weather icon Partly Cloudy

NHL’s expansion decision gets varied reaction in media

The announcement that the NHL was coming to Las Vegas, though expected, started a flurry of activity Wednesday.

Many local residents cheered while hockey fans in Quebec City, who had their bid for a team deferred, were left out in the cold. With expansion now official, here’s a quick rundown of some of the reactions in the media:

Chris Peters of CBS Sports put together a potential roster for the Las Vegas team based on the NHL expansion draft rules.

He found the new team is probably going to have a hard time finding goal scorers, as teams will look to protect their top six forwards. The franchise could draft some veterans with tougher contracts while also filling depth slots with younger, less expensive options that could have some upside.

Peters also found there likely won’t be a ton of productive blueliners available, especially ones with right-handed shots. Las Vegas might opt for experience on the back end in the expansion draft and try to find higher-upside options elsewhere, he wrote.

For goaltenders, Peters thought the team’s best option might be to grab a stop-gap starter for a year or two while taking some younger guys that could start down the road. He drafted Jimmy Howard of Detroit to fill the veteran role.

If fans want to run their own mock draft, there’s a simulator at generalfanager.com.

Scott Burnside of ESPN said new owner Bill Foley might be “the most interesting man in hockey.” The head of the NHL’s 31st franchise will take the league into uncharted territory, creating the first major pro sports team in Vegas.

The businessman, while not strictly a “hockey guy,” will be involved and demanding, Burnside wrote, and can already sense the enthusiasm for his new team.

Last month while having a burger with his wife and children an 11- or 12-year-old boy approached Foley’s table and told him he was rooting for him to get a hockey team. Now that kid has his wish.

* Eric Macramalla of Forbes said Richard Peddie, the former President and CEO of Maple Leaf Sports and Entertainment, is not a fan of the NHL’s decision.

Peddie was involved in projects like the Air Canada Centre (home of the Toronto Maple Leafs), Toronto FC and their home, Leafs TV, and Raptors TV and called expanding to Las Vegas a “bad mistake.”

“The NHL owners are going to regret it. It’s not a great community economically,” Peddie said. “Fan avidity will not develop.”

* Don Macpherson of the Montreal Gazette wrote one reason Quebec City might have lost out is the NHL’s unwillingness to break up one of its big money-making markets.

The Montreal Canadiens’ revenue was $219 million in the 2014-15 season, second in the league according to Forbes, with Quebec City as part of their television market. A potential Quebec City franchise would be a small-market team with only a small profit, and it would cut into the profits of Montreal.

Canadiens owner Geoff Molson said publicly he would welcome a rival team in Quebec City, but he voted to expand to Las Vegas along with the NHL’s other 29 owners.

* Sean McIndoe of The Guardian ran through many of the pros and cons of a Vegas team.

He wrote the city seems ready for a major pro sports team, but the NHL seems like a weird choice to start. The league has struggled when it gets creative in the past, such as when it moved into southern markets like Atlanta or Arizona.

McIndoe also questioned the team’s fan base and how it’s going to be built in the city. He asks “if you lived in Vegas, surrounded by all the most over-the-top entertainment options you could imagine, would you really be lining up to see an expansion team exchange neutral zone turnovers with the Edmonton Oilers in November?”

* Kevin Allen of USA Today called Las Vegas “a smart, sexy pick” for an NHL expansion location.

Allen said having a team in Vegas is free international marketing because of all the visitors the city attracts. The city also has a tradition of hockey in the minor leagues and its youth hockey is up 37 percent in the last decade.

The NHL has also had success in non-traditional markets, he said.

“The Florida-based Tampa Bay Lightning and Florida Panthers are the best teams in the Atlantic Division, the Los Angeles Kings have won two Stanley Cups since 2012 and the Anaheim Ducks won in 2007. The San Jose Sharks were in the Stanley Cup Final this month.”

* And Jamie Strashin of the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation wrote “by many sensible metrics, putting an NHL team in Las Vegas will be a giant struggle.”

He wonders whether the Vegas franchise will fare any better than the teams in Carolina, Columbus, Arizona and Florida which continue to just tread water. Arizona in particular “has been a story on bankruptcy, civic disputes, shrinking attendance and waning interest” in its decade-plus existence.

Strashin said any success for the team “will be difficult and hard-earned.”

