107°F
weather icon Clear

Using student test scores to rate teachers is fraught with problems.

Having taught for 32 years in an “inner city,” I can assure you that most, if not all, teachers who read this will agree: Methods of teacher evaluation are a joke. But not a very funny one.

Your front-page headline on Monday (“Is the way teachers are rated effective?”) caught my attention because unless you have spent a long time in the classroom, you would not know the incredible challenge of trying to reach all your students. Sitting in front of you are students who want to learn, those who don’t, those who can be reached and those who can’t. Add to those the very long list of students with special needs.

But beyond all that are the distractions of teaching. What do you think the students who don’t want to learn spend their time doing? In a college class for example, students are all there to learn, get a good grade and succeed. The rest of a class would not put up with disruptive behavior. Well, this is not the case in elementary and high schools, where students must be there.

According to the people who administer our education system, evaluations can be done only on performance. So let’s take the best coaches in the country and send them to the worst performing schools. Do you think those schools would improve? Eventually, but only because of recruitment. If the same players remained, those formerly best coaches would fail. UNLV football is a good example: Good coach; not top talent, as yet.

Why must we keep insisting that a teacher’s performance can be measured by their students’ performance? Tell you what: Let teachers choose their students. Then you can rate their performance.

MOST READ
Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
THE LATEST
LETTER: Remember the Bush plan?

What if we had invested a small portion of Social Security in the markets?

LETTER: Awfully generous to LVCVA chief

Does anyone really deserve a bonus of more than a quarter million dollars when they already make a half million in salary and have an expense account that most of us in the real world could never even imagine?

LETTER: Putting party first

Democrats in Nevada congressional delegation fail the test.

LETTER: It was a good run for democracy

As I watched the GOP members of Congress cheer the passage of their bill that will strip millions of health care, deny food to children and shred the Constitution, I felt sick to my stomach.

LETTER: An appreciation for America

July 4 was a special celebration of the United States’ birthday. I don’t recall ever seeing such an outpouring of recognition of our country’s origins and greatness.

MORE STORIES