Racing industry has misguided fear of embracing exchange wagering

Updated September 14, 2017 - 7:35 pm

As discussed in last week’s column, exchange wagering is an exciting new way of betting on horse racing that benefits horseplayers by letting them lock in odds. So why is it available in the U.S. only in New Jersey?

The reason is not terribly surprising. Many of racing’s varied constituencies – racetracks, horsemen, jockeys, owners and states – fear it will mean less revenue, since the commission deducted from a winning exchange wager — 12 percent in New Jersey — is less than the traditional 16 to 20-something percent takeout subtracted by racetracks. That, in theory, means less money to go around to keep the sport running.

But as Kip Levin, CEO of Betfair US and TVG, the horse racing television network, explained in last week’s column, the experience in New Jersey shows it has largely attracted new participants to the sport who are familiar with financial markets and sophisticated trading tools.

“When we talk to the industry, there has always been this concern because the model is different … that you’d be cannibalizing the handle,” he said. “(In New Jersey) there has been no cannibalization. That was completely unexpected and to me is the reason I’m optimistic that people will say ‘wow, this is actually bringing in new customers.’”

Even so, persuading racing’s interest groups to embrace the new technology has proved challenging. Betfair has been in talks in California, which changed its law to enable exchange wagering, for more than six months and has yet to reach a deal.

It seems inevitable that more states will soon authorize exchange betting on horses. But after years of seeing the fractured racing industry shoot itself in the foot, I won’t be surprised if it takes longer for that to happen than it should.

Horseplayers in Nevada may be in for an even lengthier wait. The Silver State is not near the top of Betfair’s list of jurisdictions where wagering laws can be tweaked to enable exchange wagering.

“We have looked at Nevada,” said Levin. “It’s a challenge because they have different laws for online betting and for ADW (advance deposit wagering) and they obviously have a pretty rigorous licensing process. … The cost of licensing has so far been too great to justify the size of the market.”

#RJhorseracing featured races

Off a fantastic performance last week at Kentucky Downs in which our handicapping corps picked the top two and top three finishers of our featured races, we’re turning our collective attention this week to Saturday’s 8th and 9th races at Belmont Park.

In the 8th, a mile allowance race for 3-year-olds and up, our crowd ‘cappers make Meantime (7-2 second choice on the morning line) a narrow pick over Harlan Punch (5-1) and Spieth (4-1). Surprisingly, 3-1 morning line choice Faja didn’t crack our top 3.

Reader Shelly Benardo sums up Meantime’s appeal: “Meantime. (Luis) Saez an aggressive rider out of the gate, second off the layoff, wide trip pressed all the way in last. (Trainer Brian) Lynch did not win many at the spa, overdue.”

I should know better, but I’ll go my own way with #3 Hammerin Aamer, who I think should save ground early under Jose Lezcano, then tag ‘em late.

In the 9th, the Sands Point Stakes (Gr. 2), a 1 1/8-mile test for 3-year-old fillies, our corps makes Uni (3-1 on the morning line) the strong choice, with La Coronel (4-1) and Inflexibility (6-1) filling out the placings. I do think Uni is the horse to beat, but I think La Coronel can get the jump on him and prevail in a tight finish.

You can join the fun next week. Email me to receive an alert when the free past performances are posted or check Twitter under the hashtag #RJhorseracing on Wednesday. Then email or tweet your top 3 picks along with a brief analysis and wagering strategy by 5 p.m. Thursday. If I use your comment in Friday’s column, there’s a packet of Review-Journal breath mints in it for you. Nothing could be finer!

