weather icon Mostly Cloudy

In RJ survey, attorneys suggest ousting 6 Family Court judges

Clark County attorneys want to replace six Family Court judges, the most of any court reviewed in the 2019 Judicial Performance Evaluation sponsored by the Las Vegas Review-Journal.

Of the 20 sitting Family Court judges, 19 were evaluated. Rhonda Forsberg, who was appointed in April, was not included in the review.

Attorneys voted to replace Cheryl Moss and Sandra Pomrenze — repeats from the “do not retain” list in 2013, the last time the survey was conducted. Pomrenze received a 28 percent retention score, the lowest of the 89 judges reviewed this year.

The four other judges lawyers voted to remove are Lisa Brown, Mathew Harter, Rena Hughes and William Potter.

Attorneys returned polarizing retention scores for Family Court, with judges generally scoring either in the 40s or between 70 and 90 percent.

This, according to Rebecca Gill, the UNLV researcher and associate professor of political science who conducted the survey, is consistent with results of Family Court performance reviews across the country — in part, she said, because emotions run high in such courtrooms, and “very few people walk out of Family Court happy.”

“There are some unique characteristics of the nature of these cases and the nature of the job that it’s not surprising that Family Court judges tend to overall have lower scores, and they tend to have a larger variance of scores,” Gill said.

All Family Court judges are up for re-election next year in Clark County. Voters also can expect six new seats on the ballot, bringing the total number of Family Court judges to 26.

‘Fall from grace’

Of the judges who received a score of 50 percent or below, only Harter and Hughes agreed to give interviews.

Forty-eight percent of responding attorneys voted to retain Harter. On a five-point weighted scale, he received a 3.3 summary score for the individual questions regarding his performance.

Harter, sitting in his courtroom in late October, told the Review-Journal he was shocked to see that his retention score had “dropped so much,” from 71 percent in the 2013 review.

“How did I fall from grace?” Harter asked, adding that he intends to run for re-election.

The judge, who was first elected to Family Court in 2008 and made an unsuccessful bid last year for the state Supreme Court, has a theory: Steve Sanson, a controversial figure in Nevada politics, has waged an ongoing smear campaign against him that began as early as 2014.

Sanson, a longtime Family Court critic, is president of Veterans in Politics International, a local organization that says it “exposes corruption and unethical behaviors.” Sanson also is behind a Facebook page called “WAR Declared on Clark County Family Court System,” which posts videos of judges in their courtrooms, among other things.

Harter suspects Sanson used his connections in the Nevada political landscape to get attorneys who have never appeared before Harter, or have not recently appeared before him, to rate him poorly in the review.

Sanson, in response, told the Review-Journal: “Anybody could Google Harter’s name and find out what we’ve found on him, but did we go to attorneys and say, ‘Don’t vote for Judge Harter’? No, we absolutely did not do that. People make up their own minds based on the evidence we provide.”

Attorneys, in the anonymous comment portion of the review, described Harter as a “hit and miss” judge who “does everything he can to avoid coming in to Family Court on a daily basis.”

But Harter attributed those comments to his efficiency in the courtroom and timely decisions in cases.

“I run a very efficient, tight ship, and I require attorneys to be prepared. I follow the rules and know the law,” he said. “That is absolutely what I try to do, and it’s not so I can hurry and run home.”

Like Harter, Hughes hopes to retain her seat. She is nearing the end of her first term in Family Court. Forty-two percent of responding attorneys voted to retain her.

Forty-seven percent of the lawyers did not think that Hughes accurately applies the law. Attorneys also described her as “inconsistent” and “unpredictable.”

Hughes was publicly reprimanded last year by the Nevada Commission on Judicial Discipline. The commission ordered her to undergo further legal education after she improperly held a mother in contempt of court during a custody battle in 2016.

At the hearing, Hughes awarded a girl’s father temporary custody — an order that the commission found “was not primarily motivated by the best interest of the child” — and then threatened to send the crying girl to a shelter if she refused to go with her father.

In an interview with the newspaper, Hughes declined to talk specifically about that case but said, “In general terms, I took the commission’s order to heart.”

Hughes said she since has taken as many classes as she could, without neglecting her caseload, to help her with high-conflict custody cases.

“My focus and dedication is to uphold the laws of the state of Nevada and apply them fairly as it pertains to the best interest of the children, and I won’t be deterred from that,” she said.

Question of punctuality

Moss’ retention score dropped to 42 percent from 44 percent in 2013. She received her highest score of 65 percent in 2002, the first year she was evaluated.

Mirroring her 2013 results, Moss received her lowest score this year in the area of punctuality. Fifty-eight percent of 83 respondents said Moss failed at keeping her court calendar moving.

“Sometimes have to wait two hours or more to be heard,” one attorney said. Another said she “could not run her courtroom on time if her life depended on it.”

Nevada bar records show Moss has never been disciplined, but in 2005, attorney Randy Rumph, who was representing himself in a custody case, lodged a complaint against Moss to the Judicial Discipline Commission.

Rumph said the judge had given preferential treatment to lawyers who had donated to her campaigns, including his ex-wife’s lawyer. Two of her former law clerks signed affidavits supporting the allegation of favoritism.

The complaint was dismissed two years later, but the commission at the time told Rumph it had “taken what it considers to be appropriate action,” suggesting that Moss had been privately reprimanded.

Rumph said the commission refused to elaborate further.

Potter, who’s been on the bench for more than 13 years, dropped to a 44 percent retention score from 59 percent in 2013. The drop could be attributed to his two-month suspension without pay in late 2017 after he ordered a lawyer handcuffed in court and lashed out during his own disciplinary hearing. The Judicial Discipline Commission also ordered him to undergo a psychiatric evaluation.

