Nevada Supreme Court overturns Las Vegas shooting autopsies ruling

Updated February 28, 2018 - 8:04 am

District Judge Richard Scotti violated the First Amendment when he barred the Las Vegas Review-Journal from reporting on the redacted autopsy report of an Oct. 1 shooting victim, a three-justice panel of the Nevada Supreme Court ruled Tuesday.

“While we are deeply sympathetic to the decedent’s family’s privacy concerns, the First Amendment does not permit a court to enjoin the press from reporting on a redacted autopsy report already in the public domain,” the opinion states.

The 11-page opinion, authored by Justice Kristina Pickering, comes after the Review-Journal filed an emergency petition challenging Scotti’s Feb. 9 ruling, which pertained to the autopsy report of off-duty Las Vegas police officer Charleston Hartfield, one of the 58 people killed at the Route 91 Harvest festival shooting.

Justices Mark Gibbons and James Hardesty concurred with the opinion.

“We’re grateful the Nevada Supreme Court issued such a strong defense of the First Amendment and press freedoms,” Review-Journal Managing Editor Glenn Cook said. “The quick action of the justices reflects the awfulness of Judge Scotti’s decision. His ruling was an abomination.”

In his decision, Scotti sided with widow Veronica Hartfield’s privacy concerns and ordered the Review-Journal and The Associated Press to either return or destroy any copies of Hartfield’s autopsy report.

“While nobody wants a grieving widow to be in pain, we can’t hide the truth about horrific events like 1 October, including the horrific damage that the shooter caused with the weapons he had access to,” Review-Journal attorney Maggie McLetchie said. “There is a national debate about guns right now, and what guns do to the human body is a necessary part of that debate.”

Hartfield’s report was one of 58 that a different judge ordered the Clark County coroner’s office to release in the wake of another lawsuit, which argued that the autopsies of the shooting victims should be public. That judge also ordered the coroner’s office to release the gunman’s autopsy report.

In the Supreme Court opinion, the justices assumed that Hartfield’s family “had a protectable privacy interest in preventing disclosure of Mr. Hartfield’s autopsy report.”

“Even making this assumption, the fact remains that the Review-Journal obtained the redacted autopsy reports from the Coroner before the Hartfield Parties sued,” the decision continues.

Aside from privacy rights, the widow’s attorney argued that she and other victim families should have been notified about the original lawsuit and the possible release of victim autopsies.

“Mandatory Supreme Court precedent teaches, however, that where the press obtains private information from the state — even where the state should have protected the information — damages or criminal punishment may not be imposed for its subsequent publication, absent extraordinary circumstances,” the decision states.

Scotti’s order applied only to the Review-Journal and the AP, the original parties that sued for the release of all Oct. 1 victim autopsies. Once District Judge Timothy Williams deemed the documents public record in January, about 100 other media outlets received copies of the reports, a Clark County spokesman told the Review-Journal.

“Leaving other news organizations free to report on Mr. Hartfield’s redacted autopsy report while restraining the Review-Journal and The Associated Press from doing so does not accomplish the stated goal of protecting Hartfield Parties’ privacy interests,” according to the high court’s decision.

The court concluded its ruling by instructing Scotti to vacate his order, allowing the Review-Journal and the AP to report freely on Hartfield’s report.

“The lawsuit was completely unnecessary,” Cook said. “Mr. Hartfield’s autopsy report was redacted by the coroner before it was released to the press, as was the report of every Oct. 1. victim. Their privacy was always protected.”

Contact Rachel Crosby at or 702-477-8301. Follow @rachelacrosby on Twitter.

