Regent’s dissertation copied material from uncited California report

A member of Nevada’s elected Board of Regents — who’s defended higher education officials against allegations of plagiarism — used several paragraphs of a California report without citation in his University of Nevada, Reno dissertation.

Regent Jason Geddes earned a doctorate in environmental sciences and health from UNR in 1995.

Glenn Miller, Geddes’ adviser — who co-authored parts of the paper, although not those with the passages in question — said Geddes’ mistake didn’t rise to the level of plagiarism and stressed that dissertations are not widely read.

“It’s something I would have never done and I think one of my good friends said I should be shot for not catching it,” Miller said Friday. “It clearly was incorrect — but rising to the level of plagiarism? I think it stops quite short of that.”

Miller is a professor in UNR’s natural resources and environmental science department and has been with the university for 38 years.

Geddes, who is Washoe County School District’s energy conservation and sustainability program manager, wrote in an email Friday that he should have cited the report and used quotes around the material taken from it in his dissertation. He has been a regent since 2006 and is chairman of the regents’ Academic, Research and Student Affairs Committee.

Lack of Citation

Nevada higher education officials’ grasp of academic integrity has been under scrutiny over the past year.

Higher education faculty and experts cried plagiarism late last year when Nevada System of Higher Education officials came under fire for taking large sections of a think tank’s report and using it without attribution. The allegations ultimately were not acted on because the agency’s attorney, Brooke Nielsen, found they were unsubstantiated. She did not respond to Review-Journal emails asking how she came to that determination.

Geddes wasn’t one of the critics. Among the regents, he’s been one of the agency’s most vocal defenders, telling the Review-Journal and other media that he didn’t believe what happened was plagiarism.

In Geddes’ case, his adviser said what happened was wrong but it doesn’t change the science at the heart of Geddes’ work, which he said was innovative. Geddes’ dissertation, “Photochemical and hydrolytic fate of methyl isothiocyanate in the Upper Sacramento River,” is on the aftereffects of a chemical spill in California after a train derailment.

One of the multiple examples of material from the California report that Geddes failed to cite:

“The Sacramento River in northern California has long been renowned for its beauty and trophy trout fishing. Originating near Mt. Shasta, it flows southward to Shasta Lake (Figure 1). Human population along this portion of the river is sparse.”

The 1992 report by the California Health Services Department stated, “The Sacramento River in Northern California has long been renowned for its beauty and excellent trout fishing. Originating near Mt. Shasta, it flows southward to Lake Shasta (Figure 1). Human population along this segment of the river is generally sparse.”

The paragraphs Geddes took were factual and background meant to establish that the spill had happened, Miller said.

“Plagiarism to me is when you actually use an idea or creative activity,” Miller said. “His omission is not telling where he got it from and not putting it in quotes, but his desire to cite things is, I think, exemplified in his 150 other citations.”

Geddes and the California study both cited the same congressional testimony. The Review-Journal pulled the minutes from the 1991 U.S. House of Representatives testimony to see if both Geddes and the California Health Services Department had perhaps copied the same testimony word for word.

That didn’t turn out to be the case, but the check did reveal the dissertation and the California report had the same typo, spelling the name of an individual cited, Mike Mohan, wrong. Both wrote Mahon instead of Mohan.

Smoking Gun?

Identical typos are the smoking guns of the plagiarism world, Tricia Bertram Gallant, outreach coordinator for the International Center for Academic Integrity, which is affiliated with Clemson University in South Carolina. Gallant reviewed Geddes’ dissertation at the Review-Journal’s request.

“When students copy each other on the exams, it’s when they copy the errors — that’s the telltale sign that they copied,” Gallant said. “I can see why he doesn’t know what plagiarism is if this passed.”

Gallant said Geddes’ lift of the report is so blatant it implies that the university felt it was acceptable.

“When it comes to dissertations, who is more to blame — the student or the committee who passed it? It should have been stopped before it got published if the committee was doing their job,” Gallant said.

Miller said he should have caught the lack of citation, but said he didn’t feel Geddes should be punished for something that happened so long ago.

“Prior to dissertations only being distributed in an electronic format, the joke was passed around that each graduating graduate student should put a $5 bill between two pages of the dissertation that was put in the library, and then come back in 20 years to see if it was still there,” Miller wrote in an email Friday.

According to UNR’s student code of conduct, if a graduate of the university is “found to have been involved in material academic misconduct that impacts the reputation of the university, the university will invoke its authority to resolve the incident through a review of, and possible action to modify, the graduate’s status and record including revocation of degree if warranted in accordance with (Nevada System of Higher Education) code.”

Contact Bethany Barnes at bbarnes@reviewjournal.com or 702-477-3861. Find her on Twitter: @betsbarnes.

