weather icon Clear

NTSB issues report on deadly Grand Canyon helicopter crash

Updated February 21, 2018 - 10:41 pm

A sightseeing helicopter operated by a Boulder City-based tour company made at least two 360-degree turns before crashing in the Grand Canyon, according to a preliminary report released Wednesday.

The three-page report from the National Transportation Safety Board showed the aircraft, operated by Papillon Grand Canyon Helicopters, landed about 300 feet from the planned landing site near Quartermaster Canyon on tribal land in Arizona.

The Feb. 10 crash killed three British tourists and injured three more tourists and the pilot.

The helicopter spun toward the left twice, according to the report.

“That, to me, is the hallmark of a malfunctioning tail rotor,” longtime helicopter crash attorney Gary Robb said. Robb has litigated numerous cases involving tail rotor issues.

The main rotor on the Airbus Helicopters EC130 B4 is designed to spin clockwise, he said. “If you have tail rotor malfunction, then the helicopter will turn in the opposite direction of the main rotor rotation.”

Airbus Helicopters in a statement said it is too early to speculate about the cause of the crash, citing an ongoing investigation. The NTSB is not expected to issue a full report for more than a year.

Robb said a number of mechanical issues may cause a tail rotor to malfunction.

However, an issue with a tail rotor does not necessarily mean an equipment failure. In March, the NTSB released a safety warning to pilots alerting them to the dangers of a loss of tail rotor effectiveness, which can cause a helicopter to spin. Relative wind direction, flying near ridgelines and flying with high gross weights can cause helicopters to spin out of control, according to the NTSB.

Loss of tail rotor effectiveness “can occur in all single-engine, tail rotor-equipped helicopters at airspeeds lower than 30 knots and, if uncorrected, can cause the pilot to lose helicopter control, potentially resulting in serious injuries or death,” the alert reads.

The EC130 is a single-engine aircraft, according to Airbus Helicopters’ website. The preliminary report shows wind speeds were between 12 and 19 knots, or about 14 to 22 mph, at an observation site 2 miles from the accident. Police initially said the area saw gusts of up to 50 mph on the day of the crash.

The preliminary report does not indicate whether the helicopter was equipped with a crash-resistant fuel system required by a 1994 Federal Aviation Administration regulation.

A loophole in the regulation allows manufacturers to skirt this requirement if a newly manufactured helicopter has a certificate approved before 1994. The EC130 was based on another model that received certification in 1977.

Based on the photos and videos he has seen of the wreckage in media coverage, Robb said he does not believe the aircraft was equipped with the safer fuel system. Airbus has said the crash-resistant fuel system was not standard equipment on the model of helicopter that crashed.

A crash-resistant fuel system would not prevent a post-crash fire, Robb said, but it could provide the aircraft’s occupants an opportunity to escape.

A Papillon spokeswoman did not immediately return phone calls.

Contact Blake Apgar at bapgar@reviewjournal.com or 702-387-5298. Follow @blakeapgar on Twitter. Contact Madelyn Reese at mreese@reviewjournal.com or 702-383-0497. Follow @MadelynGReese on Twitter.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
‘It’s a painful Thanksgiving. You don’t even know, should you celebrate?’

The family is having their traditional meal of turkey, yams, green beans and rice and beans — butVivian Zayas is removing a seat from the table at her home in Deer Park, New York, this year and putting her mother’s walker in its place as a reminder of the loss.

Some Hawaiians embrace tourist-free state during pandemic

Locals, many of whom depend on tourism jobs, have long felt ambivalence about living in an island paradise that relies heavily on visitor spending, but many saw an upshot to a health crisis that threatened their livelihoods.

Arizona halts some transfers of patients from Nevada, other states

With Arizona hospitals admitting increasing numbers of COVID-19 patients, state health officials said Wednesday that they suspended some transfers of patients from other states.

California sees new high in coronavirus cases

California reported a record number of coronavirus cases Wednesday as Los Angeles restaurants prepared to close for three weeks.

Trump pardons former national security advisor Flynn

President Donald Trump pardoned former national security adviser Michael Flynn on Wednesday, taking direct aim at the Russia probe.

Spare change tweet generates big money for COVID aid

As sportswriter Andy Larsen was sorting his spare change — some from a childhood piggy bank shaped like SpongeBob SquarePants — it struck him: Other people in Utah could use the money more than he could.

Biden appeals for unity in Thanksgiving address

President-elect Joe Biden appealed for unity Wednesday in a Thanksgiving-eve address to the nation asking Americans to “steel our spines” for a fight against the coronavirus that he predicted would continue for months.

Mask up: Vaccine won’t end the US crisis right away

Despite the expected arrival of COVID-19 vaccines in just a few weeks, it could take several months — probably well into 2021 — before things get back to something close to normal in the U.S. and Americans can once again go to the movies, cheer at an NBA game or give Grandma a hug.