Critics claim arbitration in medical cases limits rights

Henderson resident Sandy Runkle visited a new doctor recently and, under­standably, missed a few signatures on the voluminous intake paperwork.

But the mistake she had made that caused her the most concern was something she initially signed: A document stating that any dispute arising from her association with the doctor would be submitted to binding arbitration, which in many cases prohibits people from suing in court.

She crossed out her signature, making it clear she would not agree to binding arbitration, and said she was told she would have to find another doctor.

"People just sign these things," Runkle said. "They’re not aware they’re giving up their civil rights.

"It’s my legal right. It’s my constitutional right. It’s one of our basic rights. I don’t want it taken from me."

Runkle said she was told that the Dr. Dipak Desai case, in which thousands of Southern Nevadans had to be tested for hepatitis C and HIV because of unsanitary practices, was behind the binding arbitration push, but that claim is disputed by other doctors and insurance regulators.

And while binding arbitration agreements have become embedded in nearly every facet of consumer society, their use in medicine remains controversial.

Arbitration diverts disputes out of the courtroom and into a private process that has its merit when done fairly. Arbitration can be faster and cheaper than a lawsuit, and since it’s "binding," it usually avoids the purgatory of seemingly endless appeals.

Arbitration clauses were an issue in Southern Nevada about a decade ago when doctors increasingly turned to the agreements to stave off skyrocketing insurance premiums. Now, a wave of lawsuits has started because of the 2008 Desai case, where nine hepatitis C infections were linked to his clinics.

Runkle said she was told by Desert Gastroenterology, the practice she walked away from, that the Desai case was driving up rates and making binding arbitration clauses necessary. A representative of the practice refused to comment for this story. Desert Gastroenterology was not affiliated with Desai.

Despite the awfulness of that high-profile case, malpractice rates are not increasing overall, according to doctors and insurance regulators.

And voter-approved tort reform enacted in 2004 appears to be keeping the medical malpractice insurance market stable.

"There are a couple of malpractice insurance companies that require their doctors to do binding arbitration, or else they penalize them with higher premiums," said Jake Sunderland, spokesman for the Nevada Insurance Commission.

Sunderland said the insurance commission’s data doesn’t show a rate spike.

"Rates have been steady or even a little down over the last three years," he said. "As a whole, the market is very competitive and healthy."

But that’s the big picture, he said. An individual practice’s experience may vary.

"Maybe these doctors are exposed to more risk," he said. "Maybe they need to shop around for insurance."

Dr. Mitchell Forman, a rheumatologist and dean of the medical school at Touro University Nevada, also isn’t aware of increases.

"As far as I know, they have not," said Forman, who doesn’t use binding arbitration agreements in his practice. "They’ve been pretty stable."

He also doubted that the Desai case would be used to judge other doctors.

"This Desai case is crazy. So bizarre. So ridiculous," he said. "Everything about that case is the antithesis of good medical care."


The American Arbitration Association, the world’s largest arbitration trade organization, has studied the use of binding arbitration clauses for medical services and said they shouldn’t be a prerequisite for receiving medical care.

"Notwithstanding that, there are lots of doctors who do it, there are lots of hospitals that do it, and courts in general will enforce these," said Jean Sternlight, a law professor at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas and director of the Saltman Center for Conflict Resolution.

"They’re especially common in institutions. The bigger the institution, the more likely they are to have them."

Large entities like health maintenance organizations use binding arbitration agreements, as do the "vast majority" of nursing homes, said Paul Bland, an attorney for the public interest law firm Public Justice who frequently challenges arbitration clauses in court.

But, "they just have not caught on among doctors," he said.

"In my experience, very few individual doctors use the clauses. Most doctors feel that it would be harmful to their relationship with the patients."

Forman agreed.

"My observation and discussion with a variety of people … I would say that this, in fact, is not common," he said. "Whether it’s increasing in frequency, I have no knowledge."


Courts have generally allowed arbitration agreements to stand unless they are obviously slanted against the consumer, as the Nevada Supreme Court found in two cases with significance in the state.

Both involved home construction defects.

The court tossed out binding arbitration clauses that were in the contracts buyers signed because the clauses were buried in legalese and contained misleading language about what the clause meant and the potentially high costs of arbitration.

"They have actually been one of the courts that are the least enthusiastic about these kinds of clauses," Sternlight said, and justices "are willing to strike down arbitration clauses in some circumstances."

Bland, the Public Justice attorney, has found other courts willing to void anti-consumer binding arbitration clauses, too.

