Nevada’s ‘stand your ground’ law goes back 140 years

In 1871, brawls were not uncommon in Pioche, then a violent silver mining town that sprang up almost overnight in eastern Nevada.

So the circumstances of the fight between John Keeland and James D. Kennedy have been lost to time. Keeland beat Kennedy, and when bystanders pried him off the beaten man, Keeland asked for a pistol and declared that he would shoot Kennedy on sight the next time the two met.

That meeting occurred only minutes later, when Keeland rushed at Kennedy, who happened to be armed. Kennedy shot him dead.

What happened next would influence more than a century of Nevada law, culminating in a "stand your ground" statute nearly 140 years later.

Local authorities charged Kennedy with murder, and during the trial, jurors were instructed that the killing could only be legally justified if Kennedy "retreated as far as he safely could at the time." Kennedy had made no effort to back away from Keeland, and he was convicted and sentenced to 15 years of hard labor at the state prison.

But he appealed his case to the Nevada Supreme Court. In 1872, the justices ruled in his favor: If the facts of the case were true, then Kennedy didn’t have an obligation to retreat, and jurors should never have been told as such.

Last year, Nevada legislators took the roots of the Kennedy decision — and others like it — and wrote it into law, clarifying the right of citizens to use deadly force in self-defense of their life without first retreating or backing down.

Nevada’s new law is drawing scrutiny in the wake of a controversial "stand your ground" case in Florida, where unarmed Trayvon Martin was shot and killed by a community watch member. Prosecutors there declined to prosecute the shooter under that state’s "stand your ground" law.

But for more than a century, Nevada’s lawyers and courts have been deciding when and if people have to retreat from a threat before using deadly force. The Nevada Supreme Court has ruled on the subject several times, jurors on murder trials have been instructed on those decisions for decades, and Nevadans have the same right of self-defense they’ve had for at least 100 years.

"It’s nothing new," Allen Lichtenstein, general counsel for the American Civil Liberties Union of Nevada, said of the state law. His organization was neutral on the legislative action. "I don’t think it really changed anything."

Legislators simply turned case law, or common law, into a state statute. Judges’ decisions affect how prosecutors and defense attorneys carry out the law, regardless of whether those decisions are written into law by legislators.

For jurors on a murder trial, that means that they will get a clearer definition of when somebody can stand their ground, according to Lisa Rasmussen, a criminal defense attorney.

But that’s about it.

CONSISTENT DECISIONS

To understand how judges’ decisions become law, take a case the state Supreme Court heard in 1910, when they overturned a conviction of voluntary manslaughter stemming from a saloon shooting in Esmeralda County.

On Dec. 29 the previous year, S.P. Grimmett confronted Charles Edward Baker over a $7.50 debt. Baker became "violently angry," pronouncing Grimmett a "hophead" and a "son of a bitch," the court wrote in its decision.

Baker "hurriedly removed his coat, threw it on a roulette wheel in the saloon, ran for a billiard cue, and rushed towards" Grimmett. Bystanders stopped him and took away the cue.

He then ran behind the bar, pulled a revolver from a drawer, ran to the end of the bar and fired a shot at Grimmett. Grimmett returned fire twice, killing Baker.

Grimmett was sentenced to six years in prison, but the Nevada attorney general realized that it was clearly a case of self-defense and told the court. The court agreed.

"The law is well established that where a person, without voluntarily seeking, provoking, inviting, or willingly engaging in a difficulty of his own free will, is attacked by an assailant, and it is necessary for him to take the life of his assailant to protect his own, then he need not flee for safety, but has the right to stand his ground and slay his adversary," the court wrote in its decision.

Eighty years later, the court affirmed that decision and clarified that the right not to have to retreat applied to a person "unless he is the original aggressor."

Last year, the law legislators drafted states that a person can use deadly force in self-defense without retreating if the person "is not the original aggressor," "has a right to be present at the location where deadly force is used" and "is not actively engaged in conduct in furtherance of criminal activity at the time deadly force is used."

Lawyers interviewed by the Review-Journal could not think of a case in which the law has been applied.

Scott Coffee, president of the Nevada Attorneys for Criminal Justice and a deputy public defender who handles murder cases, expects that the law will be challenged at some point but that the judges who will rule on that challenge will realize the legislative intent was to write into law years of prior decisions.

