weather icon Clear

Army-Navy refusal to move game bad for college football

Mountain West commissioner Craig Thompson didn’t want any misunderstanding — he’s a proud American.

So his opposition to Army and Navy (and CBS) for sticking with their plan to play a week after everyone else has completed the regular season and conference championship games has nothing to do with the military and our beautiful country.

The simple fact is the stubbornness exhibited by those parties is bad for college football.

And Thompson is right, especially now that Navy is in the American Athletic Conference, giving the Midshipmen greater access to a New Year’s Six bowl.

The Army-Navy game is a week after all the playoff spots and bowls are supposed to be settled. If Navy is the highest-ranked team from the so-called Group of Five conferences, the other four leagues and their bowl partners probably will have to wait a week for the Midshipmen to play that final game.

The highest-ranked team from one of those bottom five conferences is guaranteed a spot in the New Year’s Six bowl, which went to Boise State last season.

So if it comes down to Boise State and Navy at the end of the season with the Midshipmen ahead in the College Football Playoff rankings, the Broncos must wait a week to see what happens. And so will the Las Vegas Bowl, which will lose valuable time in an already tight schedule of selling tickets and promoting its game.

“Let’s say everything is delayed a week,” Thompson said. “That gives a Mountain West team seven days, from Saturday to Saturday, to go to the Las Vegas Bowl. It’s hard enough now on Dec. 5 having barely a couple of full weeks to get ready for it. One week would be, c’mon.”

There’s a simple fix. Insist Army and Navy play the game earlier in the season or make them ineligible for a New Year’s Six game regardless of the record.

Thompson is all for moving up the game, but don’t count on it happening. Navy athletic director Chet Gladchuk made that stance clear in an interview with USA Today, saying he’s even willing to sacrifice a shot at the playoffs if that’s the price for staying put.

“I’m a full American,” Thompson said. “I’m all in favor of the Army-Navy game. I think it’s a tremendous athletic event, but it’s disruptive to 128-plus other FBS schools.”

Thompson and his conference have a vested interest. The Mountain West has been ranked first among the nonpower conferences in eight of the past 11 seasons and second twice.

And it’s not as if Thompson is unfamiliar with service academies. Air Force has been a member of the Mountain West since the conference began playing in 1999.

“For 16 years, Air Force has played as part of this (Bowl Championship Series) system and part of a bowl system, and they’ve played Army and Navy in November and October,” Thompson said.

No reason Army and Navy can’t find a similar date.

■ SABAN SPEAKS OUT — Alabama coach Nick Saban didn’t like that the Southeastern Conference created a rule to prohibit league schools from taking players who were disciplined at their previous stop for a major offense such as sexual assault.

It was Saban taking such a player, Jonathan Taylor, that was the impetus for the rule getting passed. Alabama signed the junior college transfer, who had a domestic violence charge pending. Then three months after arriving at Alabama, Taylor was charged with domestic violence, and the university kicked him out of school.

Saban told al.com the rule creates an uneven playing field with the four other power conferences and prevents second-chance success stories.

“… one of the points that I tried to make was Cam Newton being in the SEC and Nick Marshall being in the SEC benefited the SEC, and it benefited those players,” Saban said. “So if those players were not allowed to play in the SEC, they’d be playing someplace else.”

That’s where Saban got into more trouble, naming two players who were at rival Auburn. And he was wrong. Newton and Marshall were never accused of anything as serious as domestic violence, and they would have been able to attend Auburn even if the rule existed then.

Saban was just trying to stick it to Auburn, but in missing the mark, all his comment did was remind everyone why the rule was created in the first place.

■ SEEING THE SIGHTS — The Atlantic Coast Conference isn’t satisfied playing only in traditional stadiums.

Over the next two years, ACC teams will play games at Fenway Park, Bristol Motor Speedway and in Dublin. The league also has a tie-in with the Pinstripe Bowl in Yankee Stadium.

The Mountain West also has talked with the Pac-12 Conference about playing a bowl in Australia, though that happening is unlikely because of the logistical issues of such a long trip.

Contact Mark Anderson at manderson@reviewjournal.com or 702-387-2914. Follow @markanderson65 on Twitter. He also is first vice president of the Football Writers Association of America.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.