Union money troubles drove CCSD to dump consultant

A $100,100 settlement recently freed Clark County School Board President Erin Cranor from a lawsuit, but it stirred up more public accusations of backroom dealings, misuse of public money and questionable motives for actions taken by her and by school district administrators.

District officials last month sent the settlement check to Business Benefits, a consulting company the school district once employed to negotiate better rates for health insurance for school support staff. The payment, made without School Board approval or notification, focused attention on administrative decisions that could prove expensive in coming months: Superinten­dent Pat Skorkowsky canceled the Business Benefits contract midterm, at Cranor’s urging, knowing it would trigger litigation that could cost taxpayers millions of dollars, according to sworn depositions, minutes of closed-door meetings and other documents related to the lawsuit obtained by the Review-Journal.

Cranor refuses to say much about the matter, other than her intentions were good: She wants to shift all 30,000 employees and their dependents to one health plan that would be less expensive than the current system of separate coverage for teachers, support staff, administrators and school police, with some plans run by labor unions and others by the district.

But a different picture emerges from depositions and other court papers related to the Business Benefits lawsuit and interviews with senior school district and union officials.

“Her intentions are not pure,” said a senior district official who asked not to be identified.

The official said Cranor got involved in the insurance issue at the behest of John Vellardita, executive director of the district’s teachers union, the Clark County Education Association, who has jockeyed to replace Business Benefits as the district’s insurance broker.

“He (Vellardita) has realized the money isn’t in the union members — it’s in their benefits,” a high-ranking teachers union member said.

Vellardita did not return telephone calls seeking comment for this article.

Gaining control of a district-wide health plan would pay dividends for both the teachers and the plan’s new administrator.

The union’s self-funded Teachers Health Trust for years paid its now-retired CEO and subrogation lawyer, Peter Alpert, more than $500,000 per year, according to financial statements filed with the IRS. Coincidentally, Business Benefits made $500,000 in annual commission for its work. At those rates, Vellardita, who has made it clear that he wants the job, probably would increase his current salary as union executive director.

And the district-wide contract would bail out the Teachers Health Trust, which provides health insurance to 18,000 teachers and 19,000 dependents. The trust is losing millions of dollars each year and approaching bankruptcy, according to confidential financial documents obtained by the Review-Journal.

“He (Vellardita) has got his paws into this, and Cranor is Vellardita’s sidekick,” the union leader said. “She’s part of his inner circle.”

At the very least, Cranor is on good terms with the unions.

In her first run for a School Board seat in 2010, Cranor reported receiving a total of 37 campaign contributions. The two biggest accounted for more than a quarter of her total — $5,000 came from the teacher’s union, and $3,000 came from the Education Support Employees Association, another affiliate of the National Education Association. All three unions have endorsed her for re-election on Nov. 4.

RUN FOR THE MONEY

The Business Benefits lawsuit has roots dating to 2011, when former Superintendent Dwight Jones hired the company to negotiate a health plan for 22,000 support staff and their dependants covered by United Healthcare.

The strategy paid off: United Healthcare remained the provider, but Business Benefits was able to arrange much more favorable rates of $526 per employee, per month for the HMO. By comparison, less robust coverage costs City of Las Vegas employees $800 and district Teachers Health Trust members $900.

While teachers were paying far more for health coverage, their union leaders resisted the idea of dropping their self-managed trust and joining the district in one big plan.

But that changed in 2013, when union leadership changes increased Vellardita’s influence, even as economics made it much harder to go it alone.

Last year, the Teachers Health Trust posted an operating loss of $2.2 million. For the current year, the union projects a $3.9 million deficit as its $15.69 million in expenses are expected to exceed its $11.8 million in revenue.

The trust is self-funded, meaning it takes in premiums and directly pays claims.

In labor contract negotiations in mid-2013, Vellardita lobbied the district to drop United Healthcare and create a district-wide self-funded plan that he would administer, Edward Goldman, the district’s chief labor negotiator, said in a sworn deposition.

