45°F
weather icon Clear

HOA board cannot arbitrary enforce violations

Updated October 18, 2024 - 5:21 pm

Q: How can I manage selective enforcement of covenants, conditions and restrictions in my homeowners associations. I don’t want to get in a situation where I tattletale about my neighbors, but I am sick of being singled out for enforcement. Can these people actually enforce CC&Rs for some and not others? Can I demand all CC&R violations be resolved before I entertain the idea of doing anything regarding the CC&Rs. When I asked about specific issues I was told that the board recognized that there were violations but I was told the homeowner “is a really nice guy.” I am an older female, and I don’t know if I am nice, but I am tired of this situation. Your thoughts are appreciated.

A: Under Nevada Revised Statutes 116.3102 (3) (a-d), the board may determine whether to take enforcement action by exercising the association’s power to impose sanctions or commence an action for violation of its governing documents, including whether to compromise any action for unpaid assessments or other claims made by or against it. The board does not have a duty to take enforcement action if it determines that under the facts and circumstances presented that:

a. The association’s legal position does not justify taking any or further enforcement action.

b. The CC&Rs or rule being enforced is or is likely to be construed as inconsistent with the current law.

c. Although a violation may exist or may have occurred, it is not so material as to be objectionable to a reasonable person or to justify expending the association’s resources.

d. It is not in the association’s best interests to pursue an enforcement action.

Under subsection 4 of this law, the board’s decision to enforce one set of circumstances does not prevent the board from taking enforcement action under another set of circumstances but the board may not be arbitrary or capricious in taking enforcement action.

Being a “really nice guy” does not fall under the law. Not all violations are easily resolved, especially if the homeowner in violation chooses to ignore the violation and fine letters.

Q: We have an opening for a seat on our three-person HOA board. Only two people are running for this opening. Both nominees are previous board members. One in the running is claiming the other is not qualified to run as he is not listed on the deed. It seems in digging to see who owns the home, it’s the other nominee’s intention to disqualify the other candidate, in order to be elected by default.

The nominee being accused of not being a qualified candidate has been instrumental in helping to repair our reserves, doing small jobs to save our HOA money and helping homeowners with issues like programming their cars to open the gates, etc. His home is under a trust, and his name appears on the trust. I know that placing a home under a trust to protect a family’s interests is not unusual.

Can you provide an answer regarding the legality of someone running for the board under a trust as to being a qualified to run for an HOA board position as a homeowner?

A: Per NRS 116.31034 (14) states that an officer, employee, agent or director of a corporate owner of a unit, trustee or designated beneficiary of a trust that owns a unit, a partner of a partnership that owns a unit and a fiduciary of an estate that owns a unit may be an officer of the association or a member of the executive board.

In the your case, the individual running for the board must file proof in the records of the association that (116.31034 (14a-b) the person is associated with the corporate owner, trust, partnership, limited-liability company or estate and the records identify the unit owned.

Barbara Holland, CPM, CMCA, is an author, educator and expert witness on real estate issues pertaining to management and brokerage. Questions may be sent to holland744o@gmail.com.

MOST READ
Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
THE LATEST
Here is what the law says about service animals

Your board can contact the local Department of Housing and Urban Development office to discuss the specifics of your association, such as these dogs who may possess a possible threat to another individual.

Pahrump community has questions about new development

Under Nevada Revised Statutes 116.3108 (2), an association shall hold a special meeting of the unit owners to address any matter affecting the community if at least 10 percent or any lower percentage specified in the bylaws of the total number of votes in the association request that the secretary call such a meeting.

HOA assessments keep increasing

You would need to review the governing documents of the association as to the percent increase the board can assess, with or without homeowner approval.

Legal action continues over Corporate Transparency Act’s reach

Thomas M. Skiba, CAE, is the CEO for Community Associations Institute. In today’s column he gives a very important update regarding Community Associations Institute v. U.S. Department of Treasury. This challenges the Corporate Transparency Act and its applicability to community associations nationwide.

Trash days always seem to be windy days

You could write a personal letter to each board member asking them to address the trash issue by proposing a regulation that all trash must be in containers or in proper trash bags.

HOA board members must disclose conflict of interest

Under the law, each HOA board candidate must make a good faith effort to disclose any financial, business, professional or personal relationship or interest that would result or appeal to a reasonable person to result in potential conflict of interest in serving on the board.

Community Association Institute offers HOA information

The CAI chapter in Las Vegas offers monthly meetings with speakers. In addition, seminars and classes are offered on a regular basis. Published materials can be found on the national CAI webstite at caionline.org .

HOA board hires management company

No. The selection of a management company is made by the board of directors. Many associations have search committees where the members of the committee consist of board members and interested homeowners.

MORE STORIES