SAN ANGELO, Texas — Warren Jeffs was convicted Thursday of sexually assaulting two child brides after a whirlwind trial in which the polygamist sect leader insisted on representing himself, only to remain silent through much of the proceedings and present just one witness — a church elder who gave an extended Sunday school lesson on its beliefs.
The tall and lanky head of the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints stood stone-faced as a verdict of guilty on two counts of sexual assault of underage girls was read, after the jury of 10 women and two men deliberated for 3½ hours. He had stood mute during his closing argument, staring at the floor for all but a few seconds of the half hour he was allotted.
At one point, he turned and looked toward prosecutors and the jury, most of whom avoided direct eye contact with him. "I am at peace," he mumbled, then said no more. The only noise in the courtroom was the creaking of wooden benches brimming with spectators.
Jeffs, 55, had contended that his religious rights were being trampled and that God would seek revenge if the trial continued. He now faces up to life in prison. The sentencing phase of the trial began after the verdict was announced, and Texas’ attorney general said it could take three days.
Prosecutors used DNA evidence to show Jeffs fathered a child with a 15-year-old girl and played an audio recording of what they said was him sexually assaulting a 12-year-old. They also played tapes in which Jeffs was heard instructing young women on how to please him sexually — and thus, he told them, please God.
The FLDS, which has at least 10,000 members, believes polygamy brings exaltation in heaven. The members see Jeffs as God’s spokesman on earth.
Police raided the group’s remote West Texas ranch in April 2008, finding women dressed in frontier-style dresses and hairdos from the 19th century and seeing underage girls who were pregnant.
The call to an abuse hot line that spurred the raid turned out to be a hoax, and more than 400 children who had been placed in protective custody were returned to their families.
But authorities brought sexual assault and bigamy charges against a dozen men from the sect, with Jeffs the highest-profile defendant. All seven of those who have been prosecuted before him were convicted, receiving prison sentences of between six and 75 years.
As the sentencing phase began, prosecutors told jurors they will present evidence that Jeffs had 78 wives, in addition to his legal spouse, and that 24 of them were under the age of 17.
Lead prosecutor Eric Nichols said he would show that Jeffs either witnessed or performed more than 500 polygamist marriages and 67 other church marriages involving underage girls.
Jeffs stood up and made several incoherent objections to what Nichols said — something he did frequently throughout the trial.
"I object to anything pertaining to a religious manner," he said. "A constitutional guarantee involving things sacred must be invoked."
Prosecutors relied heavily on information seized from the compound, known as Yearning For Zion, in the town of Eldorado, 45 miles south of San Angelo. It features a massive, four-story temple of white limestone. Much of the material was discovered in a vault at the end of a secret passageway in the temple and another vault in an annex building.
"You might have asked yourselves," Nichols told jurors in closing arguments, "a lot of people may ask, why would someone record sex? … This individual considers himself to be the prophet. Everything he did, hour after hour, he was required to keep a record of that."
On one of the tapes played at the trial, Jeffs made a reference to "drawing close" or "being close," which authorities testified is how church members refer to sex. Two female voices were recorded saying "OK."
"A good wife is trained for her husband and follows the spirit of peace," Jeffs was heard saying.
Another recording included Jeffs and his younger victim and was made in August 2006 at the Texas compound. Played in court, it was difficult to decipher, but Jeffs’ and a female voice are heard. He says, "I perform this service in the name of Jesus Christ, Amen," then mentions the alleged victim by name. When she says something, he responds, "Don’t talk while praying." Several minutes of heavy breathing followed.
The church’s traditional headquarters is along the Utah-Arizona border, but it established the Texas compound in 2004. Jeffs once faced criminal charges in Arizona and was convicted of accessory to rape in Utah in 2007. But that was overturned by the state Supreme Court, and he was extradited to Texas in December.
Jeffs represented himself in the Texas case after firing seven high-powered attorneys in the six months leading up to the trial. He refused to give an opening statement, only to launch into a 55-minute sermon defending polygamy while objecting to a witness.
One of Jeffs’ former attorneys, Deric Walpole, was asked after the verdict whether it was frustrating to watch Jeffs defend himself. "It took me awhile to get used to the idea, but it’s about him, it’s about what he wanted to do," he said. "It’s about that man doing what he sees fit."
Jeffs read a statement he said was from God promising a scourge of biblical proportions against all involved if the case against him didn’t cease, and three times tried to have the judge removed.
He refused to cross-examine the state’s witnesses. After the prosecution rested, Jeffs rose for a opening statement in which he compared his plight to that of Mormon leader Joseph Smith Jr. and America’s civil rights movement of the 1960s, while urging jurors to "be open and remember the constitutional guarantees of religious freedoms and other needed guarantees."
The lone defense witness Jeffs called, church elder JD Roundy, spent 4½ hours reading from Mormon scripture and talking about FLDS history.
Prosecutors said the case had nothing to do with Jeffs’ church or his beliefs.
"You have heard the defendant make repeated arguments about religious freedoms," Nichols told jurors. "Make no mistake, this case is not about any people, this case is not about any religion. It is about one individual, Warren Steed Jeffs and his actions."