Contact Ben Gotz at bgotz@reviewjournal.com.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
Golden Knights Videos
Golden Knights Zamboni Lessons 101 - Video
The Golden Knights preseason tips off on Sunday, Sept. 15 and you know what that mean, it's time to roll out the zamboni! Have you ever wondered what it takes to be a zamboni operator for the Golden Knights? Golden Edge host Cassie Soto finds out!
Allegiant Unveils Golden Knights Plane - Video
Allegiant air officially unveils its new Golden Knights airbus that will take to the skies soon.
Golden Knights Rookie Camp: 3 Takeaways - Video
Vegas Golden Knights rookies took to the ice on Friday morning for practice at City National Arena. While the rookies mainly participated in drills, it was good to see the prospects get ice time. Golden Knights beat writers David Schoen and Ben Gotz discuss their three takeaways from the practice.
Golden Knights Host Charity Golf Classic - Video
The Golden Knights held its 2019 Charity Golf Classic on Wednesday at TPC Summerlin. Before teeing off, Golden Knights players Ryan Reaves, Jonathan Marchassault and Alex Tuch said who they thought were the worst and best golfers on their team.
Ryan Reaves performs wedding ceremony
Reverand Reavo makes his debut for one time only at the Chapel of Flowers for a get married by Ryan Reaves contest.
Vegas Golden Knights President Kerry Bubolz on the Golden Edge Podcast
Review-Journal reporters Ben Gotz and David Schoen talk with Golden Knights president Kerry Bubolz about his experiences with LeBron James, the team's new initiatives, a possible MLS expansion team and more.
George McPhee Conference Call on Nikita Gusev trade - VIDEO
Golden Knights President of Operations George McPhee answers questions on a conference call about the teams most recent trade of Nikita Gusev to the New Jersey Devils.
Vegas Golden Knight's Deryk Engelland Happy to Re-Sign - Video
Vegas Golden Knights defenseman Deryk Engelland is happy to stay in Las Vegas after signing a one-year deal with the team.
Golden Aces hold Tryouts For 2019-2020 Season - Video
The Golden Aces hold tryouts for the 2019-2020 season for the Golden Knights.
Golden Knight's owner Bill Foley's House for sale in The Ridges - Real Estate Millions
Vegas Golden Knights, Fleury Make Day for Critically Ill Teenager in ESPN “My Wish” - Video
A 13-year-old Las Vegas boy who has faced Hodgkin’s lymphoma is treated to a special day by the NHL’s Vegas Golden Knights in a new ESPN “My Wish” Series feature debuting Wednesday, July 17, on SportsCenter. In the feature, Doron Coldwell spends a day with the team and even gets an opportunity to replace his favorite player, three-time Stanley Cup winner Marc-Andre Fleury, in the net.
Golden Knights Sell "Battle Worn Armor" To Season Ticket Holders - Video
The Golden Knights sell their "battle worn" apparel throughout both of the teams seasons including pucks, sticks, helmets and skates.
Summerlin 4th of July Parade - VIDEO
On July 4th Summerlin will be hosting the 25th annual Summerlin Council Patriotic Parade, an event that has grown massively over the years
Golden Knights McPhee talks on the first day of NHL free agency - VIDEO
Golden Knights incoming president of operations George McPhee addresses the media as free agency starts.
Golden Knights Trade Colin Miller as Development Camp ends - VIDEO
George McPhee speaks to the media following the end of the Golden Knights development camp.
Golden Knights Development Camp Day 4 - VIDEO
Nic Hague stands out at day 4 of Golden Knights development camp.
Golden Knights Hold First Scrimmage of Development Camp - Video
The first of three scrimmages was held at the 2019 Golden Knights Development Camp. Golden Edge host Cassie Soto and Golden Knights beat writers Adam Hill and David Schoen discuss what stood out to them.
Golden Knights George McPhee Discusses Erik Haula Trade - Video
A day after it was announced that Erik Haula had been traded to the Carolina Hurricanes, incoming President of Hockey Operations George McPhee spoke to the media discussing the move.
Golden Knights Trade Erik Haula - Video
The Golden Knights have traded Erik Haula to the Carolina Hurricanes in exchange for prospect Nicolas Roy. Golden Edge host Cassie Soto and Golden Knights beat writer Adam Hill discuss the trade.
Golden Knights Coaches Looking for Veterans to Step Up in Development Camp - Video
Day two of the 2019 Golden Knights Development Camp is in the books. Director of Player Development Wil Nichol says his staff is looking for the veterans of the camp to step up and be leaders to the younger guys, while at the same time doing their best to impress the coaching staff.
Golden Knights Draft Player with Strong Hockey Bloodlines - Video
The Golden Knights drafted Mason Primeau in the 5th round of the 2019 NHL Draft. Primeau is no stranger to professional hockey, both his dad (Wayne Primeau) and his uncle (Keith Primeau) played in the NHL.
Golden Knights Kelly McCrimmon Talks Development Camp - VIDEO
Golden Knights general manager Kelly McCrimmon talks about what he expects from everyone at development camp on their first day.
Golden Knights Dylan Coghlan On Veteran Experience - VIDEO
Golden Knights defenseman Dylan Coghlan talks about his veteran experience playing in Chicago and development camp.
Golden Knights President George McPhee talks about Williams Karlsson's 8 year deal
George McPhee presser highlights June 25, 2019.
Golden Knights Center William Karlsson speaks to media about 8 year contract
William Karlsson presser highlights June 25, 2019.
Golden Knights Development Camp at Catholic Charities of Southern Nevada
For the third consecutive year, Vegas Golden Knights Development Camp participants participated in a special community event at Catholic Charities of Southern Nevada in Las Vegas. (Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @bizutesfaye
2019 NHL Awards Highlight Video
The 2019 NHL Awards took place at the Mandalay Bay Events Center in Las Vegas on Wednesday night. Though Vegas Golden Knights forward Mark Stone came close to winning the best defensive forward trophy, St. Louis Blues center Ryan O' Reilly took home the coveted Frank Selke Trophy. Jason Zucker, who was raised in Las Vegas and plays for the Minnesota Wild, accepted the King Clancy Memorial Trophy for leadership and humanitarianism. Tampa Bay Lightning's Nikita Kucherov took home the NHL's MVP Award. (Heidi Fang / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Gary Bettman discusses NHL rule changes - VIDEO
NHL commissioner Gary Bettman addressed the media after Wednesday’s Board of Governor’s meeting.
Golden Knights' Mark Stone up for Selke Trophy
Golden Knights right wing Mark Stone is a finalist for the Selke Trophy. The award goes to the best defensive forward in the NHL. Stone led the league in takeaways last season with 122. His competition is St. Louis Blues center Ryan O'Reilly... And Boston Bruins center Patrice Bergeron. Stone will find out if he wins Wednesday at the NHL Awards.
Vegas Golden Knights announce preseason schedule
The Golden Knights announced their preseason schedule Tuesday, as well as the date of their rookie camp and training camp.