weather icon Clear

Judicial debate: Clark County District Court, Dept. 2: Incumbent discusses his record

An incumbent judge with a history of publicly criticized decisions and actions from the bench apologized and tried to explain his conduct during a Las Vegas Review-Journal debate with two lawyers who want to unseat him.

Deputy Public Defender Carli Kierny and criminal defense attorney Dustin Marcello are vying for the seat in Department 2, which has been held by District Judge Richard Scotti since he was elected in 2014.

In early 2018, the Nevada Supreme Court ruled that Scotti violated the First Amendment when he barred the Review-Journal from reporting on the redacted autopsy report of a man killed during the mass shooting on Oct. 1, 2017.

“Ordinarily the freedom of the press will win out over many other rights,” said Scotti, who appeared to be sitting in his courtroom during the virtual debate. “In this case, there was concern I had for the rights of privacy of the (victim’s family). … I made a decision. I am proud of the system where my decision was reviewed by the Supreme Court. That’s our system. That’s the American way. I accept it. But under these circumstances there was no reason, I felt at the time, that that coroner report needed to be produced.”

Scotti claimed he was vindicated through another high court decision. In February, justices ruled that autopsy reports are public but wrote that “juvenile autopsy reports may include sensitive, private information and that such information may be properly redacted as privilege.”

Marcello, licensed in the state since 2006, argued that Scotti let his emotions creep into his decision.

“The issue is not the action that was taken. It’s that it was legally incorrect,” he said, pointing to Scotti’s record of being overturned. “It’s not recognizing the mistake when it was there to fix it legally. There is a legal way to address it and do it under the law instead of having to do it based off of emotions.”

Also asked about Scotti’s ruling against the newspaper, Kierny said: “You have to follow the law. That’s what judges do.”

Kierny, who has been licensed in Nevada since 2010, was working as a public defender on a child rape trial in early 2017 when Scotti tossed a pocket U.S. Constitution against the wall of his courtroom during jury selection.

The judge’s action led the high court to overturn the defendant’s conviction and sentence.

When asked about the matter during the debate, the judge called the case “emotionally charged,” adding that his father was dying at the time.

“I regret what happened, and I apologize for not treating the juror more respectfully,” Scotti said. “I was really distraught. I’ve learned from this.”

In Kierny’s closing argument during the debate, she also addressed Scotti’s low retention score in the newspaper’s 2019 judicial performance survey. Of the attorneys who responded, 52 percent said Scotti should be retained.

“Clark County deserves a judge that has an even temper,” Kierny said. “They don’t deserve somebody who throws the Constitution.”

In primary races where no candidate captures a majority of votes cast, the top two finishers will advance to November’s general election. If a candidate wins more than 50 percent of the vote in the June primary, the candidate will win the election.

The newspaper is hosting 23 scheduled events for more than 70 candidates in judicial primary races for Family Court, District Court and the Nevada Supreme Court.

While the debates can be found on reviewjournal.com, they air Wednesday and Saturday nights on Cox Cable’s YurView Channel 14 as part of a video partnership between the media companies.

Contact David Ferrara at dferrara@reviewjournal.com or 702-380-1039. Follow @randompoker on Twitter.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
Politics Videos
Nevada gyms, bars that do not serve food can reopen Friday - VIDEO
Nevada Gov. Steve Sisolak on Tuesday evening said Phase 2 of the state’s Nevada United: Roadmap to Recovery will begin on Friday. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Nevada Rep. Horsford admits to having affair - VIDEO
Nevada Congressman Steven Horsford admitted to having an affair with Gabriela Linder, a former intern for Sen. Harry Reid. Linder detailed her account of the affair in a podcast she called, "Mistress for Congress." (Heidi Fang/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Sisolak says businesses will begin reopening under phase 1 - VIDEO
The first phase of reopening Nevada’s businesses will begin Saturday, May 9, Gov. Steve Sisolak said Thursday. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Joe Biden denies Tara Reade's sexual assault allegation - VIDEO
The former senate aide claims Biden assaulted her in 1993 when he was a senator. Biden first denied the accusations via a public post on Medium. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
RJ interview with Sisolak on the reopening plan for Nevada - VIDEO
The Las Vegas Review-Journal interviewed Nevada Governor Steve Sisolak on the plan for reopening Nevada during the coronavirus pandemic. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Sisolak reacts to Goodman CNN interview- VIDEO
Las Vegas Mayor Carolyn Goodman repeated her call to immediately reopen businesses during an interview with CNN’s Anderson Cooper on Wednesday, leading to a reaction from Nevada Governor Steve Sisolak. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Sisolak praises Nevadans for staying at home, saving lives - VIDEO
Gov. Steve Sisolak said Thursday it’s still too early to know when the state’s COVID-19 shutdown orders could be lifted or when businesses could start to reopen their doors. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Trump gives governors 3-phase approach to open US - VIDEO
President Donald Trump declared victory in America’s war against the “invisible enemy” as the president’s Coronavirus Task Force released “Opening up America Again” guidelines. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Trump names Jacky Rosen to task force on reopening economy - VIDEO
President Donald Trump named Sen. Jacky Rosen, D-Nev., to be a member of his Opening Up America Again Congressional Group Thursday to advise him on coronavirus policy. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Bernie Sanders endorses Joe Biden for president - VIDEO
On April 13, former presidential hopeful Bernie Sanders announced his official endorsement of former Vice President Joe Biden. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Bernie Sanders drops out of 2020 Democratic race for president - VIDEO
Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont officially announced an end to his 2020 presidential bid on Wednesday. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Democratic National Convention postponed - VIDEO
The Democratic National Convention was set to take place over four days in the middle of July. Democratic officials have now confirmed the convention will take place the week of Aug. 17. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Henderson allows immediate sale of alcohol with curbside pickup - VIDEO
The city of Henderson decided Thursday evening to allow alcohol to be sold by restaurants as part of their curbside pickup service during the COVID-19 crisis. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Sisolak signs order banning any gathering of 10 or more people - VIDEO
Gov. Steve Sisolak on Tuesday signed a new order banning any gathering of 10 or more people in Nevada in another step the state has taken to slow the spread of the new coronavirus. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Takeaways from the president's daily briefing on coronavirus - VIDEO
RJ Washington correspondent Debra Saunders talks about today's daily White House news conference regarding the coronavirus outbreak, Friday, March 20, 2020. (Renee Summerour/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Judicial Department 5 Debate - Video
The Las Vegas Review-Journal hosts a debate between the 3 candidates running for Department 5 in Clark County District Court. Participating are Veronica M. Barisich, Terry A. Coffing and Blair Cowan Parker.
Trump cancels Las Vegas trip because of ‘coronavirus outbreak’ - VIDEO
President Donald Trump canceled planned travel to Las Vegas ‘out of an abundance of caution’ amid virus outbreak. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)