News Videos
Henderson fails to investigate the drug overdose death of one of its officers
Henderson Police Department's internal affairs did not investigate the 2014 drug overdose death of an officer. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Syphilis Awareness Day
Dr. Joe Iser, District Health Officer of the Southern Nevada Health District, discusses the effects and issues with syphilis in the Las Vegas community on April 16, 2019. (Mat Luschek/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Las Vegas diocese IDs 33 ‘credibly accused’ of sexual abuse
The Catholic Diocese of Las Vegas released a list on Friday of 33 “credibly accused” of sexual abuse who at some point served in the Las Vegas Valley. (Michael Quine/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
CCSD Arbor View meeting
The Clark County School Board hears from the public about racial tensions at Arbor View High School on Thursday, April 11, 2019. (Amelia Park-Harvey/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Parents of autistic student battle Clark County School District
Joshua and Britten Wahrer, parents of a special education student, are battling the Clark County School District for the right to equip their son with a monitoring device. (Amelia Pak-Harvey/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
New Metro homeless outreach a shift in strategy
Lt. Joe Sobrio discusses the new homeless outreach team for Metro. (Rachel Aston/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Prayer for Opportunity Scholarships
Las Vegas students and adults hold a prayer meeting about the Opportunity Scholarship program on Thursday, April 4, 2019. (Amelia Pak-Harvey/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Solar scams on the rise in Nevada
As Nevada’s solar industry has made a resurgence, solar scammers have followed suit.
Clark County schools and the late bus issue
Year after year, late or no-show buses in the Clark County School District draw the ire of parents and students alike. One year the problem even prompted a parent to crack a school bus window in frustration over a late drop-off. (Mat Luschek/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
I-15 southbound congested near Primm Sunday afternoon
Drivers heading toward California on Interstate 15 should expect heavy traffic and a 13-mile backup Sunday afternoon.
Learning lifesaving skills in advance of fire season
Students and firefighters attend a training session at Fire Station 80 in Blue Diamond, Saturday, March 30, 2019. The training session helps volunteer firefighters obtain necessary annual certification to work wild fires.
Car restoration behind prison walls
Inmates share their experiences working for the Southern Desert Correctional Center auto body shop in Indian Springs while learning valuable skills.
Parent remembers Las Vegas boy killed by car
People visit a memorial at the intersection of South Fort Apache Road and West Arby Avenue at at Faiss Park Wednesday, March 27, 2019, where Jonathan Smith, 12, of Las Vegas, died after he was struck while crossing Fort Apache Monday. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @KMCannonPhoto
Couple left with surprise medical bills after visit to the hospital
Michael Pistiner took his wife, Marta Menendez-Pistiner, to the ER in January after she fainted twice and appeared to be having a seizure. Despite paying $856 monthly for health insurance, the two, self-employed musicians, were stuck with more than $5,700 in hospital and doctor bills after than hour-and-a-half visit. Caroline Brehman/Las Vegas Review-Journal.
Las Vegas police brief the media on fatal crash
Metropolitan Police Department Capt. Nick Farese addresses the media about a car accident at South Fort Apache Road and West Arby Avenue that left one minor dead and one hospitalized on Monday, March 25, 2019. (Mike Shoro/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Former Arbor View parent talks about racial issues at the school
Lawanna Calhoun, a former Arbor View parent, talks about the state of the school. (Amelia Pak-Harvey/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Jim Foley talks about 30 years of living HIV-positive
Jim Foley, who was diagnosed as HIV positive 30 years ago, talks at his home in Las Vegas on Wednesday, March 13, 2019. (Chase Stevens/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Traffic Slows to a Crawl on I-15S Near Primm
Traffic slowed to a crawl around 2:30p Sunday, on I-15S near Primm, Nevada.
Homeless residents speak about safety
The homeless residents living at the corner of Owens Ave. and Main St. reflect on how they feel about their safety after two homeless men died, one was hit crossing the street and another was beat to death by another homeless man. (Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @bizutesfaye
CCSD Superintendent address alleged racially motivated threats at Arbor View
CCSD Superintendent Dr. Jesus F. Jara gives update on alleged racially motivated threats against Arbor View High School, and says such threats will not be tolerated. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @KMCannonPhoto
Super Bloom Near Lake Elsinore, California
Crowds packed the hills near Lake Elsinore on Saturday to capture a rare selfie amidst the super bloom of poppies turning the landscape purple. The super bloom was caused by the larger rainfall this year. (Todd Prince/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Fiery accident in Las Vegas
A three-car accident on Spring Mountain Road around 6:30 pm on Monday night
A bipartisan coalition holds simultaneous rallies to promote criminal justice
A bipartisan coalition holds simultaneous rallies to promote criminal justice. (Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @bizutesfaye
Stardust implosion anniversary
Twelve years ago today, the Stardust Resort and Casino was imploded. (Mat Luschek/Review-Journal)
Lawsuits filed against security contractors at Nevada National Security Site
Two lawsuits were filed today against the current and former government security contractors for the Nevada National Security Site, one on behalf of Jennifer Glover who alleges sexual discrimination and assault and the other on behalf of Gus Redding who alleges retaliation after he gave statements supporting Glover’s claims. (Rachel Aston/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
New housing option helps Las Vegas moms keep kids while kicking drugs
WestCare Nevada Women and Children’s Campus in Las Vegas has added a new transitional housing wing for women who have completed the inpatient treatment at the behavioral health nonprofit to help them as they go through outpatient treatment, shore up their finances and prepare to secure long-term housing. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @KMCannonPhoto
Teenager in critical condition after being struck by an SUV in Henderson
Authorities were called about 2:45 p.m. to the scene in the 2100 block of Olympic Avenue, near Green Valley Parkway and Sunset Road. The teenager was taken to University Medical Center in critical condition. (Michael Quine/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
The Water Question Part 3: Conservation loves a crisis
Future growth in the Las Vegas Valley will rest almost entirely on the community’s ability to conserve its finite share of the Colorado River.
The Water Question Part 7: How much can we grow?
Many experts agree that Southern Nevada can continue to grow, so long as residents are willing to do what needs to be done to stretch our crucial resource as far as it will go.
The Water Question Part 6: How many people can Southern Nevada’s water sustain?
The number can swing wildly depending on a host of variables, including the community’s rates of growth, conservation efforts and the severity of drought on the Colorado River.
TOP NEWS
Home Front Page Footer Listing