Nevada imagines exporting excess renewable power, but California has the same plan

Renewable energy will save Nevada.

At least, that’s the idea. Build solar, geothermal and wind plants, and not only will the Silver State meet its legal quota for clean energy, but it’ll have leftovers to export to huge markets such as California — thereby diversifying the economy. It’s a classic case of doing well by doing good.

There’s just one problem.

California’s thinking the same thing.

In a recent letter to federal officials, and at last week’s National Clean Energy Summit, California officials said they can meet green-energy needs with thousands of spare megawatts for export.

“How much we import has to be balanced with how much we’re building locally,” said California Gov. Jerry Brown at the summit. “With solar-photovoltaic prices coming down, there’s a real rush to put up panels on shopping center roofs, school roofs and along freeways. We’re going to generate a lot of energy, and hopefully, we’re going to be able to export. I think integration (with other states) is good, but we’re going to try to build as much indigenously as we can.”

By all accounts, California could build a lot. That may mean trouble for planned transmission lines across Nevada, said Eric Witkoski, the state consumer advocate who represents ratepayers in electricity rate cases.

“Some people painted it as a big gold rush in California. But they already have their own gold,” Witkoski said.


An Aug. 3 letter from Brown’s clean-power adviser, Michael Picker, shows just how much potential renewable energy California has.

Picker wrote Brad Nickell, a director of the Western Electricity Coordinating Council in Utah, to outline how California’s renewables market has changed. Picker’s letter highlighted big prospects.

California’s renewable portfolio standard says the state’s utilities must get 33 percent of their electricity from renewables by 2020. That means they’ll need 20,000 megawatts from solar, geothermal or wind in the next decade.

In 2010 and 2011, California is on track to permit 10,000 megawatts of renewables. What’s more, developers of more than 500 renewable projects totaling nearly 50,000 megawatts are seeking permits from the California Energy Commission. Picker also noted that the California Independent System Operator, a nonprofit transmission manager, says developers aim to link 70,000 megawatts of renewables to its grid. And energy trade publication Platts Electric Power Daily noted that Brown expects California to produce 12,000 megawatts of rooftop solar as well.

If the state could get 40 percent of its energy from renewables, then “we will be positioning ourselves for relationships with other load areas outside California and can hopefully provide mutual benefit in cost-efficient renewable market transfers,” Picker wrote.

It’s a goal that may dampen expectations for energy export from Nevada.

“I think initially, everybody thought the opportunity to export was going to be gigantic,” said John Candelaria, a Henderson-based senior associate with Aspen Environmental Group, which provides environmental impact assessments and other services for energy developers and agencies, including the Nevada Bureau of Consumer Protection. “But I don’t see how anyone can ignore (Gov. Brown’s) official policy saying, ‘We want it all to come from California, and we want to export.’ ”

That policy means Nevada developers must go slowly to avoid added economic stress for consumers, Witkoski said.

Local power utility NV Energy has built or bought 3,000 megawatts of generation in the last six years to avoid relying on pricey wholesale power during peak demand. To pay for those additions, general rates have nearly tripled since 2003, Witkoski said.

“If a developer is going to build transmission, we want them to proceed cautiously, so we don’t cause more rate impacts not only on residents, but businesses,” Witkoski said. “Going forward, economic models look a lot different. Growth will be a lot slower and more limited.”

One renewable transmission line is already being built in Nevada. The $510 million, 500-kilovolt One Nevada line (ON Line), which NV Energy and New York developer LS Power are building from Ely to Apex, will link NV Energy’s northern and southern grids and carry renewables to its cities.

Witkoski said the 235-mile ON Line will create “synergies” within NV Energy but he questioned additional transmission the company might build, including as many as 500 miles of lines from Washoe County to Boulder City.

Until NV Energy can evaluate demand for the line, it can’t say how much the lines would cost or how large they’d be. The deadline for developer solicitations of interest is Sept. 16.

In a Wednesday statement, NV Energy said it’s exploring opportunities with California and other markets through its Renewable Transmission Initiative.

“This approach puts the onus on developers to make sure there is a demand for their renewable-energy projects,” the company stated.


There could be demand for some Nevada renewables outside the state.

