VICTOR JOECKS: America needs more masculinity
Society has spent decades telling boys that masculinity is toxic. Now there’s a shortage of skilled tradesmen. The connection should be obvious.
Through his on-again, off-again tariff dance, President Donald Trump has made one thing clear: He wants more things built in America. He has bragged about already securing more investment dollar commitments than Joe Biden did during his entire term. And he wants more.
Trump has long championed the rural communities devastated by factory shutdowns. It’s one reason that he has enjoyed such strong support in Middle America. In his speech at the Republican National Convention last year, Vice President JD Vance detailed the importance of remembering that American is both a “nation” and “our homeland.”
The hardworking people I grew up with “love this country, not only because it’s a good idea, but because in their bones they know that this is their home,” he said, adding, “This is the source of America’s greatness.”
This is why Trump and Vance are so determined to rejuvenate American industry. But there’s a major obstacle to accomplishing this: a shortage of skilled workers.
“For every five tradespeople that retire, two enter the workforce,” Mike Rowe, host of “Dirty Jobs,” wrote last year. “That’s a 5-to-2 ratio, and the math is simply not sustainable.”
It’s not for lack of opportunity. The Navy Industrial Submarine Base needs to hire 100,000 skilled tradesmen within the next decade. But the companies working there struggle to find qualified employees.
One reason is that society has pushed students toward college. Ronald Reagan said, “If you want more of something, subsidize it.” And the government has done just that, dumping trillions of dollars into higher education over the decades. Sure enough. College enrollment more than doubled from 1972 to 2022, growing from 9.2 million to 18.6 million.
This hasn’t just limited the potential pool of future welders and plumbers. It has sent the message that those careers are second-rate. That they’re only for people who aren’t smart enough for college.
It’s a terrible and false message. It may not earn you a high SAT score, but understanding how wiring, pipes and parts work in the real world is a much-needed form of intelligence. Men working with their hands literally built the country.
There’s a more fundamental issue. The skilled trades continue to be dominated by men. This isn’t the result of the patriarchy but of innate differences between men and women. Men are stronger than women. They’re more mechanically minded. They’re more interested in working with their hands. They’re more willing to do dangerous and dirty jobs, such as building Hoover Dam.
This doesn’t make men superior. It makes men and women different. Women have their own strengths, including better language and social skills. Modern feminists rarely praise pregnancy, but growing a baby inside of you is the closest thing human beings have to a superpower.
But society doesn’t nurture the unique strengths of boys. Most schools want little boys to act like little girls. Doctors prescribe Ritalin to boys who can’t sit still. Male students see their success in areas such as mathematics and engineering dismissed as the result of systemic sexism, not their achievements. Compounding this problem is the growing number of boys living in homes without their fathers.
Little wonder that so many men — and potential skilled tradesmen — have disengaged. The labor force participation rate for men 25-54 hit 98 percent in 1954. In March 2025, it was just more than 89 percent.
Masculinity isn’t toxic. It’s what built this country. And rebuilding American industry requires celebrating masculinity, not attacking it.
Contact Victor Joecks at vjoecks@reviewjournal.com or 702-383-4698. Follow @victorjoecks on X.
