weather icon Clear

Commentary: Debate over ISIS bride’s citizenship not about Trump


In late 2014, Hoda Muthana, then 20 years old, left Alabama to become an ISIS bride in Syria. When she left the United States, she posted her passport on her Twitter account and said she was about to burn it.

Now Muthana wants to return to the U.S. with her 18-month-old son, but President Donald Trump doesn’t want to let her back in the country.

Here’s the TV news take on her case as laid out by the “Today” show’s Craig Melvin: “This is the Alabama woman who left four years ago to join ISIS. She has a son. She said that she wants to come home now. She was radicalized. She made a big mistake.”

“Alabama mother begs to return to the U.S.” reads an online ABC News headline. Considering that Muthana left Alabama four years ago to renounce the United States and join ISIS, “Alabama mother” is not the way most people would describe her.

Problem: Muthana doesn’t seem really sorry. In an exclusive interview with ABC News, Muthana was asked what she thought would be proper punishment for joining ISIS. She replied, “Maybe therapy sessions. Maybe a process that will insure us that we’ll never do this again.”

Muthana also described herself as “just a normal human being who’s been manipulated once and hopefully never again.”

The “Manson girls” — young women who trolled and killed for cult leader and mass murderer Charles Manson in 1969 — come to mind. But at least the creepy young women who fell for Manson didn’t know what they were getting into when they joined his so-called family.

Muthana was radicalized over the internet. Months before she flew to Istanbul on the road to Raqqa, ISIS posted a gruesome video of one of its masked thugs beheading journalist James Foley.

ISIS forces had beheaded Syrian troops, humanitarian workers, civilians and western hostages. A normal person does not see videos of people being beheaded and want to marry the executioner. But that’s what Muthana did. She married three ISIS fighters as her contribution to the caliphate.

Muthana also had a Twitter account on which she urged others to drive trucks to kill people at American parades. And she urged her followers to look up President Barack Obama’s schedule so they could “take down that treacherous tyrant.”

Muthana now is being used as another example of what is wrong with Trump. The president tweeted, “I have instructed Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, and he fully agrees, not to allow Hoda Muthana back into the Country!”

As Pompeo told Melvin of the “Today” show, the U.S. does not believe Muthana is a U.S. citizen, as her father was in the United States as a Yemeni diplomat shortly before her birth. The government asserts that the fact that Muthana had a U.S. passport did not establish her bona fides as a citizen.

Muthana’s family is suing to prompt Washington to get her out of a Syrian refugee camp and back into the United States.

“This shows us to be a nation of laws,” her attorney Charles Swift argued Friday on CNN. Swift also said that Muthana “understands that she’s going to be prosecuted.” (I’m not so sure she does understand given her assertion that jail time is less likely to help her when she really needs help to recover from the trauma she experienced.)

Muthana family attorney Hassan Shibly told the Daily Mail that Trump would use the case to undermine birthright citizenship in a way that affects “mostly Latino Americans.”

There is one little problem with that argument. According to Swift’s petition to establish Muthana’s citizenship, as well as that of her son, the U.S. government sent a letter to her in care of her parents’ address on Jan. 15, 2016, that informed Muthana that she was not a citizen. January 2016 — that’s before Trump was elected.

It was the Obama administration that determined Muthana was not a citizen because, according to Swift’s brief, the United Nations did not notify the U.S. government about the father’s diplomatic status until months after the daughter was born. And if there is one thing Obama was not known for it was working to end birthright citizenship.

Swift may well be right on the citizenship issue at hand. And if he is right, may Muthana be greeted with a quick embrace from a legal system ready to let her take responsibility — real responsibility — for joining a terrorist organization.

Or maybe the courts will rule that Muthana is not an American — and if that happens, for once, it won’t be because of Trump.

Contact Debra J. Saunders at dsaunders@reviewjournal.com or 202-662-7391.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
DEBRA J. SAUNDERS: Whistling past the graveyard

Rep. Adam Schiff failed to disclose that the whistleblower who complained about President Donald Trump’s call to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy had first approached Schiff’s committee with the information.

DEBRA J. SAUNDERS: Plenty of candidates, but no stars

When you consider how much the Democratic establishment loathes President Donald Trump, it’s just plain sad to watch a Democratic primary that has yet to offer up a front-runner who has Democrats truly jazzed about the election.