Writ Granted by Las Vegas Review-Journal on Scribd

Downtown Summerlin hosts its annual Festival of Arts
People crowd to Downtown Summerlin for the 23rd annual Summerlin Festival of Arts in Las Vegas, Sunday, Oct. 14, 2018. (Caroline Brehman/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Clark County educators debate alternative grading systems
Spring Valley High School principal Tam Larnerd, Spring Valley High School IB coordinator Tony Gebbia and retired high school teacher Joyce O'Day discuss alternative grading systems. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @marcusvillagran
Grandparents on the fire that killed three family members
Charles and Doris Smith talk about the night an apartment fire took the lives of three of their family members. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @marcusvillagran
New York artist Bobby Jacobs donated a sculpture to the Las Vegas Healing Garden
Bobby Jacobs, an artist from upstate New York, has spent much of the past year creating a sculpture of two separate angel wings. He donated the sculpture to the Las Vegas Healing Garden. (Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @bizutesfaye
Weather will cool slightly through the end of the week
The weather will cool slightly through the end of the week., but highs are still expected to be slightly above normal for this year. (Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @bizutesfaye
Mayor announces new public-private partnership
Mayor Carolyn Goodman announced the creation of the Mayor’s Fund for Las Vegas LIFE, a public-private partnership that will allocate money to the city’s neediest.
Fremont9 opens downtown
Fremont9 apartment complex has opened in downtown Las Vegas. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @marcusvillagran
Fall fairytale gets cozy at Bellagio Conservatory
Bellagio Conservatory introduces its fall-themed garden titled "Falling Asleep." (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @marcusvillagran
What the house that Ted Binion died in looks like today
Casino heir Ted Binion died in this Las Vegas home in 1998. Current home owner Jane Popple spent over $600,000 to restore and modernize the home. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @marcusvillagran
Rescue Mission employees terminated
Don James, a former employee for the Las Vegas Rescue Mission, talks about the day his team was terminated. (Erik Verduzco/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Raiders Cupcakes at Freed's Bakery
Freed's Bakery will have Raiders-themed cupcakes available in store and for order during football season. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @marcusvillagran
51s fans say goodbye to Cashman Field
Las Vegas 51s fans said goodbye to Cashman Field in Las Vegas, Monday September, 3, 2018. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @marcusvillagran
51s owner Don Logan's last weekend at Cashman Field
Don Logan, owner of the Las Vegas 51s, gives a tour of Cashman Field before the team's final weekend using the field. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @marcusvillagran
Metro Asst. Sheriff Brett Zimmerman on Aug. 8 officer-involved shooting
Metropolitan Police Department Assistant Sheriff Brett Zimmerman met with media Monday to discuss the details of the 14th officer-involved shooting of the year. (Madelyn Reese/ Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Matt Kelly Elementary School hosted its third annual Back-to-School Red Carpet Program
Matt Kelly Elementary School hosted its third annual Back-to-School Red Carpet Program where community and business leaders joined to welcome students back with an inspirational welcome. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
Star Trek fans on show’s enduring popularity
Star Trek fans at the Star Trek Convention 2018 talk about why they think the show has stayed popular across the years Thursday, August 2, 2018. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
Family members of murder victims talk about their loss
Family members of murder victims talk about their loss. Susan Nash, 52, was killed in a shooting along with her daughter and one of her three sons on Sunday night. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
Sayegh Cold Case Turns 40
Cary Sayegh was abducted from the playground of the Albert Einstein Hebrew Day School in Las Vegas in 1978. His body has never been found. (File Photo)
Review held in death of man after encounter with Las Vegas police
The mother of Tashii Brown, who died after an encounter with Las Vegas police on the Strip, not satisfied after public review of evidence. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Vehicle of Interest in January Homicide
Las Vegas police released footage Friday of a “vehicle of interest” from a deadly shooting in January. (Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department)
Hostage escapes clutches of robber before shooting
Metropolitan Police Department footage shows a man wearing a motorcycle helmet, identified by police as 27-year-old Mario B. Trejo, with one arm wrapped around a woman’s neck and held a handgun to her head.
Sunset Park Vigil
A small group of people gathered in Sunset Park to remember the three children recently killed in the area.
Henderson police bodycam footage of officer-involved shooting
Henderson police released body-worn camera footage of an officer-involved shooting in a grocery store parking lot at 2667 Windmill Parkway on Aug. 12, 2018. (Henderson Police Department)
Metro Asst. Sheriff Brett Zimmerman on Aug. 8 officer-involved shooting
Metropolitan Police Department Assistant Sheriff Brett Zimmerman met with media Monday to discuss the details of the 14th officer-involved shooting of the year. (Madelyn Reese/ Las Vegas Review-Journal)
News Headlines
Add Event
Home Front Page Footer Listing
You May Like

You May Like