The offending clause might require the customer to travel extensively to attend the arbitration, or bear steep expenses, or be presented in such a way that it’s impossible for the customer to know what’s being agreed to.

"It happens so frequently that I win a lot of cases," Bland said.

Some states have tried to carve out exceptions.

Oklahoma wanted to ban arbitration from nursing home cases, and Georgia officials tried to prohibit arbitration requirements for malpractice claims, for example. But courts voided those efforts.

In 2009, a measure adding more disclosure and reporting requirements to Nevada’s arbitration law passed the state Legislature but was vetoed by then-Gov. Jim Gibbons. His veto was not overridden by the Senate.

As long as arbitration clauses establish a level playing field between a consumer and a business, they are likely to be upheld, said Sternlight, even in medical cases.

"If a person signs a binding arbitration agreement, they can certainly go to court and try to say the arbitration clause is void," she said. "Whether the court would accept that argument is up for grabs.

"I remain unconvinced that the court would go so far as to hold unconscionable all arbitration imposed by doctors on their patients."

Runkle said she had been a patient of Desai’s and had to get tested after the problems at his clinic were announced.

That didn’t fuel her opposition to binding arbitration, since she always had objected to its use in real estate contracts; but the fact that people were harmed at the doctor’s office reinforced it.

Runkle said she has found a doctor who doesn’t require a binding arbitration pledge but still is miffed that she had to take the extra step.

"Maybe, when push comes to shove, it won’t matter. I’m sure nothing’s going to happen," she said, saying she does not intend to file a lawsuit.

"It just reminds me of the importance of not giving up your rights in case of things you don’t even suspect could happen. You can’t be throwing away your right to a court hearing."

Contact reporter Alan Choate at or 702-477-3861.