Fifty-seven percent of 88 respondents this year thought Potter was rude. Anonymous comments described him as a “loose cannon” with a track record of yelling at attorneys and litigants.

One attorney expressed fear about going into his courtroom, adding that “there is no way to prepare a client for what may happen.”

Forty-seven percent of responding lawyers voted to keep Brown, and 47 percent do not believe Brown accurately applies the law.

One attorney commented that she “relies too much on her law clerk to make her decisions.” Another attorney believes “her law clerk prepares notes for her to reference.”

Brown served as a Family Court judge from 2000 to 2008, when she lost her bid for re-election, and returned to Family Court in 2014.

Respect for litigants

After his more than 10 years on the bench, lawyers still want Bryce Duckworth, the presiding judge, to stick around. And he plans on it, he said in an interview.

Duckworth was the highest-scoring judge all around in Family Court with a 92 percent retention score and a 4.5 summary score. He also received the highest retention score of any Family Court judge in 2011 and 2013.

So what’s working?

According to Duckworth, he carves out personal time to avoid “the burnout,” prepares for his cases and enters the courtroom with the mindset that each person appearing before him is “having their worst day ever.” That, he said, helps him maintain his composure and reminds him that every litigant deserves his respect.

“I recognize they’re going through a crisis,” he said. “It’s not always easy going through those emotions, and part of my function, I believe, is to try and help bring them back into focus of what truly is important.”

Because of that, he said, “even if they didn’t get the result they wanted, they feel like they still had their opportunity to present their case.”

Eighty-seven percent of responding lawyers voted to keep Frank Sullivan, who was first elected to Family Court in 2008.

When compared with the rest of the Family Court judges, not including Duckworth, Sullivan’s 4.3 summary score stands out.

Eighty-seven percent of lawyers, for example, agreed that Sullivan was free from racial or ethnic bias, and 84 percent thought he was courteous and respectful.

“You have to be kind and treat everybody with respect,” Sullivan told the Review-Journal. “We have to remember that we’re public servants, that we work for the people. You have to let people have their day in court.”

He will run again next year, he said.

Contact Rio Lacanlale at rlacanlale@reviewjournal.com or 702-383-0381. Follow @riolacanlale on Twitter.

Don't miss the big stories. Like us on Facebook.
Politics Videos
Joe Biden at the national hospitality workers union.
Democratic presidential candidate, former Vice President Joe Biden speaks to members of the national hospitality workers union during UNITE HERE's town hall on Wednesday, Dec. 11, 2019 at Culinary Union Hall in Las Vegas. @bizutesfaye
Elizabeth Warren at Culinary Union
Elizabeth Warren speaks at a Culinary Union town hall in Las Vegas on Dec. 9, 2019.
Secretary of Education visits Henderson school
Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos visited students at Pinecrest Academy in Henderson to talk about college planning on Dec. 4, 2019. (Erik Verduzco/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Trump dropped from Terry Fator’s show on Las Vegas Strip - VIDEO
Fator has edited out one prominent figure: President Donald Trump, a focal point of Fator’s regular stage show and also Christmas show over the past 3½ years. The Trump puppet, with his pop-up hairpiece, has been sidelined from both shows until further notice. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Accused murder mastermind Frank LaPena is granted a pardon - VIDEO
A onetime Las Vegas casino bell captain who spent 25 years in prison as the accused mastermind in a notorious 1974 contract murder won his last legal battle for freedom Wednesday when the state Pardons Board granted him a conditional pardon restoring all his civil rights. (James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
The Middle: Nonpartisan voters and the 2020 election
How will the growing segment of nonpartisan or independent voters — those who have not registered with either political party, or who have left partisan politics behind — vote in 2020?
Tomi Lahren Speaks at UNLV - VIDEO
Fox News contributor and UNLV alumna Tomi Lahren returned to campus Wednesday night for a speech, titled “Stay Triggered,” that drew an auditorium of supporters as well as a group of protesters outside. (James Schaeffer/Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Bernie Sanders released from Las Vegas hospital - VIDEO
Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., issues a statement after he was released from Desert Springs Hospital Medical Center on Friday, Oct. 4, 2019, after suffering a heart attack earlier in the week. (Bernie Sanders via Twitter)
Democratic presidential candidates speak on impeachment - VIDEO
Democratic presidential candidates attending the March for Our Lives/Giffords Gun Safety Forum in Las Vegas comment on possible impeachment proceedings. (Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Joe Biden Las Vegas Rally Highlights - VIDEO
2020 presidential candidate, Joe Biden, came to Las Vegas to talk guns, climate change and the Ukranian-Trump scandal. Biden was interrupted by a protestor who sat amongst supporters at the rally and continued with his speech. (Angus Kelly & James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Joe Biden comments on Trump and his campaign efforts in Nevada - VIDEO
After an impeachment inquiry was opened on Donald Trump, Joe Biden talks with Review-Journal politics reporter Rory Appleton about Trump and his campaign in Nevada. (Angus Kelly & James Schaeffer / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Trump announces trade agreement with China

On the same week the House Judiciary Committee voted to approve two articles of impeachment against him, President Donald Trump announced trade deals with Mexico and Canada, and a preliminary agreement with China. The announcement served as a bookend to Monday’s news that the White House had reached on a deal with House Democrats over the USMCA trade agreement with Mexico and Canada.

DCCC ads defend Lee, Horsford on drug bill

The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee is airing ads that defend Reps. Susie Lee and Steven Horsford from Republican attacks by citing their work on a bill to lower prescription drug costs.