The school district’s response: Excluding United Healthcare was out of the question because it controls 75 percent of the market. Other companies have either declined to bid for the district’s business or were unwilling to offer more than a one-year contract because of the huge number of employees.

Goldman, who declined comment for this article, then testified that Vellardita said he should replace Business Benefits as the district’s broker with United Healthcare.

“He said that he could do the job himself, and he could do a better job because he had a lot of experience doing this,” Goldman said.

“I said ‘BBI is our broker, and you’re not going to dictate who our broker is,’ ” said Goldman, recalling that Vellardita emphasized his experience as a union leader in Oakland, Calif.

Vellardita was head of the long-term care division for United Healthcare Workers-West in Oakland until SEIU, its parent organization, sued him and 16 other leaders for unraveling the local after hearing that SEIU wanted to take it into trusteeship and replace them, in part because of financial improprieties. He was ordered to pay the largest share of damages at $77,850 shortly before he started work in Las Vegas.

THE ‘PUSHING FORCE’

As Vellardita was lobbying hard to take Business Benefit’s place as broker for a new district-wide health plan, Cranor without the knowledge of other School Board members started looking into Business Benefits and its president, Tim DeRosa.

Goldman said Cranor accused him of accepting kickbacks from DeRosa, and an attorney representing Business Benefits said in his deposition that Cranor in the fall of 2013 accused unspecified school district officials of taking bribes. The attorney asked the district to provide evidence of kickbacks, but it got none.

Cranor later dropped the allegation — Goldman wasn’t even involved in negotiating the Business Benefits contract — but didn’t give up.

According to minutes of a closed-door meeting on Sept. 23, 2013, Skorkowsky told the School Board that the support staff plan had a healthy surplus, but in prior years it had been millions in the red because of assumptions made by Business Benefits. The broker, he explained, thought more employees would sign up for low-cost coverage, but many initially took a higher-cost option.

“I will say, specifically, Trustee Cranor has been the pushing force for us delving into this deeper,” Skorkowsky told the board.

District Chief Financial Officer Jim McIntosh told the board that former Superintendent Dwight Jones, who had resigned four months earlier, directed Business Benefits to hide the deficit by using reserves to cover it.

Skorkowsky and other top administrators also criticized DeRosa for negotiating a higher commission from United Healthcare, starting in 2014.

The broker works for CCSD but gets no direct payment from the district. Instead, it is paid a half-percent commission by United Healthcare, or about $500,000 per year.

United Healthcare agreed to pay DeRosa 2.25 percent after he learned the company gave that rate to other brokers representing 500 or more covered employees, according to subpoenaed documents.

In a departure from past practice, United Healthcare Nevada CEO Don Giancursio told DeRosa that he needed the district’s written approval because the commission, now $2.5 million, would be rolled into premiums over the length of the two-year contract, according to his declaration in the lawsuit.

DeRosa’s attorney, former Clark County Commissioner Rory Reid, then asked the school district’s head attorney, Carlos McDade, for a written acknowledgement. McDade demurred.

“McDade suggested that would not be a good idea because someone, I don’t know who, had made Freedom of Information requests regarding these matters and that if they put that in writing, that it would be discoverable (by the public),” Reid said in his deposition. “He (McDade) acknowledged having seen the commission schedule and that it would be in the best interest of everyone to not have it in writing.”

In a lawsuit deposition, McDade said, “I might have said those words, but the problem is that there was no agreement as to how the commission was going to be paid.”

McDade asserted that Reid “always, always, always” told him the commission wasn’t paid from the district’s premiums.

In the weeks after the meeting, DeRosa asked Skorkowsky to let him meet board members to refute any allegations of wrongdoing. He refused.

And in October 2013, Cranor sent Skorkowsky an email:

“It appears there may be intent to continue to the current contract with the broker (Business Benefits), even though the contract is now known to be unfavorable to the district,” Cranor wrote. “The reason this is a concern is that it would seem to limit both our ability to sever the existing unfavorable contract and to limit our options going forward with a plan that includes the CCEA (teacher union) employee group.”

Failure to act now, she wrote, would delay movement to a unified health plan for years.

