weather icon Clear

Justice Thomas offers a history lesson

Justice Clarence Thomas in the case of McDonald v. Chicago — the right of Americans to own guns — was the lone justice standing forthright for the 14th Amendment’s Privileges and Immunities Clause instead of dallying with the Due Process Clause. I think his reasoning should speak for itself:

"Interpretations of the Fourteenth Amendment in the period immediately following its ratification help to establish the public understanding of the text at the time of its adoption. Some of these interpretations come from Members of Congress. During an 1871 debate on a bill to enforce the Fourteenth Amendment, Representative Henry Dawes listed the Constitution’s first eight Amendments, including ‘the right to keep and bear arms,’ before explaining that after the Civil War, the country ‘gave the most grand of all these rights, privileges, and immunities, by one single amendment to the Constitution, to four millions of American citizens’ who formerly were slaves. … ‘It is all these,’ Dawes explained, ‘which are comprehended in the words "American citizen." ‘ … Even opponents of Fourteenth Amendment enforcement legislation acknowledged that the Privileges or Immunities Clause protected constitutionally enumerated individual rights."

Thomas also offers a ugly history lesson or a lesson of our ugly history. Read why he says, "The use of firearms for self-defense was often the only way black citizens could protect themselves from mob violence."


Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
Pelosi says agreement ‘imminent’ on revamped NAFTA

Democratic lawmakers have demanded changes designed to do more to protect workers and the environment and to make sure the deal’s provisions can be enforced.

Ex-Gov. Deval Patrick enters Democratic presidential race

Ex-Massachusetts Gov. Deval Patrick launched what he acknowledged to be a “Hail Mary” bid on Thursday for the Democratic presidential nomination.

Missouri woman sought after husband’s body found in freezer

The grim discovery was made after a witness told police that Paul Barton’s body had been in the suspect’s freezer since his death on Dec. 30, 2018.

Venice to get $21.7M quickly to recover from record flooding

Italy’s government declared a state of emergency Thursday in flood-ravaged Venice, seeking to release money to repair the historic lagoon city after it was damaged by the highest tide in 50 years.

2 dead, gunman in custody after shooting at California high school

A student gunman opened fire Thursday at a Southern California high school, killing two students, wounding three others and shooting himself in the head, authorities said.

Tons of blame to share in California’s wildfire, blackout crisis

The utility that serves more than 5 million electrical customers in one of the world’s most technologically advanced areas is faced again and again with a no-win decision: risk starting catastrophic deadly wildfires, or turn off the lights and immiserate millions of paying customers.