weather icon Clear

HOA rental percentage can affect FHA financing

During the second homeowner forum at one of my associations, one of our homeowners wanted to discuss the rental percentage issue concerning Federal Housing Administration loans.

The homeowner referenced an article that was published in the Review-Journal that I had written Oct. 30, 2005. The article was in response to a reader whose association were losing its FHA certification because of excessive rental units. My homeowner asked me a “simple” question, how does rental caps and FHA loans apply to this association?

Back in 2005, the Legislature passed Nevada Revised Statutes 116.335. This law has been amended several times. Section 1 of this law prohibited homeowner associations from establishing any rental caps. The only exception were those associations that had rental caps before the passage of NRS 116.335. Section 3 of the law stated that if an association had a rental cap before the passage of this law, the association could not decrease the maximum number or percentage of units that could be rented.

During the Great Recession, significant numbers of association homes became rentals, thereby potentially jeopardizing the ability of homeowners to obtain FHA loans depending upon the percentage of rentals within the community.

I checked with attorney John Leach on this issue. Here is what he said:

“That is such a great question. In fact, I posed a similar question to the Legislature years ago. Please note that existing rental caps are enforceable. The problem is adopting new ones. In the Red Hills case, the Nevada Supreme Court concluded that unanimous consent was required because of the language in the covenants, conditions and restrictions, which was copied from NRS 116.2117 (4).

“We have several homeowners associations that are still considering adopting rental caps, but they understand that they may be challenged. NRS 116.2117 (2) appears to grant an owner one year to challenge a recorded amendment. In addition, the recent rental cap amendments have only been applicable to owners that acquire title to property after the rental cap has been recorded. In other words, all owners in existence when the rental cap is recorded are grandfathered in and allowed to rent in spite of the cap. I wish I had a good answer for you, but there just doesn’t seem to be one.”

After I read John’s response, I sent him one final email which read: “So bottom line, FHA can refuse to fund an homeowner because of the high percentage of rentals in their HOAs and the HOAs cannot do anything because the law does not allow HOAs to establish a rental cap if one had not already existed prior to the new law? Correct?”

John’s response to me: “I think that is a fair and accurate assessment. Time to get the law changed.”

For those readers who have been following my column for many years, I have often stated that this law needed to be changed as homeowner associations were becoming “ apartment communities.” For some associations, this is not an exaggeration. Are the interests of investor homeowners the same as resident homeowners? For many associations, the answer would be no.

I don’t know if the legislators that supported this law over the years realized the financial crisis that they have imposed upon those homeowners who want to buy a home or refinance a home with an FHA loan. It is time for change. The only way this law will be modified will be because of you, the reader. Start the process of discussing the issues with your state representatives to draft a modification of the law.

Q: I approached my HOA about adding a motion sensor solar light to the rear of our complex where the lighting is less the 1 foot-candle ( measured it) at the access gate. My son is visually impaired and is blind in darkness because of a progressive disease — retinitis pigmentosa — which makes it difficult for him to see the lock to open the gate. I was told unequivocally, no. I question whether or not the light levels at the manual gate are even legal, but is there any code that would allow me to make them address this? It would only cost a few hundred dollars to add a solar cell with a motion sensor. There might be a tree that is blocking the streetlight from lighting the gate, but I have not verified that. The tree is on private property. It seems like I could make them add a street light to ensure the area meets the minimum lighting levels, but I do not want to do that because it would cost a great deal more to the HOA. They seem unreasonable.

A: Based upon your information, the association would fall under both the Fair Housing Act laws of the state and federal government, the section, titled, “accommodations.” This is an inexpensive fix for your association, significantly less expensive than defending their actions in a civil rights case. Your board should rethink its decision. You can contact the local HUD office at 702-366-2100 for help.

Barbara Holland is a certified property manager, broker and supervisory certified association manager. Questions may be sent to holland744o@gmail.com.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
3 can make a quorum for HOA board

Let’s assume that you have a full board of five directors and at a duly noticed board meeting only three directors can attend.

Changes in law will affect how associations can tow vehicles

Senate Bill 212 was changed. It affects how associations can tow vehicles in the community. The existing law states that a vehicle may not be towed until 48 hours after affixing a notice to the vehicle that explains when it will be towed (with the exception of vehicles that are related to health, safety or welfare, i.e. parking in front of fire hydrants, etc.).


Editor’s note: Listings include the resale home’s parcel number. The address listed is the homebuyer’s mailing address and not the actual location of the resale home. About 90 percent of these addresses reflect the home purchase. Check the parcel number to make sure. Also, a few transactions do not reflect the market value of the homes. The information is provided by Accudata, a local research firm. For the complete listing, visit RJRealEstate.Vegas.

New Nevada laws that will affect HOAs

There were not too many laws passed in this last legislative session that affected our local homeowners associations. Here are some that did.

BHHS partners with Adwerx to offer Realtors new program

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Nevada Properties, in partnership with Adwerx Enterprises, has launched a new platform, called Brilliantly Simple to immediately advertise its real estate listings online. The platform automatically creates digital advertising programs for each home, including custom ads that are optimized for social media, apps and websites.

Homeowners have right to see HOA financial records

Per Nevada Revised Statute 116.31175 (1a), upon written request, you are entitled to receive financial statements from your association. Please send a formal specific request of what financial statements that you would like to receive.

High land costs affect developments

For all the job growth and expansion in the Las Vegas economy, a lack of land and its high cost is restricting growth in the valley, experts told the Southern Nevada real estate and development community.

Local home prices stuck at $300,000

For the third straight month, the Greater Las Vegas Association of Realtors, GLVAR, reported that local home prices are hovering at $300,000, while the number of homes on the market continues to increase.

Fair Housing Law requires accommodations for disabled

The Fair Housing Law requires accommodations for the disabled. Based upon your email, the homeowner would have a strong claim against the association if the homeowner was forced to remove the motor home, or if the association were to fine the homeowner because of the therapy equipment. Take the time to meet with this homeowner and see if there are any other viable alternatives.