In November, Cranor loaded copies of documents and other research material she had collected on a thumb drive and delivered it to Skorkowsky, who was far more receptive than Jones had been. In contrast to Jones, Skorkowsky is on good terms with the unions and maintains an open door policy for Vellardita.

The district’s governance policy for board members states that “the president has no authority to supervise or direct the superintendent.” Doing that requires a majority vote of the School Board.

ABRUPT CANCELLATION

On Dec. 31, Skorkowsky abruptly notified Business Benefits that its contract, which would expire the next day, would not be renewed. The terse notice baffled Business Benefits. The contract actually required an automatic rollover on Jan. 1 unless a cancellation notice had been sent the prior June.

In his haste to dump Business Benefits, Skorkowsky risked a breach of contract lawsuit that could cost taxpayers more than $2 million, based on the 2.25 percent commission the company would have received.

Skorkowsky in a statement last week said he can’t reveal “details” of the decision to kill the contract because of the ongoing lawsuit but said the deal was not “serving the best interests of our taxpayers or our students.

“Trustee Cranor did not direct me to make this decision,” Skorkowsky wrote.

He did not address Cranor’s email, however, and would not take questions.

Cranor, in a separate statement last week, said she can’t reveal much because of the lawsuit.

“I can confirm that my actions last year were taken on the advice of the District Attorney’s office, upon which I relied for guidance and direction after discovering discrepancies in CCSD’s health benefits spending,” wrote Cranor, referencing the lawyer the Clark County district attorney’s office provides to give the board legal advice.

“I look forward to the resolution of this issue when the facts will come to light, and I hope the facts will be reported as aggressively as have been the speculation and conjecture so far.”

In his lawsuit deposition, Skorkowsky testified that he alone directed McDade to send the termination notice, without consulting anyone.

Yet Skorkowsky and McDade knew that dropping Business Benefits without full notice could cost taxpayers millions of dollars in litigation and had discussed it with School Board members, according to transcripts of the Sept. 23, 2013, closed-door meeting.

“We’re looking at possible damages and things like that if we did terminate …” McDade told board members, arguing that any lawsuit would probably be settled out of court.

As expected, Business Benefits sued the district in May. But in a rare move, Cranor was also named as an individual. The plaintiffs said she had stepped beyond her authority to undo the contract, and the lawsuit raised questions about the district’s communication with Vellardita in regard to Business Benefits.

At that point, it became imperative to get Cranor clear of the lawsuit, senior district officials familiar with the lawsuit told the Review-Journal.

In August, the district offered Business Benefits $100,100 to drop Cranor as an individual.

District officials sent the settlement check — stamped with Cranor’s signature as board president — on Sept. 12 without informing board members, who had expected to have a chance to vote on it. Board members were in the dark about the payment until they read an Oct. 15 Review-Journal article about it. District officials have said board approval wasn’t required despite a regulation mandating a vote on “total settlements” of more than $100,000.

While the settlement shields Cranor from the potential of being held personally liable for damages, it may have made things worse for her in other ways.

The district’s attempt to make the issue quietly go away has invigorated the low-key campaign of Joe Spencer, who is challenging Cranor in the November election.

Spencer has called on Cranor to resign and step out of the race and has filed a complaint against her with the state ethics board.

Cranor is no stranger to that board, which earlier this year settled another complaint after she acknowledged breaking campaign laws forbidding use of taxpayer money to push the district’s 2012 ballot question.

Nor has the lawsuit settlement dampened questions about why the district had to precipitously dump its broker rather than make a clean break after the agreed-upon six-month notice.

Why did it rush and risk millions?

The answer may lie in the fortunes of the Teachers Health Trust.

Vellardita has repeatedly denied the trust’s financial troubles and approaching insolvency, but financial statements make it clear. In September, Vellardita wrote that the teachers union is “taking proactive intervention measures to assist THT’s (the Teachers Health Trust) financial situation.” He said more changes will be needed in the future to “provide financial stability.”

“We’re bleeding pretty bad,” said a high-ranking union leader in reference to the trust, noting that teachers are complaining about late payments to their doctors.