Legislators were "not attempting to expand or contract anything in the case law," Coffee said. "They’re attempting to codify what’s out there."

DIFFERENCE IN INTERPRETATION

The Florida law has a key difference: It includes an immunity from prosecution and civil lawsuits if the person uses justifiable deadly force.

Florida judges have used the law to justify situations in which citizens who use deadly force are the original aggressors, or willingly place themselves in situations where they had to use deadly force.

That’s why the Florida law has come under scrutiny.

In the Martin case, community watch coordinator George Zimmerman saw the teen walking in the neighborhood, called police and began following him. Dispatchers repeatedly told Zimmerman he didn’t have to follow Martin, but Zimmerman continued pursuit. Eventually, an altercation occurred — the details are in dispute — and Zimmerman shot and killed Martin, who was unarmed. Zimmerman claimed self-defense under the law, and he hasn’t been charged.

The Tampa Bay Times identified other questionable cases that judges found justified under Florida’s "stand your ground" law, including one in which a man who saw someone stealing a radio out of his vehicle grabbed a knife and chased the suspect down. The suspect swung a bag of stolen radios at the man, who then stabbed him in the chest with a knife. The fact that the man never called police, hid the knife and sold the bag of stolen radios by the time police caught him didn’t matter to the judge, who felt the case was self-defense.

In Clark County, prosecutors have been willing to charge people in situations where deadly force could have been avoided.

In 2008, Edward Jones, 26, was driving to his home from a Christmas party with his family in the car early one morning. When he reached his northwest valley neighborhood, a drunken Isaiah McCallum, 18, ran into the street and threw something at his car. After a brief argument, Jones grabbed a handgun and got out of his car as McCallum’s father, a bodybuilder, approached and joined the argument.

Jones got back in his car and drove to his house, about seven homes away. The McCallums followed. Jones whisked his family into the house and retrieved a loaded magazine for his gun as his in-laws, who were drunk, according to court records, confronted the teen, who was shouting racial epithets. Jones’ in-laws were Hispanic. McCallum was white.

The elder McCallum struck Jones’ mother-in-law in the face during the confrontation, and Jones later told police he shot at him to scare the man. The shot struck John McCallum in the back and killed him.

Authorities charged Jones with murder, then later reduced the charge to voluntary manslaughter. Jones pleaded guilty to the charge and was sentenced to five years of probation.

‘WE VALUE HUMAN LIFE’

Former District Attorney David Roger, who retired in January, doesn’t believe the new law will lead to any differences in how self-defense cases are handled because it remains true to the 1990 Nevada Supreme Court decision.

He noted that the law also carries a "balancing test," where the person’s reason for using deadly force must be "reasonable" to other people. There has to be an immediate threat to the person’s life, he said.

"The unwritten rationale for our laws is that we value human life," he said. "Once that danger is gone, you no longer have the right to self-defense."

That line became blurred in 1998.

On Oct. 25 that year, Thomas Gaule was accosted by two men when he entered his west valley home. He later said the men beat him and shocked him with stun guns, but he managed to retrieve a shotgun.

Gaule fired a shot as the two men ran for the door. One of the suspects collapsed in the driveway, but Gaule continued to pursue the other down the street. He shot him about 500 feet from his home, and the man died.

A jury found Gaule guilty of voluntary manslaughter with use of a deadly weapon for chasing down and killing the second man. He wasn’t charged in the other man’s death.

At his sentencing, officials with the state Division of Parole and Probation recommended Gaule serve at least four years in prison.

But the prosecutor and the judge disagreed, and Gaule received probation.

