Affordable Care Act created a “risk-corridor” program designed to help insurers cover higher-than-expected claims payouts if large numbers of sick patients enrolled. The problem? Insurers requested about eight times more risk-corridor payments than they contributed to fund the program. So the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, which is administering the law, slashed risk-corridor payouts. It will need Congress to approve more funding in 2016 to make good on the rest.

The bottom line: Nevada Health CO-OP got just $1.15 million of the $20 million it expected in the fourth quarter.

The receivership also noted in court filings that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services stopped paying premium and cost-sharing subsidies to cover the difference between the insurer’s charges and what its members could afford.

But the federal agency, which did not respond when asked about the cut, isn’t solely responsible for the ongoing financial problem.

The change in funding wasn’t announced until Oct. 1 — two months after the CO-OP said it would close. And when the CO-OP announced its shuttering, it blamed high claims costs and sluggish enrollment, saying nothing about federal funding.

Receivership reports and IRS filings show the CO-OP helped create its own money problems and was profligate with startup dollars.

Obamacare regulates medical-loss ratios, or the share of premium income that insurers must spend on medical benefits. For individual insurance plans, at least 80 percent of premium revenue must go to benefits, while expenses such as administrative overhead and profit are limited to 20 percent.

The receivership’s January status report showed the CO-OP operating on a medical-loss ratio of 148 percent and a total loss ratio of 186 percent with administrative and other costs.

The report blamed a “particularly high degree of utilization of vendor services,” or outsourcing central functions to contractors whose fee schedules “were appreciably higher than industry average.” The report added that some vendor services either weren’t delivered or were provided “with many chronic problems.”

CO-OP tax returns for 2012, 2013 and 2014 all show the same top vendor: Labor union UNITE HERE, which took in nearly $5.5 million in total vendor fees, including $3.37 million in 2014 alone. The returns listed the labor group as a provider of consulting and executive and administrative services, among other functions.

UNITE HERE’s consulting work is notable because the labor organization helped start the CO-OP, which began life in 2012 as Hospitality Health CO-OP. The three sponsors that received its $65.9 million in federal startup loans were the Culinary Union’s Culinary Health fund, its parent UNITE HERE Health, and the Health Services Coalition, a consumer group with more than 300,000 members employed by cities, unions and big companies.

UNITE HERE and the Culinary also installed their officials as executives of the CO-OP. Before joining the insurer, CEO Tom Zumtobel was vice president and president of the Culinary Health Fund. Kathy Silver, the carrier’s treasurer, was the health fund’s president when the CO-OP launched.

Zumtobel, now a consultant with PPN Health Access in Reno, was paid as much as $428,000 per year as CO-OP CEO. Silver made more than $375,000.

Silver, who remains the Culinary Health Fund’s president, didn’t answer requests for comment.


Devon Herrick, a senior fellow with the anti-government-regulation think tank National Center for Policy Analysis in Dallas, said high executive salaries and consulting contracts “are a way to siphon public funds out of CO-OPs.”

Because unions administer single-employer health plans, it makes sense for a CO-OP to seek advice from labor-group colleagues, particularly when the carrier’s executives lack industry experience.

“But what most employer plans and unions do is hire an actuary,” Herrick said. “It just sounds abusive to pay the union consulting fees like that when actuarial consultants are better suited for the job of designing health plans and estimating premiums.”

CO-OP tax returns show the nonprofit hired health consultant Milliman to provide actuarial services, but the firm’s $1 million in consulting fees over three years totaled less than a fifth of UNITE HERE’s charges.

UNITE HERE also failed to deliver on some vendor services. The CO-OP borrowed the Culinary’s existing provider network, but hiccups in doubling up on doctors’ contracts with the new insurer meant massive early troubles with that network — troubles that caused some enrollees to flee CO-OP plans.


Now, the CO-OP has fresh financial emergencies: The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services in February said it would try to recoup startup loans from failed CO-OPs, though a spokesman had no update as of last week on how or when the bureau would collect from Nevada Health CO-OP.

Federal law places the loan above most other claims against the receivership, but it’s unclear if it would outrank provider reimbursements, according to a January status report.

None of that helps the Ljungquists today.

Bob Ljungquist said the answer to fixing his household’s mess is simple, even if executing it is complicated.

The agencies just need to deliver on their promises, he said.

“In my mind, it’s CMS (Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services) doing what they’re supposed to do instead of dragging things out and holding up (federal funding), and it’s the Division of Insurance cleaning up their act,” he said. “The people who are left behind are just trying to figure out what went on, and I’m sure there’ll be lawsuits coming down the road.”