NSPCA Gets Kittens From LA
Man killed during road-rage incident
Las Vegas police are looking for two men involved in the shooting death of a man outside a 7-Eleven story at Bonanza Road and Maryland Parkway on Nov. 12, 2018. (Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department)
VA Southern Nevada Healthcare System hosts Veterans Day Car Show and BBQ
The 4th Annual Veterans Day Car Show and BBQ is held in celebration of Veterans Day at the VA Southern Nevada Healthcare System Medical Center in North Las Vegas, Saturday, Nov. 10, 2018. (Caroline Brehman/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Wildfires in Southern California
Wildfires hit Ventura County, Calif., on Nov. 9, 2018. (Richard Brian/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Dedication of Nevada's Battle Born memorial
The state of Nevada on Friday dedicated its Battle Born memorial honoring 895 state residents who have died in America’s wars.
Las Vegas police and Sunrise Children's Hospital hope to prevent infant deaths
The Metropolitan Police Department and Sunrise Children's Hospital held a press conference to get the message out on preventable infant deaths attributed to "co-sleeping" and other unsafe sleeping habits. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
No serious injuries after car hits tree in south Las Vegas
One person reported minor injuries but wasn’t hospitalized after a Wednesday morning crash in the south valley.
Nellis Air Force Base keeps airmen fed
Nellis Air Force Bass airmen have delicious and healthy food items, and a variety of dining facilities to choose from. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Suspicious package found at central Las Vegas post office
Las Vegas police determined that a suspicious package found Monday morning at a central valley post office was not a threat.
Suspicious package found at central Las Vegas post office
Police evacuated the area around the Garside Station post office early Monday morning near Oakey and Decatur boulevards.
With husband's passing, family in limbo for workers' comp claim
Meredith Tracy's husand, Russell Tracy, died more than a year ago on his first day working for a new company when he fell 22 feet into a manhole that was not properly safeguarded. His employer was fined $82,000 in penalties for unsafe practices, but the company has denied her workers' compensation claim, leaving her with no compensation since the death. Rachel Aston Las Vegas Review-Journal @rookie__rae
With husband's passing, family in limbo for workers' comp claim
Meredith Tracy's husand, Russell Tracy, died more than a year ago on his first day working for a new company when he fell 22 feet into a manhole that was not properly safeguarded. His employer was fined $82,000 in penalties for unsafe practices, but the company has denied her workers' compensation claim, leaving her with no compensation since the death. Rachel Aston Las Vegas Review-Journal @rookie__rae
Las Vegas family shares flu warning
Carlo and Brenda Occhipinti lost their son, Carlo Jr., or “Junior,” to the flu last year.
Author Randall Cannon shares an anecdote about Stadust Raceway
Author Randall Cannon shares an anecdote about Dan Blocker, who played Hoss Cartwright on the TV show "Bonanza," and the actor's passion for auto racing at Stardust International Raceway in Las Vegas during the 1960s. (Ron Kantowski/Las Vegas Review-Journal.)
Project Neon 85 percent complete
On Wednesday morning Oct. 31, Interstate 15 northbound lane restrictions were removed opening up Exit 41 to Charleston Blvd. On Thursday Nov. 1, Interstate 15 southbound lane restrictions were removed. The new southbound off-ramp to Sahara Ave. and Highland Dr. also opened Thursday, November 1. With Project Neon 85% finished the flow of traffic on Interstate 15 has substantially diminished. (Michael Quine/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Girl killed after jumping from bridge onto 215 Beltway in Henderson
Eastbound lanes of the 215 Beltway are shut down by the Nevada Highway Patrol after a female juvenile jumped from the 215 overpass at Stephanie and was struck by a FedEx tractor trailer. Michael Quine/Las Vegas Review-Journal @Vegas88s
Kristallnacht story
An interview with 94-year-old Holocaust survivor Alexander Kuechel who survived seven concentration camps and didn’t leave Germany until after World War II was over. (Mia Sims/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
1 dead in central Las Vegas crash
An early Wednesday morning crash left at least one person dead and another injured. The crash was reported just around 3 a.m. at the intersection of Flamingo Road and Swenson Street. At least two vehicles were involved in the crash, one of which caught fire. Debris was scattered across the intersection as police combed the area as they investigated the scene. Flamingo is blocked in both directions between Swenson and Cambridge Street. Northbound Swenson is blocked at the intersection.
Richard Knoeppel named the 2018 Nevada Teacher of the Year
Richard Knoeppel, an architecture design instructor at the Advanced technologies Academy, named the 2018 Nevada Teacher of the Year on Monday, Oct. 29, 2018. (Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @bizutesfaye
Mojave Poppy Bees
(Zach Portman/University of Minnesota Department of Entomology) Male Mojave poppy bees exhibit territorial fighting behavior. The Center for Biological Diversity wants the bee, found only in Clark County, to be added to the endangered species list.
Clark County Schools announce random searches
Clark County School District middle and high school students will be subject to random searches for weapons under a new initiative to combat the wave of guns found on campus. (Amelia Pak-Harvey/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Ron Jeremy and Heidi Fleiss React to Dennis Hof's Death
Ron Jeremy and Heidi Fleiss speak about their friend and prominent brothel owner Dennis Hof's death at Dennis Hof's Love Ranch. (Benjamin Hager/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Nevada brothel owner Dennis Hof has died
Nevada brothel owner and Republican candidate for Nevada State Assembly District 36, Dennis Hof has died. He was 72. Nye County Sherriff's office confirmed. Hof owned Love Ranch brothel, located in Crystal, Nevada.
Las Vegas police investigate suspicious package at shopping center
Las Vegas police evacuated a southeast valley shopping center at Flamingo and Sandhill roads early Tuesday morning while they investigated reports of a suspicious package. (Max Michor/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
The Las Vegas Metro hosts the K-9 Trials