Contact reporter Lawrence Mower at lmower@ reviewjournal.com or 702-383-0440.

ad-high_impact_4
News
Melvin Dummar dead at 74
Melvin Dummar has died at 74. Dummar was famous for claiming to have saved Howard Hughes in a Nevada desert in 1967. Dummar claimed to have been left $156 million in Hughes’ will. The will mysteriously appeared after Hughes’ death in 1976. It was dismissed as a fake two years later. Dummar never saw a dime of the billionaire's fortune. Dummar died Saturday in Nye County.
Officer-involved shooting in Nye County
The Nye County Sheriff's Office gives information about a shooting in Pahrump on Thursday night after a man began firing shots outside of his home. (Nye County Sheriff's Office)
Law Enforcement Active Shooter Training Exercise
Multiple Las Vegas Valley law enforcement agencies held an active shooter drill at the Department of Public Safety’s Parole and Probation office on December 6, 2018. Officials set up the training exercise to include multiple active shooters, a barricaded suspect and multiple casualties. (Katelyn Newberg/ Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Public memorial service for Jerry Herbst
Archiving effort hits milestone at Clark County Museum
The Clark County Museum catalogs the final item from the bulk of Route 91 Harvest festival artifacts. (John Przybys/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Pearl Harbor survivor Edward Hall talks about his memories of Dec. 7, 1941
U.S. Army Corps Edward Hall, a 95-year-old survivor of Pearl Harbor talks about his memories of that horrific day. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
Final Route 91 Harvest festival remembrance objects catalogued at Clark County Museum
The last of the more than 17,000 items left at the makeshift memorial near the Las Vegas sign after the Oct. 1 shootings have been catalogued at the Clark County Museum in Las Vegas. The final item was a black-and-white bumper sticker bearing "#VEGASSTRONG. An additional 200 items currently on display at the museum will be catalogued when the exhibit comes down. (K.M. Cannon Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Dozier execution timeline
Scott Dozier was set to be executed July 11, 2018, at the Ely State Prison. Judge Elizabeth Gonzalez delayed the execution.
Grand Jury Indicts Constable for theft
A Clark County grand jury indicted Henderson Constable Earl Mitchell. A Las Vegas Review-Journal investigation prompted the criminal probe. The newspaper found Mitchell wrote himself thousands in checks, took out cash at ATMs and traveled on county funds. He faces four felony counts of theft and a county of public misconduct. Mitchell and his attorney could not be reached for comment.
93-year-old WWII veteran arrested during visit to VA hospital
Dr. S. Jay Hazan, 93, a World War II veteran, talks about his arrest during his visit to VA hospital on Friday, Nov. 30. (Erik Verduzco Las Vegas Review-Journal @Erik_Verduzco_
Pearl Harbor survivor struggles in her senior years
Winifred Kamen, 77, survived the attack on Pearl Harbor as an infant, works a 100 percent commission telemarketing job to make ends meet. (K.M. Cannon Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Las Vegas Metropolitan Briefing 18th street gang
Las Vegas Metropolitan briefs the media on the recent arrests made regarding the 18th street gang.
Man shot in Las Vegas traffic stop had knife, police say
Police said the man fatally shot by an officer during a traffic stop in downtown Las Vegas had a “homemade knife.” Demontry Floytra Boyd, 43, died Saturday at University Medical Center from multiple gunshot wounds after officer Paul Bruning, 48, shot him during a traffic stop. Bruning pulled Boyd over on suspicion of driving recklessly at 7:41 a.m. near Sunrise Avenue and 18th Street.
Catahoula dogs rescued from home in Moapa Valley
Catahoula dogs were brought to The Animal Foundation after being rescued from home in Moapa Valley.
Intuitive Forager Kerry Clasby talks about losses in California wildfire
Intuitive Forager Kerry Clasby talks about losses she suffered in California's Woolsey Fire in Malibu in November. (Al Mancini/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Benefit dinner for Kerry Clasby, the Intuitive Forager
Sonia El-Nawal of Rooster Boy Cafe in Las Vegas talks about having a benefit for Kerry Clasby, known as the Intuitive Forager, who suffered losses on her farm in California’s Woolsey Fire in Malibu. (Al Mancini/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Former President George H.W. Bush dies at 94
Former President George H.W. Bush has died at the age of 94. He died Friday night in Houston, about eight months after the death of his wife, Barbara.