Camp Broadway teaches kids how to sing and dance
The Smith Center's 7th annual Camp Broadway musical theater program gives 150 kids ranging from ages 6-17 an opportunity to learn musical theater skills from industry professionals over a five-day period. Marcus Villagran/ Las Vegas Review-Journal @brokejournalist
Watch Ruthless! at Las Vegas Little Theatre
The musical Ruthless! will be playing at Las Vegas Little Theatre from July 13-29. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
Cadaver art and sword swallowing at The Dark Arts Market
Curator Erin Emrie talks about her inspiration for The Dark Arts Market at Cornish Pasty Co. in Las Vegas Tuesday, July 10, 2018. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
'NO H8' Campaign comes to Las Vegas
Hundreds of locals participate in the NO H8 campaign founded by Adam Bouska and Jeff Parshley as a response to Proposition 8, a California ban on same-sex marriage. The campaign has since evolved to represent equal treatment for all. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
What to expect at Station Casinos' Fourth of July celebration
Station Casinos' is hosting its annual 4th of July celebration with Fireworks by Grucci. Fireworks scheduled to go off on Wednesday, July 4 around 9 p.m. at Green Valley Ranch Resort, Red Rock Resort, Fiesta Rancho and Texas Station. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
Star Wars and Golden Knights mashup at downtown art shop
Star Wars and Vegas Golden Knights fans attend the Boba Fett Golden Knight Paint Class at The Bubblegum Gallery in Las Vegas, Friday, June 29, 2018. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
Tourists and locals enjoy Independence Day fireworks at Caesars Palace
Hundreds of tourists and locals gaze at the Independence Day fireworks show at Caesars Palace on Saturday, June 30, 2018. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
Clark County recount votes in commission’s District E primary
Clark County staff begin the recount requested by candidate Marco Hernandez in the democratic primary for the County Commission's District E seat on Tuesday, June 26, 2018. (Marcus Villagran/Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
Long-running local hip hop producer wants Vegas rappers to shine
Las Vegas Hip Hop producer and co-owner of Digital Insight Recording Studios Tiger Stylz reflects on 30 years of music production in the city. (Marcus Villagran/Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
"Pawn Stars" fans visit Richard Harrison's memorial at Gold & Silver Pawn
"Pawn Stars" fans from around the world visit the Gold & Silver Pawn Shop in Las Vegas following the passing of Richard "Old Man" Harrison on Monday, June 25, 2018. (Marcus Villagran/Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
Construction for new 51s ballpark underway
New home of the Las Vegas 51s is planned to be finished by March 2019 in Summerlin according to team president Don Logan. (Marcus Villagran/Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
Underground home was built as Cold War-era hideaway
The underground house at 3970 Spencer Street is one of the valley’s most unusual homes built 26 feet underground in 1978 by Girard “Jerry” B. Henderson, who, planned to survive the end of the world there.
Lip Smacking Foodie Tours takes you where the locals go
Donald Contursi talks about Lip Smacking Foodie Tours, which offers walking tours of restaurants on and off Las Vegas Boulevard with food samples and tidbits of history about the places they visit.
Bump stock manufacturers under fire
The Justice Department said last month that it had started the process to amend federal firearms regulations to clarify that federal law defines bump stocks as machine guns.
Art Bell’s Top 10 Shows
A selection of radio host Art Bell’s most popular shows.
Caesars Forum Meeting Center
Caesars broke ground Monday on its $375 million Caesars Forum Meeting Center (convention center) just east of the High Roller observation wheel. (Caesars Entertainment)
Technology reshapes the pawn shop industry
Devin Battersby attaches a black-colored device to the back of her iPhone and snaps several of the inside and outside of a Louis Vuitton wallet. The device, installed with artificial intelligence capabilities, analyzes the images using a patented microscopic technology. Within a few minutes, Battersby receives an answer on her app. The designer item is authentic.
Recreational marijuana has been legal in Nevada for one year
Exhale Nevada CEO Pete Findley talks about the one year anniversary of the legalization of recreational marijuana in Nevada. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Young adults aren't saving for retirement
Financial advisors talk about saving trends among young adults. (Bailey Schulz/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
President Trump’s tariffs could raise costs for real estate developers, analysts say
President Donald Trump made his fortune in real estate, but by slapping tariffs on imports from close allies, developers in Las Vegas and other cities could get hit hard.
Las Vegas business and tariffs
Barry Yost, co-owner of Precision Tube Laser, LLC, places a metal pipe into the TruLaser Tube 5000 laser cutting machine on Wednesday, June 20, 2018, in Las Vegas. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
Nevada Film Office Connects Businesses To Producers
The director of the Nevada Film Office discusses its revamped locations database and how it will affect local businesses. (Bailey Schulz/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Opendoor isn't the typical house flipping company
Unlike most house flippers, the company aims to make money from transaction costs rather than from selling homes for more than their purchase price.
The Venetian gondoliers sing Italian songs
Gondolier Marciano sings a the classic Italian song "Volare" as he leads guests through the canals of The Venetian in Las Vegas. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Building In Logandale