Those money problems would disappear if the union were in charge of a district-wide health plan, both union leaders and district administrators told the Review-Journal.

ad-high_impact_4
News
Local man goes under cover searching for answers to homelessness
Licensed mental health therapist Sheldon Jacobs spent 48 hours under cover posing as a homeless man in an attempt to gain perspective on the complex issue.
Social Work UNLV Lecturer's Calling
Ivet Aldaba-Valera was the first person in her family to graduate from both high school and college. The 33-year-old UNLV lecturer is now pursuing her Ph. D in public policy at the school and has used her degree in social work to engage with the young Latino and Latina community of Las Vegas. (Madelyn Reese/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @MadelynGReese
The world's longest racetrack could be coming to Pahrump
Spring Mountain Motor Resort and Country Club in Pahrump might be the first racetrack in the world longer than 16 miles long once the expansion is complete. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @marcusvillagran
Gold Point townsperson talks about why he choose to live in a ghost town
Gold Point townsperson Walt Kremin talks about the ghost town in Nevada he calls home. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @marcusvillagran
Search for missing 3-year-old boy at Sunset Park
Las Vegas police and Red Rock Search and Rescue team search for a missing child at Sunset Park in southeast Las Vegas on Sunday, Sept.2, 2018. (Chitose Suzuki/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Nobel Peace Prize winner Malala Yousafzai speaks at Las Vegas tech conference
Nobel Peace Prize winner Malala Yousafzai, who was shot by the Taliban on her way home from school in Pakistan after advocating for girls' education, spoke at VMworld 2018 at Mandalay Bay. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
MGM Resorts International CEO Jim Murren addresses Oct. 1 lawsuits
MGM Resorts International Chairman and CEO Jim Murren addresses criticism his company has received for filing a lawsuit against the survivors of the Oct. 1 shooting. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Father recalls the night his 14-year-old son died jumping into moving traffic
From the Clark County Detention Center, Ezequiel Anorve Serrano talks about the night his 14-year-old son, Silas Anorve, died jumping into moving traffic on U.S. 95. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
Palace Station unveils new sports book
Palace Station talks about the new sports book Thursday, August 23, 2018. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
One of world's longest racetracks planned in Pahrump by 2020
The racetrack will be 16 miles long by the year 2020 according to Spring Mountain Motor Resort and Country Club owner John Morris. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
Henderson police bodycam footage of officer-involved shooting
Henderson police released body-worn camera footage of an officer-involved shooting in a grocery store parking lot at 2667 Windmill Parkway on Aug. 12, 2018. (Henderson Police Department)
Robotics takes off at Las Vegas Academy
Las Vegas Academy’s robotics team made it all the way to the world competition last year, the first year the team competed. Zackary Perry describes how they programmed their robot to compete. The team is an example of what Tesla wants to have in every school in the state. (Meghin Delaney/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Bicyclist suffers major head trauma in hit-and-run
A bicyclist was hospitalized with life-threatening injuries after a Thursday morning hit-and-run crash near the school formerly known as Agassi Prep. Police said the bicyclist was hit by a white SUV, which fled the scene. The injured man suffered multiple injuries including major head trauma. As of 9 a.m., Lake Mead remained closed between Martin Luther King and Revere Street while police investigate.
Las Vegas artist Dave Dave dies at 42
Dave Dave talks about his art and his life in 2016. (Michael Quine/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Dave Dave, whose dad set him on fire in 1983, dies
