96°F
weather icon Clear

Same-sex marriage challenge vowed

A federal challenge to Nevada's ban on same-sex marriage was denied, but proponents vowed Friday to fight on with an argument that a pair of state laws regarding same-sex unions unconstitutionally make gay couples "second-class citizens."

Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund attorney Tara Borelli noted that a Thursday ruling by U.S. District Chief Judge Robert Jones came a day before the U.S. Supreme Court considered whether to take up the gay marriage question and weeks after voters approved same-sex marriage in three states and defeated a ban in a fourth.

"We think this decision is not only out of step with where the country is headed but also completely wrong on the law," Borelli said. She said a challenge will be filed with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco.

Jones, in Reno, ruled that Nevada has "a legitimate state interest" in maintaining the traditional institution of marriage and that excluding the recognition of same-sex couples is "rationally related to furthering that interest."

The question "is not the wisdom of providing for or recognizing same-sex marriages as a matter of policy," Jones wrote in his 41-page order.

Rather, he called it a constitutional question about Nevada's right to prohibit recognition of marriages from other states "if those laws do not conform to Nevada's one-man-one-woman civil marriage institution."

Monte Stewart, lawyer for the Coalition for the Protection of Marriage, a Boise, Idaho-based advocacy group that opposes gay marriage and was involved in the case, declined comment.

Officials with Gov. Brian Sandoval's office and the Nevada state attorney general's office didn't respond to messages. Lawyers in the Carson City attorney's office declined to comment.

The Nevada lawsuit, Sevcik v. Sandoval, was filed in April on behalf of eight Nevada couples. It was the first by Lambda Legal to make the direct state marriage equality claim in federal court.

It said the 2002 state constitutional amendment prohibiting same-sex marriage violated the Equal Protection Clause of the U.S. Constitution by denying same-sex couples in Nevada the same rights, dignity and security that other married couples enjoy.

Borelli said letting domestic partners register their legal status but not marry "brands these loving couples and their children as second-class citizens."

The lawsuit also accused the state of establishing a "selective bar to access to marriage" with a 2009 domestic partnership law that passed over a veto by then-Gov. Jim Gibbons, a Republican.

And the lawsuit maintained that same-sex couples are still discriminated against by hospital officials and police officers who question their relationship status because they aren't legally recognized as spouses.

MOST READ
Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
THE LATEST
Hulk Hogan, icon in professional wrestling, dies at 71

Hulk Hogan won a world championship in Las Vegas in 1993 and was a fixture for years, facing everyone from Andre The Giant and Randy Savage to The Rock and WWE chairman Vince McMahon.

MORE STORIES