Geothermal energy, abundant in Northern Nevada, costs less than other renewables. A 2010 Review-Journal comparison of renewables in Nevada found geothermal projects selling for 8.6 cents per kilowatt hour, compared to 13 cents per kilowatt hour from two solar projects. Geothermal also produces 24 hours a day. Cost and availability make geothermal attractive next to intermittent renewables such as solar and wind.

And then there’s Valley Electric Association in Pahrump. The 23,000-member co-op just got the nod to join the California Independent System Operator, which could allow it to send solar power to the Golden State, Witkoski said.

Solar Express Transmission, a private firm, is two years into development of a line in the same area, and is working on financing the $200 million project.

Candelaria said tapping into the Independent System Operator is a smart strategy that could qualify Nevada-based projects as California resources for renewable-portfolio purposes. Other developers will have to be just as nimble to find success next door.

“Cost does matter. Transmission developers in this state have to make sure they understand the rules, and they have to be careful to follow the rules,” Candelaria said. “They have to provide transmission solutions that make renewable projects as competitive as possible. If they can get energy connected to California in the cheapest way possible, it’s my opinion that there are still opportunities for renewable developers in Nevada.”

The question is how substantial those opportunities are anymore.

A big transmission developer stared that question in the face recently, and didn’t like the answer.

In July Developer TransCanada sold its 1,000-mile, 500-kilovolt Zephyr transmission line still under construction from Medicine Bow, Wyo., to Las Vegas.

TransCanada said it didn’t make sense to keep the $3 billion project given California’s uncertain renewable market.

“Developers who are looking at these opportunities are just going to have to refine their approach,” Witkoski said. “They’re going to have to drill down and be specific on the numbers and whether they can be competitive. They may hold some attraction for some buyers in California. There may still be developers here who can offer a low-cost product. But it is going to be a challenge.”

Contact reporter Jennifer Robison at or 702-380-4512.