The Las Vegas Metro K-9 Trials returns to the Orleans Arena to benefit the Friends For Las Vegas Police K-9 group.
Kingman residents love their little town
Residents of Kingman, Ariz. talk about how they ended up living in the Route 66 town, and what they love about their quiet community. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Service at Southern Nevada Veterans Memorial Cemetery
Twelve unclaimed veterans are honored at Southern Nevada Veterans Memorial Cemetery in Boulder City in Oct. 9, 2018. (Briana Erickson/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Las Vegas house prices reach highest level in 11 years
Las Vegas house prices are rising But so is the amount of available homes on the market Still, properties priced below $300,000 are selling fast And September was the first time since June 2007 that the median house price reached the $300,000 mark Las Vegas home prices have been rising at one of the fastest rates in the country over the past year Recent data show the market is now less affordable than the national average
National Night Out
About 100 Summerlin residents gathered at Park Centre Dr. in Summerlin on Tuesday for National Night Out. Lt. Joshua Bitsko with Las Vegas Metro, played with 3-year-old David who was dressed as a police officer. Face painting, fire truck tours and more kept kids busy as parents roamed behind them. (Mia Sims/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Rural homeless issue comes to a head in Pahrump
On Sept. 12, Pahrump sheriff deputies told residents of a homeless encampment on private property that they had 15 minutes to vacate and grab their belongings. That decision might face some legal consequences. (Rachel Aston/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
3 Pahrump residents arrested on false imprisonment charges
James Thatcher, 28 of Pahrump, Chelsea Demille, 30 of Pahrump, and Sandra Wombles, 19 of Pahrump were all arrested after it was discovered that they were holding an adult female and male prisoners in their bedroom. (Nye County Sheriff's Office)
2 kids struck by gunfire in North Las Vegas shooting
On Saturday, Nov. 17, 2018, people opened fire into a residence in the 3600 block of Hamlin Place in North Las Vegas. Two kids were hit by gunfire and sent to the hospital with non-life threatening injuries, according to North Las Vegas police. Anyone with information is asked to call the NLVPD at 702-633-9111.
Man killed during road-rage incident
Las Vegas police are looking for two men involved in the shooting death of a man outside a 7-Eleven story at Bonanza Road and Maryland Parkway on Nov. 12, 2018. (Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department)
16-year-old shot in North Las Vegas
A 16-year-old was hospitalized but was expected to survive after a shooting in North Las Vegas, near Centennial Parkway and Fifth Street, on Tuesday, November 13, 2018. North Las Vegas police spokesman Aaron Patty gives an update. (Katelyn Newberg/ Las Vegas Review-Journal)
3-year-old boy shot in North Las Vegas
North Las Vegas Police Officer Aaron Patty talks about an accidental shooting that left a 3-year-old boy “fighting for his life” on Nov. 10, 2018.
Senior Citizen Carjacking Attack -- 3 Suspects Sought
Las Vegas Metropolitan Police detectives are seeking the public's assistance in identifying the three attackers who carjacked and beat a 78-year-old man near Fremont and east Charleston on Tuesday. (LVMPD)
Henderson Police Department Chief Latesha Watson Talks Change
11-year-old girl shot, killed in North Las Vegas
An 11-year-old girl is dead after she was struck by gunfire Thursday night during a shooting in North Las Vegas
North Las Vegas police on deadly shooting
North Las Vegas police spokesman Eric Leavitt briefs the media about a shooting that left an 11-year-old girl dead on Nov. 1, 2018. (Katelyn Newberg/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Stephan Bonnar DUI Arrest
Stephan Bonnar arrested for DUI in Nevada.
Family members of murder victims talk about their loss
Family members of murder victims talk about their loss. Susan Nash, 52, was killed in a shooting along with her daughter and one of her three sons on Sunday night. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
Sayegh Cold Case Turns 40
Cary Sayegh was abducted from the playground of the Albert Einstein Hebrew Day School in Las Vegas in 1978. His body has never been found. (File Photo)
Review held in death of man after encounter with Las Vegas police
The mother of Tashii Brown, who died after an encounter with Las Vegas police on the Strip, not satisfied after public review of evidence. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Vehicle of Interest in January Homicide
Las Vegas police released footage Friday of a “vehicle of interest” from a deadly shooting in January. (Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department)
Hostage escapes clutches of robber before shooting
Metropolitan Police Department footage shows a man wearing a motorcycle helmet, identified by police as 27-year-old Mario B. Trejo, with one arm wrapped around a woman’s neck and held a handgun to her head.
Sunset Park Vigil
A small group of people gathered in Sunset Park to remember the three children recently killed in the area.
Migratory Bird Day teaches adults and kids to celebrate birds
Different organizations offered activities for kids and adults to learn about birds and celebrate their migration journey at Sunset Park. (Rachel Aston/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
"Jackson: The Red Rock Canyon Burro" is a children's book about Red Rock Canyon
"Jackson: The Red Rock Canyon Burro" is a children's book about Red Rock Canyon (Janna Karel Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Interfaith Amigos speak in Las Vegas
Celebrity photographer dedicates dance book to Las Vegas shooting victims
Behind the scenes with local celebrity photographer Jerry Metellus as he talks about his Dance For Vegas coffee book dedicated to the 58 victims of the October 1 shooting. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @marcusvillagran
Dreamsickle Kids Foundation founder Gina Glass talks awareness
Gina Glass, 35, founded Dreamsickle Kids Foundation to raise awareness for sickle cell disease in Nevada. (Jessie Bekker/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
The Meadows School founding kindergarten teacher retires after 34 years at the school
Linda Verbon, founder of the The Meadows School's kindergarten program and the first faculty member hired at the school, retired in the spring after 34 years at The Meadows. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
News Headlines
Add Event
Home Front Page Footer Listing
You May Like

You May Like