Las Vegans Celebrate Big Snowfall
Las Vegans celebrate big snowfall at Lee Canyon.
Exploring old mines for denim jeans and other vintage items
Caden Gould of Genoa, Nev. talks about his experiences looking for vintage denim jeans and other items in old mines and other places areas across Nevada and the west.
Officers share photo of dead gunman after Las Vegas shooting
A little over an hour after SWAT officers entered Stephen Paddock's suite at Mandalay Bay, Las Vegas police officers far from the scene were already sharing cell phone photos of the dead Oct. 1 gunman.
Frontier jet safely returns to Las Vegas after losing engine piece
Frontier jet safely returns to Las Vegas after losing engine piece. (@FlightAlerts_)
Park Service plans ahead for lower lake levels
National Park Service releases new plans to maintain access to the water as Lake Mead continues to shrink.
Women claim abuse at Florence McClure Women's Correctional Facility
Current and ex-inmates, including Merry West, are suing Florence McClure Women’s Correctional Facility, claiming abuse and inadequate medical care. (Rachel Aston/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @rookie__rae
Butte County Sheriff's Office Body Cam Footage
Bodycam video from Butte County (Calif.) Sheriff's Office Deputy Aaron Parmley, who was in Paradise November 8 helping with evacuations. (Butte County Sheriff's Office)
NDOT construction blasting along State Route 106
NDOT construction blasting along State Route 160, near Mt. Potosi Road, in Clark County as part of a $59 million, 6-mile-long highway widening project that began this summer. (Nevada Department of Transportation)
Car crashes into Papa Murphy's Pizza shop
A driver crashed a car into a western Las Vegas Valley pizza shop on Tuesday morning, police said. (Joe Stanhibel/Special to Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Low-lake-level pumping station nears completion
Barnard Construction and the Southern Nevada Water Authority give one last tour before the new low-lake-level pumping station is activated.
Trailer: Valley of Fires
Sultan’s Playroom from Make-A-Wish Southern Nevada
Make-A-Wish Southern Nevada’s Scott Rosenzweig talks about granting Sultan Bouras Souissi’s wish, and what went into building it. (John Hornberg/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Crime
Officer Shoots Suspect in Nye County - Bodycam
A Nye County Sheriff’s deputy shot and killed a man Thursday night. Jason Paul O’Bannon, 46, died after the altercation with police. Reports of a man firing a weapon outside his house brought police to the scene just after 8 p.m. Detective Wesley Fancher fired the shot that killed O’Bannon, police said. O’Bannon had a “lengthy criminal history” in California and Nevada dating to 1988, according to police
Nye County sheriff news conference on officer-involved shooting
Nye County Sheriff Sharon Wehrly details the police response as officers came under fire Thursday when a man was shooting a rifle in his yard. When the man pointed a weapon at an officer, police opened fire. The man died.
Officer-involved shooting in Nye County
The Nye County Sheriff's Office gives information about a shooting in Pahrump on Thursday night after a man began firing shots outside of his home. (Nye County Sheriff's Office)
Law Enforcement Active Shooter Training Exercise
Multiple Las Vegas Valley law enforcement agencies held an active shooter drill at the Department of Public Safety’s Parole and Probation office on December 6, 2018. Officials set up the training exercise to include multiple active shooters, a barricaded suspect and multiple casualties. (Katelyn Newberg/ Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Dozier execution timeline
Scott Dozier was set to be executed July 11, 2018, at the Ely State Prison. Judge Elizabeth Gonzalez delayed the execution.
Las Vegas Metropolitan Briefing 18th street gang
Las Vegas Metropolitan briefs the media on the recent arrests made regarding the 18th street gang.
Las Vegas Metropolitan Briefing - 18th street gang
Las Vegas Metropolitan briefs the media on the recent arrests made regarding the 18th street gang.
The Mob Museum
Man shot in Las Vegas traffic stop had knife, police say
Police said the man fatally shot by an officer during a traffic stop in downtown Las Vegas had a “homemade knife.” Demontry Floytra Boyd, 43, died Saturday at University Medical Center from multiple gunshot wounds after officer Paul Bruning, 48, shot him during a traffic stop. Bruning pulled Boyd over on suspicion of driving recklessly at 7:41 a.m. near Sunrise Avenue and 18th Street.
Man shot, killed by Las Vegas police after traffic stop