Holiday shopping and returns make this the busiest time of year for UPS
The UPS Las Vegas South facility is the company's busiest pre-load operation in the country, and it's even busier this time of year. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Primm’s outlet mall has fallen on hard times
The mall, attached to Primm Valley Resort, opened in 1998. Back then, it was a “textbook, perfect outlet-center location." But now, Primm’s outlet mall has fallen on hard times. Las Vegas Boulevard has endless shopping spots. And there are other outlet malls that don’t require a hefty drive to the state line. Its mortgage-holder foreclosed on the mall in late September.
Miltary auction at Ritchie Bros. Auctioneers
Humvees, ammo cans, construction equipment, field gear and more is on the auction block Friday and Saturday at Ritchie Bros. Auctioneers. About 10,000 items in all are for sale in what GovPlanet bills as the largest auction of its kind.
Las Vegas residents discuss avoiding holiday scams
Las Vegas residents discuss their donation habits and how they avoid giving money to scam charities during the holiday season. (Bailey Schulz/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Tesla’s Nevada Gigafactory ahead of economic impact expectations
The Tesla Gigafactory’s economic impact on Nevada has exceeded projections, bringing in more than 7,000 jobs. In 2014, Nevada agreed to give the automotive and energy company $1.3 billion in tax abatements. In return, Tesla promised to meet certain requirements in areas like employment and capital investment. As of June, Tesla has brought in a total of $6.05 billion in capital investment, surpassing the $4.95 billion projection. The original contract gave the company until 2024 to make $3.5 billion in capital investments in Nevada. Derek Armstrong, deputy director of the Governor’s Office of Economic Development.
Land sales near the Las Vegas Raiders stadium
Land around the Las Vegas stadium site has been selling for high prices. A few months before the stadium’s groundbreaking, Global Trust Group acquired a 2.5-acre parcel just north of the stadium site. The property sold for $7.25 million, or $2.9 million an acre. Osprey Real Estate Capital and Huntington Hotel Group acquired a 2-acre industrial site just west of the stadium site in late November. The property sold for $6.5 million, or $3.15 million per acre. That's roughly 12 times the average price of land in the valley this year as tracked by Colliers International.
T-Mobile Tech Experience Truck parks in Toshiba Plaza at T-Mobile Arena
The Tech Experience Truck is a state-of-the-art showroom on wheels, with demonstrations that put connected drones, smart cities, augmented/virtual reality and smart tracking. The exhibit shows new wireless technology – including 5G and the Internet of Things (IoT). (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Steve Siegel, CEO of the Siegel Group, speaks about helping families and other needy residents
Steve Siegel, CEO of the Siegel Group, speaks about helping families and other needy residents to keep them from teetering off into homelessness. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vrgas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
Crowds camp out for Chick-fil-A opening
Dozens of customers camped out 24 hours ahead of the 6 a.m. Thursday opening of the new Chick-fil-A on Rainbow Blvd.
Cheapest listings for sale in Las Vegas
Listed for $39,990, 585 S. Royal Crest Circle, Unit #9 is one of the cheapest homes currently listed for sale in Las Vegas. (Caroline Brehman/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
MGM's sports betting deals
MGM Resorts International signed a sports betting sponsorship agreement with the NBA in July It was the first professional sports league to have official ties with a legal sports betting house. The deal came just two months after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned a law prohibiting sports betting in most states. In October, MGM became the first gaming company to sign a sports betting partnership with the NHL. In November, MGM became the first gaming company to sign a sports betting partnership with the MLB. Financial terms of Tuesday’s deal and earlier partnerships have not been announced.
Terry Miller discusses Convention Center
Project Manager Terry Miller explains the phases of Convention Center construction.
Zappos treats their team members on Cyber Monday
Zappos rolls out a variety of food, drinks and special activities for all team members at their downtown Las Vegas headquarters for Cyber Monday. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Team Hybrid at the 2019-Model Motor Trend International Auto Show
Among the companies showing off the 2019 model cars, Team Hybrid shows off its modified cars. Las Vegas resident David David talks about the team, which is in its ninth year exhibiting at the show, and his show car.
Black Friday Shoppers at downtown Summerlin and at the Arsenal
Black Friday shoppers at downtown Summerlin and at the Arsenal. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfYe
Black Friday shopping in Las Vegas
Black Friday sale shopers express their shopping experience. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
Las Vegas Livestock recycling Strip food waste
Las Vegas Livestock collects and recycles food from many Las Vegas Strip companies. (Nicole Raz/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Black Friday at Fry's
Shoppers line up for deals early on Black Friday at Fry's Electronics on Las Vegas Boulevard South. (Mat Luschek/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Black Friday shoppers at Best Buy at 5 am
Black Friday shoppers at Best Buy at 5 am on Nov. 23. (Mat Luschek/Las Vegas Review-Journal
Black Friday - 1am Closing Time
Quiet night.
Black Friday - 12:30am - Best Buy Arroyo Crossing
Sam's Town Holiday Lighting Ceremony
On Wednesday, Nov. 21, 2018, Mystic Falls Park opened with its annual tree lighting ceremony, hosted by Boyd Gaming Executive Chairman Bill Boyd. The attraction features a Winter Wonderland theme and holiday-inspired laser light show, available daily Nov. 23 to Jan. 1. (Mat Luschek/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
What Is A Smart City?
George Karayannis, vice president of CityNow, Panasonic’s smart-city arm, explains. (Nicole Raz/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Walmart uses virtual reality to train employees
Walmart Academy Facilitator demonstrates the VR training program being used by Walmart stores across the country.
With holidays around the corner, department stores hiring extra staff
J.C. Penny hired 72 seasonal workers this year at the Galleria at Sunset mall in Henderson in order to handle the heavy traffic of the holiday shopping season. (Rachel Aston/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Startup Weekend fosters new businesses
With the help of entrepreneurial peers and an expert panel of mentors, Techstars Startup Weekend fosters the ideas of attendees into marketable business plans. (Rachel Aston/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Mecum Car Auction in Las Vegas
The Mecum Auctions is held at the Las Vegas Convention Center. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/ Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
Construction underway for new Google Data Center
Henderson is slated to be home to a new Google data center in December 2020. The Governor’s Office of Economic Development approved $25.2 million in tax abatements for Design LLC, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Google. The company plans to build the data center on 64 acres of land on Warm Springs Road west of Boulder Highway.
Anthony Rufo talks about his new product, an in-home digital companion and monitor.
Anthony Rufo talks about his new product, HAPPIE Home technology, an in-home digital companion and monitor designed for unpaid family caregivers that gives personalized alerts, messages and reminders. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
Holiday parades help bring shoppers to Downtown Summerlin
Sports Town USA floor manager Angela Gardonio talks about the work that goes into the Downtown Summerlin holiday parades and how they benefit her and other businesses there.
News Headlines
Add Event
Home Front Page Footer Listing
You May Like

You May Like