weather icon Clear

‘Dreamers’ get their day in court

Updated November 12, 2019 - 5:42 pm

WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments Tuesday in a case expected to determine whether nearly 700,000 undocumented immigrants – 13,000 from Nevada – can stay and work in the United States under a program begun by former President Barack Obama.

The Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, known as “DACA,” allows qualified “Dreamers” — the children of undocumented immigrants brought into the United States as minors — to apply for temporary protected status to live and work in the United States.

After Congress failed to pass a comprehensive immigration reform bill, the Obama administration in August 2012 approved the DACA program. Obama had earlier said he was not a king, and lacked the authority to ignore existing immigration laws passed by Congress.

As a 2016 Republican candidate for president, Donald Trump was highly critical of DACA. He promised that, if elected, he would “immediately” terminate the program because, in his view, it was illegal and unconstitutional.

But as president, Trump hesitated and expressed reservations about “punishing children, most of whom are now adults, for the actions of their parents.” He went so far as to urge Congress to pass a DACA measure – even though he knew any compromise reform would not go over well with his die-hard base.

But then in September 2017, ahead of a threatened lawsuit against DACA, then-Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced that Trump would “wind down the program.”

Long legal fight

In the two-plus years that followed, the University of California and entities in New York and the District of Columbia challenged the Trump decision. Lower courts kept DACA in place, as the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to roll three challenges together into one case, captioned: Department of Homeland Security v. Regents of the University of California.

Opposing Trump is a coalition of Dreamers, Democrats, civil rights activists and big business interests that charge Trump’s decision to end DACA violated the Administrative Procedure Act.

Former Solicitor General Ted Olson — who successfully represented President George W. Bush during the 2000 Florida recount and challenged Proposition 8, California’s 2008 voter-approved initiative banning gay marriage — argued in favor of DACA on Tuesday.

Current Solicitor General Noel J. Francisco defended the administration’s position. The one-hour of legal questions and answers eschewed the personal arguments common in the DACA debate and focused on procedural issues.

At one point, Justice Brett Kavanaugh, the newest justice on the court, asked Olson, “Do you agree that the executive has the legal authority to rescind DACA?”

Olson answered, “Yes.”

Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., a long-term advocate for a big immigration bill, tweeted, “I find it hard to believe the Supreme Court would deny President Trump the ability to cancel an Obama-era Executive Order on immigration. The way to solve the DACA issue has ALWAYS been through legislation, not an Executive Order.”

But DACA supporters claimed the moral high ground. DACA beneficiaries told their stories, and ended with the statement, “My home is…”

“Here,” fellow activists gathered around them finished the sentence.

Keeping a promise to Dreamers

“DACA recipients are Americans in every sense but their citizenship status and deserve to live their lives without the constant threat of deportation,” Rep. Steven Horsford, D-Nev., said in a statement. “We must keep our promise to Dreamers. Denying their legal rights or rescinding the promise made to them seven years ago at the outset of the DACA program would be immoral and wrong.”

Sen. Jacky Rosen, D-Nev., agreed: “When the Trump administration rescinded DACA, it forced hundreds of thousands of Dreamers to live in perpetual fear in the only country they’ve ever known as home,” she said in a statement. “Whatever the outcome from today’s oral arguments, we must continue fighting tirelessly to protect the many thousands of Dreamers who call Nevada home. They represent some of our nation’s brightest, and I will continue to stand with them by supporting ongoing efforts in Congress to reach an immediate and permanent bipartisan solution to protect our Dreamers.”

Meanwhile, in Las Vegas, the UNLV UndocuNetwork, an organization for undocumented students and staff, held a small gathering in support of DACA on campus.

Student Mariana Resendiz said that even with DACA protections, she struggled to find financial aid or scholarships. Resendiz said UndocuNetwork is now able to offer resources like scholarships for all undocumented students, but that the students who could benefit from this help are threatened by the looming Supreme Court decision.

“Until then, we’re left in limbo,” Resendiz said.

Michael Kagan, director of the Immigration Clinic at the UNLV School of Law, said it’s essential for DACA recipients to apply for renewal, despite the uncertainty of the Supreme Court case.