Las Vegas police give a briefing after a man was shot and killed by an officer following a traffic stop. (Rio Lacanlale/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Video of suspect in Home Depot parking lot shooting
A man who was injured in a Nov. 20 shooting in the southwest Las Vegas Valley died at a hospital Tuesday, the Clark County coroner’s office said.
Nevada Task Force 1 Dog Units Return
Four dogs and their handlers returned to the Las Vegas Valley on Thursday, November 29, 2018, after deploying to the Paradise, California wildfire last week. The dogs, trained in human remains detection, are part of Nevada Task Force 1, a Federal Emergency Management Agency urban search and rescue team. (Katelyn Newberg/ Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Police thwart brazen kidnapping attempt
Metro officers suspicious of woman claiming to be with Child Protective Services prevent possible kidnapping of three-week-old infant.
Shot Spotter technology used by Metro extended for another year
Gunfire location technology being used by the Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department gets extended for another year of evaluation.
Nye County pursuit ends in rollover crash caught by dashcam
A truck flipped twice before landing on its wheels as a driver tried to flee Nye County Sheriff's deputies on Friday, Nov. 23, 2018.
Nevada Highway Patrol stops wrong-way driver on Thanksgiving
The Nevada Highway Patrol has released dashboard and body camera video showing troopers deploying spike strips to stop a suspected impaired wrong-way driver early Thanksgiving Day. (Nevada Highway Patrol)
DUI sentencing
The parents of 8-year-old Levi Echenique speak after a woman who drove under the influence of marijuana and killed the boy was sent to prison.
3 Pahrump residents arrested on false imprisonment charges
James Thatcher, 28 of Pahrump, Chelsea Demille, 30 of Pahrump, and Sandra Wombles, 19 of Pahrump were all arrested after it was discovered that they were holding an adult female and male prisoners in their bedroom. (Nye County Sheriff's Office)
2 kids struck by gunfire in North Las Vegas shooting
On Saturday, Nov. 17, 2018, people opened fire into a residence in the 3600 block of Hamlin Place in North Las Vegas. Two kids were hit by gunfire and sent to the hospital with non-life threatening injuries, according to North Las Vegas police. Anyone with information is asked to call the NLVPD at 702-633-9111.
Man killed during road-rage incident
Las Vegas police are looking for two men involved in the shooting death of a man outside a 7-Eleven story at Bonanza Road and Maryland Parkway on Nov. 12, 2018. (Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department)
16-year-old shot in North Las Vegas
A 16-year-old was hospitalized but was expected to survive after a shooting in North Las Vegas, near Centennial Parkway and Fifth Street, on Tuesday, November 13, 2018. North Las Vegas police spokesman Aaron Patty gives an update. (Katelyn Newberg/ Las Vegas Review-Journal)
3-year-old boy shot in North Las Vegas
North Las Vegas Police Officer Aaron Patty talks about an accidental shooting that left a 3-year-old boy “fighting for his life” on Nov. 10, 2018.
Senior Citizen Carjacking Attack -- 3 Suspects Sought
Las Vegas Metropolitan Police detectives are seeking the public's assistance in identifying the three attackers who carjacked and beat a 78-year-old man near Fremont and east Charleston on Tuesday. (LVMPD)
Henderson Police Department Chief Latesha Watson Talks Change
11-year-old girl shot, killed in North Las Vegas
An 11-year-old girl is dead after she was struck by gunfire Thursday night during a shooting in North Las Vegas
North Las Vegas police on deadly shooting
North Las Vegas police spokesman Eric Leavitt briefs the media about a shooting that left an 11-year-old girl dead on Nov. 1, 2018. (Katelyn Newberg/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Stephan Bonnar DUI Arrest
Stephan Bonnar arrested for DUI in Nevada.
Family members of murder victims talk about their loss
Family members of murder victims talk about their loss. Susan Nash, 52, was killed in a shooting along with her daughter and one of her three sons on Sunday night. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
Sayegh Cold Case Turns 40
Cary Sayegh was abducted from the playground of the Albert Einstein Hebrew Day School in Las Vegas in 1978. His body has never been found. (File Photo)
Review held in death of man after encounter with Las Vegas police
The mother of Tashii Brown, who died after an encounter with Las Vegas police on the Strip, not satisfied after public review of evidence. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
TOP NEWS
News Headlines
Add Event
Home Front Page Footer Listing
Circular
You May Like

You May Like