THEATER: Composer takes exception to review
In a recent review of Utah Shakespearean Festival's original musical production of "Great Expectations" (which runs through Aug. 28 in Cedar City), I said the music, lyrics and book were so bland that the festival should drop them all and start over. I later received an e-mail from composer Richard Winzeler, whose letter was a reminder to me of what it's like to be on the receiving end of stinging criticism.
"Hi Anthony-
"Richard Winzeler here, composer on 'Great Expectations'. I read your review this morning, and was obviously disappointed. I realize that you have an entitled opinion, which I respect, but it's a shame that your dismissing of the material can be discouraging to both performers, creators, and potential audiences alike. The reality of seeing several performances while in Utah, and then going to the feedback sessions the next day, was that the patrons seemed to love the show. In addition to consistent positive comments, the standing ovations count for something I think. Refreshingly, as you so related in another on-target article, the word of mouth is valuable in supporting the show, even if critics like yourself have a different opinion.
"I'm sorry you had a negative experience with our show. It has been a 12 year rewarding journey, and from the audience feedback at least, we have done our job well enough. I'm not sure what your "expectations" might have been coming into the theater, or what musical shows that you admire as a standard of excellence, but I hope in the future that you might be more open to new works, approaching them in a nurturing and positive manner.
"I continue to believe in our production, regardless, and wish you the best in your career."
(This is the first of a series of blog entries about local-area theater events. I'm hoping readers will share their own critiques, audition notices, and deep thoughts about anything going on in the performing arts community by e-mailing me at vegastheaterchat@aol.com.)
