WMS lawsuit could reduce Bally’s product display at gaming expo

Timing is everything.

Still a patent infringement lawsuit between rival slot machine manufacturers is not an earth-shattering story. Much of the gambling equipment sector has spent the past decade in federal courtrooms arguing over intellectual property matters covering casino game technology.

But what’s unique about a lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court in Illinois by WMS Industries against Bally Technologies is the timing, coming just a few weeks before next month’s Global Gaming Expo in Las Vegas.

WMS claims that Bally infringed on its technology patent covering slot machines that use superimposed video images, known as transmissive technology, on its spinning reels.

Janney Montgomery Scott gaming analyst Brian McGill said the lawsuit could force Bally to remove some products it had been planning to display on its G2E trade show floor.

“In the past, WMS has not been that aggressive heading to the courts to try to enforce intellectual property,” McGill told investors, “We think it could suggest Bally is developing additional product based on transmissive technology that would potentially take share from WMS products.”

The lawsuit covers several popular Bally slot machines, analysts say, including Cash Spin, Dragon Dynasty, Twin Tigers and Sky Spirits.

Roth Capital Markets gaming analyst Todd Eilers said Bally’s Cash Spin slot machine accounts for about 1,000 games in various markets and could reach 2,000 by June. He said the game could be worth $50 million in annual lease revenue to the company and another $40 million in annual gross profit.

“The lawsuit against Bally is not surprising as Bally’s technology looks similar to WMS’ transmissive reels product,” Eilers said. “However, we are not patent experts and would highlight that Bally has done very well with regards to patent litigation over the last several years.”

Bally and slot machine giant International Game Technology have filed lawsuits and counterlawsuits against each other going back 10 years, mainly over competing spinning wheel features on different slot machines.

Jefferies & Co. gaming analyst David Katz said the lawsuit could weigh heavier on shares of Bally, which has had more of a history in patent-infringement cases.

“Although our view is that these conflicts have historically been a common occurrence, the importance of the products involved for both companies suggests that the suit is not insignificant,” Katz said.

When WMS introduced the slot machines, it was the only company using the technology.

Sterne Agee gaming analyst David Bain told investors that the lawsuit could affect other companies in the gaming equipment sector.

“While the outcome of the lawsuit may give additional clarity to the supplier industry for future technological advances, it will most likely take several years and several million dollars to resolve,” Bain told investors. “Unfortunately, we do not view a victory for either company in the near-term.”

Contact reporter Howard Stutz at hstutz@reviewjournal.com or 702-477-3871.

ad-high_impact_4
Business
Bellagio, MGM Resorts International’s luxury hotel turns 20
The more than 3,000-room Bellagio hotel is situated on the site of the former Dunes Hotel. The Dunes was imploded in 1993, and construction of the Bellagio started in 1996. It cost $1.6 billion to build, making it the most expensive hotel in the world at the time. The Bellagio was former Wynn Resorts Ltd. Chairman and CEO Steve Wynn’s second major casino on the Strip after The Mirage. MGM Resorts International acquired the property from Steve Wynn in 2000. (Tara Mack/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Facial recognition software at G2E – Todd Prince
Shing Tao, CEO of Las Vegas-based Remark Holdings, talks about his facial recognition product. (Todd Prince/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Former NBA player, Shaquille O'Neal, speaks about his new Las Vegas chicken restaurant
Former NBA player, Shaquille O'Neal, speaks about his new Las Vegas chicken restaurant. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
Bobby Baldwin to leave MGM
MGM Resorts International executive and professional poker player Bobby Baldwin is set to leave MGM.
Caesars has new armed emergency response teams
Caesars Entertainment Corp. has created armed emergency response teams. They are composed of former military and law enforcement officials. "These teams provide valuable additional security capabilities,” Caesars spokeswoman Jennifer Forkish said. Caesars is hiring Security Saturation Team supervisors, managers and officers, according to LinkedIn. The company did not say how many people it plans to hire for the units. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Las Vegas, airlines prepare for CES
CES in January is expected to attract more than 180,000 attendees. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
AGS partners with Vegas Golden Knights
AGS is the nation’s second-largest manufacturer of Class II slot machines used primarily in tribal jurisdictions. It announced a marketing partnership with the Vegas Golden Knights NHL team. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Lehman Brothers bet big on Las Vegas
Lehman Brothers collapsed 10 years ago, helping send the country into the Great Recession.
Fremont9 opens downtown
Fremont9 apartment complex has opened in downtown Las Vegas. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @marcusvillagran
Ross & Snow launches in Las Vegas
Luxury shoe brand Ross & Snow has opened in Las Vegas, featuring "functional luxury" with premium shearling footwear. (Bailey Schulz/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Remote Identification and Drones
DJI vice president of policy and public affairs discusses using remote identification on drones. (Bailey Schulz/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Drones and public safety in Nevada
Two representatives in the drone industry discuss UAV's impact on public safety. (Bailey Schulz/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Frontier Airlines to launch flights from Las Vegas to Mexico
Frontier, a Denver-based ultra-low-cost carrier, will become the first airline in more than a decade to offer international service to Canada and Mexico from Las Vegas when flights to Cancun and Los Cabos begin Dec. 15. (Rick Velotta/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
MGM Resorts International CEO Jim Murren addresses Oct. 1 lawsuits
MGM Resorts International Chairman and CEO Jim Murren addresses criticism his company has received for filing a lawsuit against the survivors of the Oct. 1 shooting. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
MGM Resorts International opens the doors on MGM Springfield
Massachusetts’ first hotel-casino opens in downtown Springfield. The $960 million MGM Springfield has 252 rooms and 125,000-square-feet of casino. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
MGM Resorts International prepares to open MGM Springfield
Las Vegas-based MGM Resorts International gave news media and invited guests a preview of the $960 million MGM Springfield casino in Massachusetts. The commonwealth's first resort casino will open Friday, Aug. 24. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
A Walk Through Circus Circus
It only takes a short walk through Circus Circus to realize it attracts a demographic like no other casino on the Strip: families with young children. (Todd Prince/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Morphy Auctions, a vintage slot machines seller, wants gaming license
Vice president Don Grimmer talks about Morphy Auctions at the company's warehouse located at 4520 Arville Street in Las Vegas on Thursday, Aug. 16, 2018. (Rick Velotta/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Nevada's venture capital money doesn't stay in state
Zach Miles, associate vice president for economic development for UNLV, said there’s venture money in Southern Nevada, “but trying to find the right groups to tap into for that money is different.” According to a 2017 report from the Kauffman Foundation, Las Vegas ranked number 34 out of 40 metropolitan areas for growth entrepreneurship, a metric of how much startups grow. With a lack of growing startups in Las Vegas, investment money is being sent outside of state borders. The southwest region of the U.S. received $386 million in funding in the second quarter, with about $25.2 million in Nevada. The San Francisco area alone received about $5.6 billion. (source: CB Insights)
Neon wraps can light up the night for advertising
Vinyl wrap company 5150 Wraps talks about neon wraps, a new technology that the company believes can boost advertising at night. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
Nevada on the forefront of drone safety
Dr. Chris Walach, senior director of Nevada Institute for Autonomous Systems, talks to a reporter at NIAS's new Nevada Drone Center for Excellence of Public Safety, located inside the Switch Innevation Center in Las Vegas. K.M. Cannon Las Vegas Review-Journal @KMCannonPhoto
TOP NEWS
News Headlines
Add Event
Home Front Page Footer Listing
Circular
You May Like

You May Like