Texas homebuilder D.R. Horton bought 43 lots in rural Logandale. (Eli Segall/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Indoor farming in Southern Nevada
Experts discuss Nevada's indoor farming industry. (Bailey Schulz/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Former Fontainebleau could have become a Waldorf Astoria
Months after developer Steve Witkoff bought the Fontainebleau last summer, he unveiled plans to turn the mothballed hotel into a Marriott-managed resort called The Drew. But if Richard “Boz” Bosworth’s plans didn’t fall through, the north Las Vegas Strip tower could have become a Waldorf Astoria with several floors of timeshare units. (Eli Segall/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
LVCVA CEO Rossi Ralenkotter announces plans to retire
Rossi Ralenkotter, CEO of the LVCVA, on Tuesday confirmed a Las Vegas Review-Journal report that he is preparing to retire. Richard N. Velotta/ Las Vegas Review-Journal
Cousins Maine Lobster to open inside 2 Las Vegas Smith’s stores
Cousins Maine Lobster food truck company will open inside Las Vegas’ two newest Smith’s at Skye Canyon Park Drive and U.S. Highway 95, and at Warm Springs Road and Durango Drive. Cousins currently sells outside some Las Vegas Smith’s stores and at Fremont Street and Las Vegas Boulevard. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Las Vegas home prices to continue to rise, expert says
Lawrence Yun, chief economist at the National Association of Realtors, gives homebuyers a pulse on the Las Vegas housing market. (Eli Segall/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
NV Energy announces clean energy investment
The company is planning to add six solar projects in Nevada, along with the state's first major battery energy storage capacity. Bailey Schulz/Las Vegas Review-Journal
3 Mario Batali restaurants on Las Vegas Strip to close
Days after new sexual misconduct allegations were made against celebrity chef Mario Batali, his company announced Friday that it will close its three Las Vegas restaurants July 27. Employees of Carnevino Italian Steakhouse, B&B Ristorante and Otto Enoteca e Pizzeria, all located in The Venetian and Palazzo resorts, were informed of the decision Friday morning. Bastianich is scheduled to visit the restaurants Friday to speak to employees about the next two months of operation as well as how the company plans to help them transition to new positions.
Nevada has its first cybersecurity apprenticeship program
The Learning Center education company in Las Vegas has launched the first apprenticeship program for cybersecurity in Nevada. It was approved by the State Apprenticeship Council on May 15. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Las Vegas union members voting to authorize the right to strike
Thousands of Las Vegas union members voting Tuesday morning to authorize the right to strike. A “yes” vote would give the union negotiating committee the power to call a strike anytime after June 1 at the resorts that fail to reach an agreement. (Todd Prince/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Small businesses struggle to find qualified candidates
A 2018 survey found that over two-thirds of small businesses in Nevada find it somewhat to very difficult to recruit qualified candidates. Bailey Schulz/Las Vegas Review-Journal
Nevada secretary of state website offers little protection against fraudulent business filings
Property developer Andy Pham tells how control of his business was easily seized by another person using the secretary of state website.
Caesars may be going solo in its marijuana policy
Several Southern Nevada casino companies aren’t following Caesars Entertainment’s lead on marijuana testing.
How much is the Lucky Dragon worth?
Less than a year-and-a-half after it opened, the Lucky Dragon was in bankruptcy.
Gyms and discount stores take over empty retail spaces
Grocery stores used to draw people to shopping centers. But many large retail spaces have been vacant since 2008. Discount stores like goodwill and gyms like EOS Fitness are filling those empty spaces, and helping to draw shoppers back in. K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal
Funding source of Las Vegas stadium for the Raiders is sound, expert says
The stadium is funded in part by $750 million of room taxes, the biggest such tax subsidy ever for a professional sports stadium. Robert Lang, executive director of Brookings Mountain West and The Lincy Institute at UNLV, says that is a good use of public funds. (Richard Velotta/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Las Vegas needs light rail, expert says
Robert Lang, executive director of Brookings Mountain West and the Lincy Institute said he is afraid of a "congestion mobility crisis." Las Vegas needs a light rail system, he said, to accommodate the city's growing number of attractions. (Richard Velotta/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Three takeaways from Wynn Resorts' Earnings Call
Matt Maddox came out swinging in his first earnings conference call as Wynn Resorts chief executive officer, boasting of record Las Vegas quarterly revenues and applicants lining up for work.
Star Wars VR Comes to Las Vegas
Sneak peak at the new "Star Wars: Secrets of the Empire" VR experience at the Grand Canal Shoppes.
Elaine Wynn continues her fight to change Wynn Resorts board
Elaine Wynn, the largest shareholder of Wynn Resorts Ltd., is seeking to kick a friend of her ex-husband Steve Wynn off the company’s board of directors. (Todd Prince/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Zillow is getting into house flipping in Las Vegas
Las Vegas Review-Journal real estate reporter Eli Segall says flipping houses has waned in popularity after the housing bubble burst.
News Headlines
Add Event
Home Front Page Footer Listing
You May Like

You May Like