Kagan said that the number of visits to the clinic has been steady since 2017, but that there have been other signs that immigrants are bracing for a future without DACA, like making preparations for self-employment.

“I hope that eventually we can give people some sense of permanency,” Kagan said.

‘Far from angels’

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer berated Trump for “his relentless scapegoating of immigrants.”

In the morning, Trump chimed in on Twitter, “Many of the people in DACA, no longer very young, are far from “angels.” Some are very tough, hardened criminals. President Obama said he had no legal right to sign order, but would anyway. If Supreme Court remedies with overturn, a deal will be made with Dems for them to stay!”

Undocumented immigrants who have committed a felony, significant misdemeanor or three or more other misdemeanor offenses are not eligible for DACA. And Trump has talked about being close to a DACA deal before, without results.

The court’s ruling is expected in June, during the heat of the 2020 presidential race.

Contact Debra J. Saunders at dsaunders@reviewjournal.com or 202-662-7391. Follow @DebraJSaunders on Twitter. Review-Journal reporter Aleksandra Appleton contributed to this story.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
Politics Videos
Joe Biden at the national hospitality workers union.
Democratic presidential candidate, former Vice President Joe Biden speaks to members of the national hospitality workers union during UNITE HERE's town hall on Wednesday, Dec. 11, 2019 at Culinary Union Hall in Las Vegas. @bizutesfaye
Elizabeth Warren at Culinary Union
Elizabeth Warren speaks at a Culinary Union town hall in Las Vegas on Dec. 9, 2019.
Secretary of Education visits Henderson school
Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos visited students at Pinecrest Academy in Henderson to talk about college planning on Dec. 4, 2019. (Erik Verduzco/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Trump dropped from Terry Fator’s show on Las Vegas Strip - VIDEO
Fator has edited out one prominent figure: President Donald Trump, a focal point of Fator’s regular stage show and also Christmas show over the past 3½ years. The Trump puppet, with his pop-up hairpiece, has been sidelined from both shows until further notice. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Accused murder mastermind Frank LaPena is granted a pardon - VIDEO
A onetime Las Vegas casino bell captain who spent 25 years in prison as the accused mastermind in a notorious 1974 contract murder won his last legal battle for freedom Wednesday when the state Pardons Board granted him a conditional pardon restoring all his civil rights. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
The Middle: Nonpartisan voters and the 2020 election
How will the growing segment of nonpartisan or independent voters — those who have not registered with either political party, or who have left partisan politics behind — vote in 2020?
Tomi Lahren Speaks at UNLV - VIDEO
Fox News contributor and UNLV alumna Tomi Lahren returned to campus Wednesday night for a speech, titled “Stay Triggered,” that drew an auditorium of supporters as well as a group of protesters outside. (James Schaeffer/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Bernie Sanders released from Las Vegas hospital - VIDEO
Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., issues a statement after he was released from Desert Springs Hospital Medical Center on Friday, Oct. 4, 2019, after suffering a heart attack earlier in the week. (Bernie Sanders via Twitter)
Democratic presidential candidates speak on impeachment - VIDEO
Democratic presidential candidates attending the March for Our Lives/Giffords Gun Safety Forum in Las Vegas comment on possible impeachment proceedings. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Joe Biden Las Vegas Rally Highlights - VIDEO
2020 presidential candidate, Joe Biden, came to Las Vegas to talk guns, climate change and the Ukranian-Trump scandal. Biden was interrupted by a protestor who sat amongst supporters at the rally and continued with his speech. (Angus Kelly & James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Joe Biden comments on Trump and his campaign efforts in Nevada - VIDEO
After an impeachment inquiry was opened on Donald Trump, Joe Biden talks with Review-Journal politics reporter Rory Appleton about Trump and his campaign in Nevada. (Angus Kelly & James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Bolton, Mulvaney testimony sought for impeachment trial

The president faces likely impeachment in the House, where Democrats have control, but he is expected to be acquitted in a trial in the Senate.

Trump announces trade agreement with China

On the same week the House Judiciary Committee voted to approve two articles of impeachment against him, President Donald Trump announced trade deals with Mexico and Canada, and a preliminary agreement with China. The announcement served as a bookend to Monday’s news that the White House had reached on a deal with House Democrats over the USMCA trade agreement with Mexico and Canada.