Contact Mike Brunker mbrunker@reviewjournal.com or 702-383-4656. Follow @mike_brunker on Twitter.

ad-high_impact_4
Sports Betting Spotlight Videos
Sports Betting Spotlight: College Football Bowl Edition
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart and Las Vegas Wynn Sports Book Director Johnny Avello go over their picks for the college bowl games.
Sports Betting Spotlight: NFL Week 15
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart and Las Vegas Wynn Sports Book Director Johnny Avello go over their picks for week 15 of NFL football.
Sports Betting Spotlight: NFL Week 14
Review-Journal reporter Todd Dewey, handicapper Kelly Stewart and TI sports book director Tony Nevill preview NFL Week 14.
Sports Betting Spotlight: NFL Week 13
Review-Journal reporter Todd Dewey, handicapper Kelly Stewart and The Mirage sports book director Jeff Stoneback preview Week 13 of the NFL regular season. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Sports Betting Spotlight: College football Week 14
Review-Journal reporter Todd Dewey, handicapper Kelly Stewart and The Mirage sports book director Jeff Stoneback preview Week 14 of the college football season. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Sports Betting Spotlight: College Week 13
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart and Matt Holt give their picks for week 13 of college football.
Sports Betting Spotlight: NFL Week 12
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart and Matt Holt give their picks for week 12 of NFL football.
Sports Betting Spotlight: College football Week 12
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart and Bob Scucci go over their picks for college football week 12.
Sports Betting Spotlight: NFL Week 11
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart and Bob Scucci go over their picks for NFL football week 11.
Sports Betting Spotlight: NFL Week 10
Review-Journal reporter Todd Dewey, handicapper Kelly Stewart and CG Technology Sports Book Vice President Matt Holt preview Week 10 of the NFL.
Sports Betting Spotlight: College Football Week 11
Review-Journal reporter Todd Dewey, handicapper Kelly Stewart and CG Technology Sports Book Vice President Matt Holt preview Week 11 of the college football season.
Sports Betting Spotlight: College Football Week 10
Review-Journal reporter Todd Dewey, handicapper Kelly Stewart and Boyd Gaming Sports Book Director Bob Scucci preview Week 10 of the college football season.
Sports Betting Spotlight: NFL Week 9
Review-Journal reporter Todd Dewey, handicapper Kelly Stewart and Boyd Gaming Sports Book Director Bob Scucci preview Week 9 of the NFL season.
Sports Betting Spotlight: NFL Week 8
Review-Journal reporter Todd Dewey, handicapper Kelly Stewart and The Mirage sports book director Jeff Stoneback preview Week 8 of the NFL season.
Sports Betting Spotlight: NFL Week 7
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart and Alan Berg go over their picks for NFL week 7.
Sports Betting Spotlight: NFL Week 6
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart, and Boyd Gaming sports book director Bob Scucci make their picks for NFL Week 6. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Sports Betting Spotlight: College football Week 7
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart, and Boyd Gaming sports book director Bob Scucci maker their picks for Week 7 of college football. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Sports Betting Spotlight: NFL Week 5
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart, and CG Technology Sports Book Vice President Matt Holt go over their picks for week five of college football.
Sports Betting Spotlight: College Football Week 6
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart, and CG Technology Sports Book Vice President Matt Holt go over their picks for week six of college football.
Sports Betting Spotlight: College Week 5
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart (@kellyinvegas) and Wynn Sports Book Director John Avello go over their picks for week five of college football and their best bets.
Sports Betting Spotlight: NFL Week 4
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart (@kellyinvegas) and Wynn Sports Book Director John Avello go over their picks for week four of the NFL and their best bets.
Sports Betting Spotlight: NFL Week 3
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart (@kellyinvegas) and Caesars Oddsmaker Alan Berg go over their picks for week three of NFL football and their best bets.
Sports Betting Spotlight: College Football Week 4
Todd Dewey, Kelly Stewart (@kellyinvegas) and Caesars Oddsmaker Alan Berg go over their picks for week three of college football and their best bets.
TOP NEWS
ad-infeed_1x2_1
News Headlines
ad-infeed_1
ads_infeed_2
Local Spotlight
Events
Home Front Page Footer Listing
Circular
You May Like

You May Like