Dave Dave, a respected Las Vegas artist who was badly scarred as a boy when his father tried to burn him to death in Southern California, died at Sunrise Hospital on July 15. He was 42. When he was 6, Dave's father tried to kill him by setting him on fire. He was given a sleeping pill and his bed at a Buena Park, California, motel was doused with kerosene. “I remembered being in a lot of pain,” Dave told the Review-Journal in 2016. “When stuff happens to you at that young of an age, you tend to block it out, but I remember the pain was excruciating.” Dave, who was born David Rothenberg, became close friends with Michael Jackson, who met him after the attack, which burned more than 90 percent of his body. “I wanted to meet him, and he wanted to meet me, and that just turned into a lifelong relationship that never ended,” Dave said. “It was amazing being friends with Michael Jackson. He was an amazing person.” Dave attended ArtCenter College of Design in Pasadena, California, and collaborated with various artists around Las Vegas, eventually selling his art to private collectors. Despite his challenges, he continued to live, thrive and create. Dave Dave
Homicide detectives investigate woman's death
Las Vegas police were called to Tahiti Village Resort early Wednesday after calls that someone had been shot. Police found a woman’s body between a parking garage and boiler room on the resort's property. A guest first reported hearing gunfire. There are no witnesses, but police will examine surveillance videos and look for clues. The woman was not identified, but a purse was found near the body. She did not appear to be a guest at the resort.
LVMPD Discusses Ross Dress for Less Shooting
LVMPD Assistant Sheriff Charles Hank discussed the 15th officer-involved shooting of the year at a press conference at Metro headquarters on Tuesday, Aug. 14. The active-shooter incident took place at the Ross Dress for Less store at the 4000 block Blue Diamond Road in the south Las Vegas Valley. (Madelyn Reese/ Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Metro Asst. Sheriff Brett Zimmerman on Aug. 8 officer-involved shooting
Metropolitan Police Department Assistant Sheriff Brett Zimmerman met with media Monday to discuss the details of the 14th officer-involved shooting of the year. (Madelyn Reese/ Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Clark County School Board president Deanna Wright on travel expenses
Clark County School Board President Deanna Wright says she followed proper expense protocol in trip to Florida last year.
Matt Kelly Elementary School hosted its third annual Back-to-School Red Carpet Program
Matt Kelly Elementary School hosted its third annual Back-to-School Red Carpet Program where community and business leaders joined to welcome students back with an inspirational welcome. Bizuayehu Tesfaye/Las Vegas Review-Journal @bizutesfaye
Shooting leaves 1 dead in southeast valley
A man was found fatally shot in the doorway of a squatter apartment after an argument ended in gunfire on Sunday night. Officers responded about 10:30 p.m. to the Silver Pines apartments and discovered the man in a breezeway in one of the buildings. The wounded man died at the scene, despite the efforts of another person, who tried to administer medical aid. Witnesses saw a man and a woman flee the scene, but were unable to give police a clear description.
North Las Vegas unveils new school crosswalk
North Las Vegas councilman Isaac Barron talks about the new school crosswalk in front of CP Squires Elementary School Monday, August 6, 2018. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
LVMPD Briefing on OIS #13
Assistant Sheriff Tim Kelly held a press conference to discuss details of the 13th officer-involved-shoot for the department in 2018. Video shows the moments before the suspect was shot. The shooting, which has been edited out, occurred as the suspect lunged at an officer outside the apartment. (Madelyn Reese/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Sedan and semitrailer collide in south Las Vegas
An early Wednesday morning crash has left one person in critical condition. A sedan and semitrailer collided around 4 a.m. at the corner of Spencer Street and Serene Avenue. Police do not believe impairment is a factor in the crash. Spencer has been blocked off north of Serene while police continue their investigation.
Cybersecurity Professionals Flock to Las Vegas for Black Hat
Black Hat USA, the largest annual cybersecurity conference, is expecting a record 17,000 attendees during its six-day run at the Mandalay Bay Convention Center this week. One thing attendees have in mind is making sure they don't get hacked while they're there. (Madelyn Reese/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Police chase ends with suspects captured in east Las Vegas
An early Tuesday morning chase ended with a car crash in an east Las Vegas neighborhood. Police were pursuing the vehicle, which they say was involved in robberies in Las Vegas and North Las Vegas, when the driver crashed at Owens and Statz Street. A man was taken into custody. A woman was ejected from a vehicle and taken to a hospital with non-life threatening injuries. The intersection at Mojave Road and Owens Avenue was shut down while police officers searched for the suspect and investigated. The intersection will remain closed for most of the morning.
