weather icon Clear

Judge rules Nevada’s medical marijuana registration program is constitutional

Nevada’s medical marijuana registration program is constitutional, a Clark County judge has ruled.

In a 38-page order filed Friday, District Judge Rob Bare also determined the state is legally immune from related claims of fraud and unjust enrichment.

“The court may not judge the wisdom or necessity of the registration program because the court is not the policy maker. …” Bare wrote. “The best avenue of redress is through the Legislature, not the courts.”

The ruling ends a class-action lawsuit filed Aug. 13 by a 42-year-old Las Vegas man with a history of migraine headaches. The man, identified only as John Doe, claimed the state had engaged in fraud and unjust enrichment by accepting fees for registration cards without giving patients a legal source of marijuana.

Nevada lawmakers voted to allow medical marijuana dispensaries and commercial growing in 2013, but the state’s first dispensary did not open until July 2015. The state’s second dispensary opened on Aug. 24 in Clark County.

The plaintiff’s attorney, Jacob Hafter, said he plans to appeal Bare’s ruling.

Hafter raised a variety of issues in the case. In addition to claiming fraud and unjust enrichment, he argued that Nevada’s medical marijuana registration program violated the due process and equal protection clauses of the Constitution’s 14th Amendment and the self-incrimination clause of the Fifth Amendment.

Hafter specifically argued that the due process clause protects a fundamental right to access health care.

“I think this is the next big civil rights argument,” he told Bare during a December hearing.

In his order, the judge found no fundamental right in federal law to use medical marijuana.

Hafter further argued that the registration process violates the equal protection clause by imposing an unnecessary burden on patients seeking one type of medical treatment.

However, Bare found the registration program “is rationally related to the legitimate state interest of protecting the health, safety and welfare of the public.”

Bare also rejected Hafter’s argument that the process violates the self-incrimination clause by requiring patients to admit that they are violating federal law.

According to his lawsuit, the plaintiff has suffered from migraines since he was 15, and only marijuana relieves the related nausea. He applied for a Nevada Department of Health and Human Services registration card in 2013, paid fees and was issued a card that expired after a year. He later renewed his card.

Contact reporter Carri Geer Thevenot at cgeer@reviewjournal.com or 702-384-8710. Find her on Twitter: @CarriGeer

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
More tainted marijuana found in Las Vegas

The Nevada Department of Taxation on Monday issued a health notice after batches of marijuana sold from four Las Vegas dispensaries were found to have fungus, bacteria and high levels of mold and yeast.

Nevada marijuana official placed on leave

A top Nevada marijuana official who has faced criticism over his conduct during the state’s cannabis licensing process was placed on administrative leave last week.

Nevada marijuana license ruling could come next week

A Nevada judge said Friday she expects next week to finish hearing a case involving dozens of companies that lost bids to open new retail pot stores asking her to stop the state from licensing more marijuana businesses.

California to increase enforcement against illegal pot shops

California is planning to intensify its enforcement against the state’s thriving illegal marijuana market, including launching an ad campaign Friday that urges consumers to seek out licensed shops with safe products.

Officials raid 247 Colorado homes growing black market pot

Authorities said Friday they raided hundreds of black market marijuana operations in Colorado that flouted the state’s cannabis law by growing tens of thousands of plants in Denver-area homes and selling the drugs out of state.