Updated June 7, 2018 - 11:45 pm
Those long-shot wagers on the Golden Knights turned to dust Thursday night when the Washington Capitals beat Vegas 4-3 in Game 5 at T-Mobile Arena to win their first Stanley Cup.
The odds on the expansion Knights winning the Stanley Cup in their inaugural NHL season were as high as 500-1 in the preseason at the Westgate sports book, which took 13 bets at that price. The William Hill sports book took 350 futures bets on the Knights at 100-1 or greater and would have lost more than $1 million had Vegas hoisted the Cup.
Overall, Las Vegas sports books stood to lose $5 million to $7 million on the Knights.
But avoiding a record loss for a futures wager didn’t translate into big wins for the books.
The win by the Capitals, whose odds were as long as 28-1 to win the Cup when they trailed the Columbus Blue Jackets 2-0 in their first-round playoff series, cost the Westgate sports book six figures.
“We had to reduce the liability on the Knights at the expense of the other remaining teams, including the Capitals,” Westgate sports book director Jay Kornegay said. “We were basically in a lose-lose situation. We lost a little less on them than we would’ve with the Knights.”
Boyd Gaming sports book director Bob Scucci said the Capitals’ victory resulted in a small win for his shop.
“We did OK, not great, because if you’re going to lose a ton on the Golden Knights, it makes sense at the beginning of the series to try to take a lot of Capitals money. In that respect, we reduced liability on the Knights but increased liability on the Capitals,” he said. “We hedged every series, and we did the same thing on the Capitals. But we didn’t do as great as we would have if they played someone else other than the Golden Knights.”
The books cleaned up on the Stanley Cup Final, when Vegas’ storybook season ended with its first four-game losing streak. As was the case all season, the books won when the Knights lost and lost when they won.
But the betting public still came out ahead on the Knights, who went 51-24-7 in their improbable regular season and opened the postseason on a 13-3 streak.
“We’re down for sure on all the Knights games. But we’re fine with it. As citizens of this community, we’re certainly OK with it,” said Kornegay, a Knights’ season-ticket holder. “It’s been a great season for this city and this team.
“It was something new for the bookmakers, too. We’ve never seen this before, and we’ve never seen this in this sport before.”
Boyd Gaming and the South Point sports books reported losing on the Knights overall this season but winning on hockey because of the extra action on the NHL that was generated by Vegas.
“The handle was fantastic,” South Point sports book director Chris Andrews said. “In the end, we’ll make a little more money this year than we did last year (on the NHL). The handle was so good, it overcame whatever we lost on the Knights.”
Sunset Station sports book director Chuck Esposito said the NHL handle more than doubled this season because of the Knights, who generated 10 times as much action on their games as any other one on the board.
“With in play (betting) and props, it kind of made it a wagering event for each Knights game,” he said. “This series has probably been the most heavily bet pro hockey final that I can ever remember.”
With the advent of legal sports betting nationwide, sports books in other states probably will face a multimillion-dollar liability on a home team. But it will be hard to top one of the greatest sports stories ever told.
“It won’t be like this story,” Kornegay said, “because they won’t even have the Browns at 500-1.”