Record number participate in Touro University Nevada White Coat Ceremony
Three hundred sixty-five medical students received their white coats during the Touro University Nevada White Coat Ceremony at the M Resort in Henderson Monday. The ceremony was developed to honor students in osteopathic medicine, physician assistant studies, nursing, occupational therapy and physical therapy as they accept the professional responsibilities inherent in their relationship with patients. (K.M. Cannon/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Stop for school buses, urges CCSD
Clark County School District Police Department hold a mock traffic stop at Centennial High School in Las Vegas, Monday, Aug. 6, 2018. (Marcus Villagran/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @brokejournalist
Work Begins at Las Vegas Community Healing Garden
Crews moved the wooden Remembrance Wall at the Las Vegas Community Healing Garden on South Casino Center Boulevard Monday. Construction on a permanent wall is set to begin within the week. (Madelyn Reese/Las Vegas Review-Journal) @MadelynGReese
Man wounded outside Cottages apartment
Las Vegas police don't have a motive after a man was shot early Monday morning outside a northwest valley apartment. The man's mother called police to say her son had been shot. She called police around 1:15 a.m. Other people were inside the apartment but no one else was injured. Police are still looking for the shooter.
Crime
Vehicle of Interest in January Homicide
Las Vegas police released footage Friday of a “vehicle of interest” from a deadly shooting in January. (Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department)
Hostage escapes clutches of robber before shooting
Metropolitan Police Department footage shows a man wearing a motorcycle helmet, identified by police as 27-year-old Mario B. Trejo, with one arm wrapped around a woman’s neck and held a handgun to her head.
Sunset Park Vigil
A small group of people gathered in Sunset Park to remember the three children recently killed in the area.
Henderson police bodycam footage of officer-involved shooting
Henderson police released body-worn camera footage of an officer-involved shooting in a grocery store parking lot at 2667 Windmill Parkway on Aug. 12, 2018. (Henderson Police Department)
Metro Asst. Sheriff Brett Zimmerman on Aug. 8 officer-involved shooting
Metropolitan Police Department Assistant Sheriff Brett Zimmerman met with media Monday to discuss the details of the 14th officer-involved shooting of the year. (Madelyn Reese/ Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Nye County detectives pursue suspects
A swarm of Nye County deputies, at the request of Las Vegas police, surrounded a hotel room in Pahrump last week to take two fugitives into custody. (Nye County Sheriff's Office)
Las Vegas judge’s ruling will halt tonight’s execution
On Wednesday Judge Elizabeth Gonzalez issued a ruling that will halt the execution of convicted murderer Scott Dozier. Alvogen Inc., which makes the sedative midazolam, filed a lawsuit Tuesday accusing the Nevada Department of Corrections of surreptitiously obtaining the drug for use in an execution.
3 people shot in southeast Las Vegas
Three men were shot Thursday night in southeast Las Vegas, and two of them have life threatening injuries. Las Vegas police responded to the incident just after 10 p.m. on the 5000 block of Mountain Vista Street. The investigation is in its early stages and police were unable to describe the suspect or say how man people they think were involved. Police encourage anyone with information regarding this shooting to call Crime Stoppers at 702-385-5555, or 3-1-1
Robbery suspects apprehended
Four robbery suspects were taken into custody Thursday morning after a vehicle and foot chase that ended in an east Las Vegas neighborhood. The incident began when a person was robbed at gunpoint around 4:45 a.m. near Maryland Parkway and Desert Inn. Officers arriving at the scene tried to stop two vehicles. One vehicle escaped but police chased the second into a neighborhood on Flamingo Road near Mountain Vista Street. Police surrounded the neighborhood and the suspects were apprehended. It looked like one police vehicle was involved in a collision with the suspects' car. One woman suffered an unknown injury and was taken to the hospital in an ambulance. 01:04
Las Vegas police looking for robbery suspects
Two robbers who recently targeted three Las Vegas businesses remained at large Tuesday and police are asking the public to help identify them. (Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department)
TOP NEWS
News Headlines
Add Event
Home Front Page Footer Listing
Circular
You May Like

You May Like